The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle
The Carton Show with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle is sports talk with a pulse — loud, loose and unapologetically entertaining. Carton’s larger-than-life style and McMonigle’s no-nonsense perspective create a show that blends comedy, controversy and real debate. From Yankees and Mets drama to Giants, Jets, Knicks, Nets and whatever headline is dominating the day, nothing is too serious to laugh at or too big to challenge. Unfiltered and unpredictable, The Carton Show turns sports talk into an event.
Episodes
Is it time to PANIC about the Yankees?? | 'Go Get 'Em'
The Yankees losing streak has reached seven games after a brutal extra-inning loss to the Tigers, getting swept by Detroit at home for the first time since 2008. Chris McMonigle is FED UP with the Yanks woes, as he sounds off on the listless offense, Camilo Doval's implosion, the continued struggles of key players like Cody Bellinger in need of stepping up in Aaron Judge's absence, and how much of
Full Show: Analyzing the Yankees Seven-Game Slide and LeBron to the Knicks
Craig and Big Matt examine the Yankees' struggles as they endure a seven-game losing streak, questioning the job security of Aaron Boone. They dive into a hypothetical NBA landscape where LeBron James considers a move to the Knicks while the Celtics and Sixers pull off a massive trade. The conversation turns festive with a debate over July 4th traditions, featuring a guest appearance from Chris Ch
Hour 1: Could LeBron James Join the Knicks for One Last Title Run?
Craig and Big Matt debate the possibility of LeBron James signing with New York for a veteran minimum contract to chase one final championship. They also analyze the New York Yankees' seven-game losing streak and address the mystery surrounding Mitchell Robinson's injury history following his departure to the Celtics.
01:20 - Yankees Seven Game Skid
05:00 - Yankees Hitting Struggles
10:05 - LeBro
Hour 2: Carton and C-Mac Debate the Yankee Standard and LeBron to the Knicks
Craig Carton and C-Mac evaluate the state of the New York Yankees and whether the franchise's championship standard has slipped in recent years. They also explore the possibility of LeBron James joining the Knicks for a veteran minimum deal and argue over the necessity of apple pie on Independence Day.
01:20 - Lionel Richie Concert Grudge
05:45 - July Fourth Party Etiquette
10:50 - The Great Pie
Hour 3: Should Aaron Judge Lead the Yankees from the Dugout?
Craig and Evan debate Aaron Judge's public comments about the Yankees' lack of focus during a losing streak while he remains sidelined with an injury. They also discuss NBA trade rumors, the history of hot dog recipes, and an experiment involving indestructible Oreos.
02:25 - Disney Dads and Reading
04:53 - Judge Questions Team Focus
10:40 - Meaning of Sports Accountability
15:30 - Yankees Trade
Hour 4: Chris Christie Clashes Over Apple Pie & Knicks LeBron Rumors
Governor Chris Christie joins to share his holiday plans and critique the crew's 4th of July dessert choices. He offers his take on the Knicks' chemistry and the potential arrival of LeBron James. The segment concludes with a chaotic round of the Wednesday Wheel featuring trivia on founding fathers and ringless athletes.
01:20 - Wedding Talk and Topics
04:41 - Chris Christie Joins
08:24 - State F
Craig Carton GOES OFF on Celtics' SHOCKING Trade & Says He's DONE Eating Oreos!
One segment... two unbelievable takes. 😂
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the NBA's wild offseason, including the Celtics' stunning decision to trade Jaylen Brown and how it impacts the defending champion Knicks' quest to repeat.
Then the conversation takes a hilarious turn as Craig reveals why he's officially sworn off Oreos forever after watching one viral video. Plus, fireworks, Four
Craig Carton GOES OFF on Yankees Fans: "These AREN'T the Dark Days!"
With the Bronx Bombers in the middle of a brutal losing streak, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle tackle the biggest question in New York: Has the Yankees standard really fallen?
Carton pushes back on the outrage, arguing that despite the frustration, the Yankees are still one of baseball's winningest franchises and that calling this era "the dark days" is an insult to what real losing looks like.
Yankees Trade Strategy & The Great Pop-Tart Rivalry
Craig and C-Max evaluate the New York Yankees' roster gaps and trade deadline priorities as the team faces a critical stretch against divisional rivals. They also explore the competitive history of iconic food brands like Boar's Head and the origin story of the Pop-Tart. The segment features an anecdote about Jerry Seinfeld calling into the station to discuss his film, Unfrosted.
01:00 - Yankees
Craig Carton SHOCKS Knicks Fans: "I'd Take LeBron James!"
Craig and Chris McMonigle debate whether New York should put decades of LeBron hate aside for one more championship run. Would LeBron coming off the bench make the Knicks unstoppable? Would the circus be worth it? And would Knicks fans actually give him a standing ovation at Madison Square Garden?
"It's July 4th, Buddy. It's Apple Pie": A Heated Dessert Debate
A spirited debate breaks out over the necessity of apple pie on the Fourth of July and whether rejecting holiday traditions is considered un-American. The conversation shifts to favorite hot dog brands before critiquing wealthy celebrities like Michael Jordan and Brad Pitt for taking on unnecessary product endorsements.
01:00 - Ray Charles Musical Energy
02:11 - July 4th Pie Debate
04:05 - Holida
Craig Carton STUNS Knicks Fans: Should They Sign LeBron James After Winning the NBA Title?!
On WFAN's The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether the defending champion Knicks should actually consider signing LeBron James if he's willing to take a veteran minimum deal. Is it the perfect move for another title run, or would it turn New York into the LeBron farewell tour?
Yankees Fans Want Boone FIRED?! Craig Carton & C-Mac Say Not So Fast...
On this episode of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether Aaron Boone deserves to be fired or if fans are overreacting to one brutal week of baseball. They discuss the Yankees' offensive collapse, defensive mistakes, injuries piling up, and why Boone has historically been able to pull the team out of these midseason swoons.
Full Show: Big Mac Rages Over Yankee Collapse as Mitchell Robinson joins Celtics
Craig Carton and Big Mac react to the shocking news of Mitchell Robinson joining the Boston Celtics and the Yankees' devastating seven-game losing streak. They evaluate Steve Cohen's decision to guarantee David Stearns' job security despite the Mets' struggles and a rumored blockbuster trade involving Jaylen Brown. The discussion captures the outrage surrounding New York's professional teams durin
Hour 1: Yankees Hit Seven-Game Skid as Mitchell Robinson Heads to Boston
Craig and Big Mac react to the Yankees’ seven-game losing streak and the team's struggles to execute in critical late-inning moments. They also discuss Mitchell Robinson signing with the Boston Celtics and Steve Cohen’s public defense of David Stearns' long-term plan for the Mets.
01:23 - Mitchell Robinson Knicks Exit
05:52 - Defining A Yankee Swoon
12:52 - Steve Cohen Podcast Interview
16:54 - F
Hour 2: Big Mac Blasts Yankees' Skid and Blockbuster NBA Trade
Big Mac analyzes the breaking news of Jaylen Brown's trade to the Philadelphia 76ers for Paul George. He also expresses frustration over the New York Yankees' seven-game losing streak, criticizing Anthony Volpe's decision-making and the team's offensive struggles.
01:00 - Jaylen Brown Trade News
05:18 - Volpe Bunt Decision Critique
10:58 - Analyzing Yankees Summer Swoons
17:47 - Volpe vs Caballer
The Carton Show TORCHES Steve Cohen: “He Just Told Mets Fans He Doesn’t Care What You Think!”
Chris McMonigle and Craig debate whether Cohen's commitment to Stearns is smart ownership or completely tone-deaf, especially with the Mets sitting near the bottom of the National League and reportedly preparing to sell at the trade deadline.
Aaron Boone's BIGGEST Mistake Yet?!
The Yankees' losing streak just keeps getting worse, and Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle are asking one question: What was Aaron Boone thinking?!
Steve Cohen FINALLY Admits the Mets Had a Lindor-Soto Problem
On WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Mets owner's podcast appearance where he confirmed there was tension between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto during the 2025 season. Cohen also made it clear that David Stearns will remain the Mets' President of Baseball Operations through his full five-year plan, even as the team spirals.
Yankees Have OFFICIALLY Hit Rock Bottom
The New York Yankees have officially entered a full-blown June swoon after dropping their 7th straight game, and Chris McMonigle has had enough. From blown opportunities to Aaron Boone's decisions, Cody Bellinger's struggles, and another frustrating extra-inning loss, Craig Carton and Big Mac break down everything that's gone wrong in the Bronx.
Plus, Mitchell Robinson leaves the Knicks to sign w
Full Show: Darryl Strawberry Defends Mets Rebuild & Rebukes Media Bashing
Darryl Strawberry joins the program to share his perspective on the Mets' rebuilding phase and the need for a respected manager like Carlos Beltran or Albert Pujols. They also analyze the Yankees' five-game skid, LeBron James' departure from Los Angeles, and a significant Supreme Court ruling on transgender athletes.
01:50 - Yankees June Swoon
05:45 - Rice Offensive Struggles
11:40 - Postseason L
Hour 1: Yankees "June Swoon" & SCOTUS Trans Athlete Ruling
The Yankees' recent losing streak sparks a heated debate over whether the team is entering a "June swoon" amidst significant injuries to stars like Aaron Judge. Discussion shifts to a recent Supreme Court ruling on trans athletes in sports and the impressive dedication shown by Jalen Brunson to the Knicks. They also examine LeBron James' potential Lakers exit and the ongoing organizational silence
Hour 2: LeBron’s LA Failure & Why Shohei Ohtani Needs to Play the Field
Craigie and Big Mac analyze LeBron James' departure from the Lakers, labeling his tenure a disappointment despite the bubble championship. They also debate Shohei Ohtani's historical greatness, questioning if a player can be the best ever without playing the field. Finally, they quiz a local intern on classic pop culture and discuss the intricacies of athlete hair transplants.
01:20 - LeBron Leav
Hour 3: Artist Debate on "Going Back to Cali" and Yankees Injury Concerns
They discuss the results of a listener poll regarding whether LL Cool J or Biggie Smalls is most associated with the song "Going Back to Cali" before pivoting to the New York Yankees' recent struggles. The conversation covers Aaron Judge's rehab progress and the pressure on younger players like Ben Rice and Cam Schlittler to fill the void. Callers also weigh in on the New York Mets' season and loc
Hour 4: Darryl Strawberry Defends the Rebuilding Mets and David Stearns
Craigie and Big Mac analyze the latest "LOL Mets" moments, including an embarrassing outfield misplay and an on-deck circle injury. Mets legend Darryl Strawberry joins the program to preach patience during the rebuild and discusses the leadership vacuum within the clubhouse.
01:22 - Juan Soto's Outfield Blunder
06:40 - Fans React To Struggles
11:05 - Mauricio Hits Francisco Alvarez
16:45 - Soccer
Craig Carton TORCHES the Mets: "They're an EMBARRASSMENT!"
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to another embarrassing Mets loss, Juan Soto's disastrous defensive play, the growing questions surrounding the clubhouse, Lindor's visible frustration, Bo Bichette's emotional return to Toronto, and why this team is looking more like a Little League squad than a playoff contender.
Yankees in a FULL-BLOWN June Swoon? Carton Sounds the Alarm on Judge & Ben Rice!
The Yankees have dropped five straight, the offense has disappeared, and now Aaron Judge's injury timeline is raising even more concerns. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether this is officially a "June swoon," why Ben Rice and Cam Schlittler must carry the team, and what Judge's latest rehab update means for the Yankees' playoff hopes.
Craig Carton's Heartwarming Call With Young Mets Fan Will Make You Smile
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle take a call from 19-year-old Anthony, a passionate Mets fan who refuses to give up on his team despite a disappointing season. What starts as a baseball conversation turns into a heartfelt discussion about family, the 2015 World Series, grandma's famous meatballs, and why sports mean so much to fans of all ages.
Craig Carton & Big Mac EXPLODE Over Biggie vs. LL Cool J Debate!
Who owns "Going Back to Cali"- LL Cool J or The Notorious B.I.G.? Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle turn a simple music question into an all-out debate, complete with a live listener poll that delivers a surprising result! Then the conversation goes completely off the rails with a rapid-fire trivia game featuring songs named after cities and states, hilarious intern struggles, and an unexpected NBA
Craig Carton ROASTS John Cena's Hair Transplant & Big Mac's Hat
From Big Mac's controversial hat getting compared to Spike Lee and LL Cool J, to Craig's brutally honest thoughts on going bald, comb-overs, and John Cena's hair transplant, the laughs don't stop. The conversation even spirals into classic TV shows, Beatles trivia with the interns, and whether Shohei Ohtani deserves to win the Cy Young Award.
Is LeBron James a Top 10 Laker and Does Shohei Ohtani Need a Glove?
Craigy and Big Mac debate the legitimacy of LeBron James' tenure with the Los Angeles Lakers and rank the greatest players in franchise history. They also discuss Shohei Ohtani's historic season and whether a player can be considered the greatest of all time without playing the field.
01:33 - Mitchell Robinson Update
02:15 - LeBron Laker Legacy
11:48 - Top Ten Lakers List
21:30 - Shohei Ohtani De
Craig and C-Mac Debate Yankees Slump and Transgender Athlete Rulings
Craig and C-Mac examine the New York Yankees' recent five-game slide and debate whether the fan base is overreacting compared to previous New York Knicks struggles. They also discuss the Supreme Court's ruling on transgender athletes in sports and clarify soccer rules with Anthony Gallo.
01:00 - Soccer Shootouts and Josh Hart
03:05 - Gallo Explains Soccer Rules
07:09 - Yankees Slump vs Knicks
13:
The Yankees Are COLLAPSING, Is the June Swoon Official?
Are the Yankees officially in a June swoon? Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether New York's five-game skid is just a rough stretch or the beginning of something much worse. With Aaron Judge still out, Ben Rice and Cody Bellinger struggling, and the offense completely disappearing, Craig says the Yankees "stink right now" while Big Mac isn't ready to panic just yet.
Best of the Yankees on WFAN: Is it time to panic about the Yankees' June swoon?
Following a historically brutal weekend in Boston, we break down the Yankees' alarming offensive collapse and Aaron Boone's baffling post-game reaction. Plus, we look ahead to the trade deadline and debate whether it's finally time for Brian Cashman to go all-in.
Yankees EMBARRASSED in worst loss of the season | 'Go Get 'Em'
Chris McMonigle is NOT happy after the Yankees lost what he declared the worst loss of the season to finish the worst series of the season. C-Mac sounds off on the scuffling offense, as Ben Rice and Cody Bellinger have contributed NOTHING of late, which is hurting the team while Aaron Judge is hurt (4:45). C-Mac also took exception to Jazz Chisholm leaving the clubhouse and not speaking to reporte
Wally Backman Tells Carton and Big Mac He Can Fix the Mets
Carton and Big Mac analyze Steve Cohen’s controversial behavior and his perceived disconnect from the Mets' fan base. Former Mets second baseman Wally Backman joins the studio to discuss his desire to manage the team and improve clubhouse accountability. They also examine the Yankees' recent sweep by the Red Sox and break down the news of Landry Shamet’s new contract with the Knicks.
01:50 - Stev
Carton Slams Steve Cohen’s ‘Brain Dead’ Response to Mets Fans
Craig Carton and Big Mac react to the New York Mets' free fall and owner Steve Cohen’s social media interactions with frustrated fans. They examine Eric Chavez’s insights into clubhouse dynamics and debate the New York Yankees' struggles after a sweep in Boston. The conversation also features a touching call from an 89-year-old die-hard fan and a critique of Emmanuel Acho’s take on Caitlin Clark.
Wally Backman Critiques Mets Struggles and Juan Soto's Couch Routine
Former Met Wally Backman joins the studio to discuss his new role with the Staten Island FerryHawks and offers his blunt assessment of the current Mets clubhouse culture. They also delve into a Knicks season ticket holder's legal battle and analyze Eric Chavez's revealing comments about Juan Soto's behavior during his time with the team.
01:55 - Summer Playlists
04:50 - Knicks Ticket Rights
13:15
Hour 3: Could Wally Backman Save the Mets? Plus Yankees' Fenway Meltdown
Craig and Big Mac debate if Wally Backman's old-school fire is what the Mets need while exploring the potential for Steve Cohen to sell the team. They react to the Yankees being swept in Boston and evaluate growing concerns regarding Gerrit Cole and Jazz Chisholm Jr. Additionally, they cover NBA news including Malik Beasley's indictment and Landry Shamet's contract with the Knicks.
01:20 - Wally
Hour 4: Defending Aaron Boone’s Post-Sweep "Embrace the Grind" Comments
Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze Aaron Boone's polarizing postgame remarks following the Yankees' sweep by the Red Sox, debating whether his optimistic leadership style is effective. They also examine the skepticism surrounding Steve Cohen's ownership of the Mets, specifically regarding his casino plans and his public handling of stadium incidents. Finally, they compare the Mets' historical champi
The Mets' Future Looks SCARY
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the latest Steve Cohen controversy and explain why many Mets fans feel the owner has become increasingly disconnected from the fanbase.
Yankees Fans Are OVERREACTING?! Carton & Big Mac Fire Back
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the ugly series, discuss whether Aaron Boone deserves the criticism, question Jazz Chisholm's recent behavior, and explain why injuries—not a complete collapse—are driving the Yankees' struggles.
The guys also react to the Malik Beasley gambling indictment, discuss Steve Cohen's future with the Mets, and celebrate the Knicks bringing Landry Shamet back
BREAKING: Ja Morant Traded & The Mets' Next Manager Debate!
The Mets' managerial search is officially underway, and Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate who should replace Carlos Mendoza.
Would Mets fans embrace Wally Backman, or should the organization pursue baseball legends like Albert Pujols, Carlos Beltrán, or David Ross? The guys discuss which candidate has the credibility to change the culture and reconnect with a frustrated fanbase.
Plus, the
The Mets Are DEAD And Carton Thinks Steve Cohen Should Walk Away
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the New York Mets' disastrous season and debate whether owner Steve Cohen has become part of the problem. After discussing Wally Backman as a potential manager, the conversation turns into a heated debate over Carlos Mendoza, David Stearns, Cohen's social media presence, rising Citi Field prices, and whether the billionaire owner should actually consider s
Wally Backman TORCHES the Mets: "Today's Players Are SOFT!"
Backman opens up about why he still wants to manage the New York Mets, what he believes is wrong with today's team, why chemistry wins championships, and how he'd handle stars like Juan Soto. He also shares incredible stories from the legendary 1986 Mets, Davey Johnson, clubhouse culture, old-school baseball, and why he'd take the Mets manager's job for FREE.
Breaking Down the Knicks' Season Ticket Resale Controversy
Big Mac & Craig addresses a longtime Knicks season ticket holder's frustration after having his membership revoked for reselling tickets on the secondary market. He also explores Eric Chavez's critical comments regarding the New York Mets' leadership and clubhouse dynamics.
01:00 - Don Toliver Ticket Giveaway
02:01 - Summer Vacation Playlists
03:57 - Knicks Ticket Revocation Debate
12:02 - Eric C
89-Year-Old Mets Fan BREAKS Craig Carton’s Heart Live on WFAN
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle take a heartfelt call from an 89-year-old lifelong Mets fan who has lived through the highs and lows of New York baseball—from the Brooklyn Dodgers leaving town to the Miracle Mets of 1969. The emotional conversation turns into one of the most memorable moments on WFAN as Craig asks whether he'll ever see another Mets championship.
The guys also continue reacting
Craig Carton ERUPTS on Steve Cohen After Mets' Latest Disaster!
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Yankees getting swept by the Red Sox, falling out of first place, and the growing concerns surrounding their postseason hopes. But according to Craig, the Mets somehow managed to have an even WORSE weekend.
From Steve Cohen's controversial comments and fan backlash to the firing of Carlos Mendoza, Juan Soto clubhouse drama, and why Craig believes Cohe
Best of the Yankees on WFAN: Trade for Skubal?
Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash debate if the Yankees should pursue Tarik Skubal at the trade deadline. Plus, reaction to Jazz Chisholm's "lollipop-gate" and his heroics the next day; Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on why fans should back off Anthony Volpe; Boomer & Gio give their thoughts on Chisholm, too.
Best of the Mets on WFAN: It's over
This week was NOT short on Mets rants, as Boomer and Gio sounded off on how poorly the team has played this season, with Boomer comparing these Mets to Phil Jackson's Knicks. Plus, Evan Roberts ripped the team for being "awful," and called on Steve Cohen to speak about the state of the franchise. Craig Carton did the same, while he and Chris McMonigle broke down the embarrassment the front office
Best of the Knicks on WFAN: Draft debate and Becky Hammon faces the music
The Knicks traded (a lot) during the NBA Draft, and we had all the reactions to what Leon Rose is up to this week. Plus, Becky Hammon addressed her comments about Jalen Brunson not being a 1A, leading to Evan Roberts sounding off on why that one sound bite will never go away. Plus, Boomer and Gio react to Julius Randle returning to New York...this time as a member of the rival Nets.
Best of the Mets on WFAN: Carlos Mendoza fired
News broke Friday morning of the Mets firing manager Carlos Mendoza, and we had all the instant reactions, including Evan sounding off on the move being "too little, too late," Craig Carton applauding Steve Cohen for making the decision, and guesses on who will manage the team in 2027.
Full Show: Mets Fire Carlos Mendoza as Stearns Takes Responsibility for Collapse
Craig Carton and Pete Hoffman analyze the New York Mets' decision to fire manager Carlos Mendoza following a string of embarrassing losses. They provide live coverage of David Stearns' press conference and speak with Todd Zeile, Terry Collins, and Paul Virzi about the team's future.
01:50 - Carlos Mendoza Fired
10:01 - David Stearns Blame
13:50 - Aubrey Huff Feud
21:50 - Mendoza Farewell Statemen
Hour 1: Carton Applauds Steve Cohen for Firing Carlos Mendoza
Craig Carton reacts to the New York Mets firing manager Carlos Mendoza, arguing that the move was an act of mercy by owner Steve Cohen. He discusses why the blame now shifts entirely to David Stearns and considers whether a fiery personality like Wally Backman should lead the clubhouse. The conversation also touches on Carton's social media feud with Aubrey Huff and the general lack of accountabil
Hour 2: David Stearns Fires Carlos Mendoza as Mets' Nightmare Season Spirals
David Stearns holds an emotional press conference following the firing of manager Carlos Mendoza, taking full responsibility for the roster's failure and the worst Mets start since 2003. They are joined by comedian Paul Virzi to discuss the fallout, the Knicks' championship run, and the challenges of coaching in New York.
01:20 - Stearns Addresses Mendoza Firing
04:52 - Stearns Denies Stepping As
Hour 3: Is Jaxson Dart the Next Joe Burrow? Plus Todd Zeile on Mets Firing
Paul Virzi joins the program to explain why Jaxson Dart has the makeup of a franchise quarterback like Joe Burrow. They also discuss the celebrity fandom surrounding the Knicks before Todd Zeile breaks down the firing of Carlos Mendoza and the accountability of David Stearns.
01:20 - Jaxson Dart Comparison
04:45 - Famous Knicks Fans
08:32 - Mets Firing Reaction
13:40 - Weight Loss Journey
19:20 -
Hour 4: Terry Collins on Carlos Mendoza Firing and the Mets' Future
Terry Collins joins the program to share his perspective on the New York Mets firing manager Carlos Mendoza and the team's overall lack of competitiveness. He and Craig discuss the nuances of locker room accountability and the importance of fundamentals in the major leagues. The conversation also covers the New York Knicks' roster moves, including Jose Alvarado's contract and the future of Karl-An
Knicks Re-Sign Jose Alvarado and Cookie's Take on the Mets Firing
Cookie and Pete Hoffman break down the New York Knicks re-signing Jose Alvarado and the financial logistics of keeping Mitchell Robinson on the roster. They examine the fallout from the New York Mets firing Carlos Mendoza and brainstorm ways to keep fans engaged at Citi Field on WFAN. The duo also reacts to a caller's huge gambling win and critiques staff attendance during major news days.
01:54
Episode 33: Yankees make ALL the errors in ugly loss at Fenway | 'Go Get 'Em'
Chris McMonigle reacts to an ugly showing from the Yankee defense, making four errors in a series-opening loss in Boston, where Cam Schlittler gave up four runs, none of them earned. He sounded off on the growing Austin Wells problem, even if the nightmare fifth inning wasn't all his fault. C-Mac wonders if the defensive alignment is weakening the team in the field as Aaron Boone tries to get his
"Carlos Mendoza Wasn't the Problem!" Terry Collins Calls Out the Mets
Former Mets manager Terry Collins joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN to react to Carlos Mendoza's firing and doesn't hold back. Collins explains why managers have to demand accountability, why today's Mets need to get back to baseball fundamentals, and why he still believes this team has enough talent to turn things around.
Comedian Paul Virzi Talks Jaxson Dart's Stardom, Upcoming Tour, and Callers Vent About Mets
Craig Carton & Comedian Paul Virzi talk about his new found friendship with Jaxson Dart, his upcoming tour, and they take calls on the Mets firing of Carlos Mendoza.
Todd Zeile BLASTS Mets Front Office After Carlos Mendoza Fired
Carlos Mendoza is OUT as Mets manager, but was he really the problem? Todd Zeile joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN to deliver a powerful defense of Mendoza, saying he was sent into battle with "no weapons" and that the front office deserves far more blame. Zeile also questions David Stearns' roster construction, discusses Steve Cohen's role in the firing, and reveals what really happe
Comedian Paul Virzi Discusses How the Knicks Changed His Life, Carlos Mendoza's Firing
Friend of the Carton Show comedian Paul Virzi joins Craig to catch up on life including how the Knicks changed the way he viewed the world and how he views the Mets firing of Carlos Mendoza through a Yankees fans lens.
Craig Demands David Stearns Take Responsibility for the Mets Mess
Craig and Petey react to the firing of Carlos Mendoza and the need for David Stearns to take ownership of the team's struggles. They explore the lack of accountability within the roster before shifting gears to discuss a unique summer drink recipe.
01:00 - Harvard's Influence on Stearns
03:17 - Demanding Mets Accountability
09:28 - Watermelon Espresso Drink Recipe
Could Wally Backman Be the Fiery Leader the Mets Need?
Craig Carton reviews Carlos Mendoza's departure statement and critiques David Stearns' performance as general manager. He considers the case for Wally Backman as a potential manager who could bring much-needed toughness to the organization. Additionally, the conversation touches on the fan experience at Citi Field and the hurdles of finding a viable replacement for Stearns.
01:00 - Mendoza's Fare
METS FIRE CARLOS MENDOZA! Craig Carton Says Steve Cohen FINALLY Did the Right Thing
Carton explains why Steve Cohen actually did Mendoza a favor, shifts the blame squarely onto David Stearns, questions the future of the Mets organization, and breaks down what happens next with Andy Green taking over as interim manager.
Did Jazz Chisholm Get The Message? | 'The Bret Boone Podcast'
Bret Boone joins the guys at 97.3 The Fan in San Diego to give his perspective on one of the hottest topics in Baseball - as his Brother and Yankees Manager, Aaron Boone, had to straighten one of his stars out after a questionable decision.
Jasson Dominguez powers Yankees past Skubal in series win | 'Go Get 'Em'
Chris McMonigle breaks down a big series win for the Yankees, including a thrilling win in the series finale against Tarik Skubal. C-Mac raves about the season that Paul Goldschmidt is having, how the former MVP looks like his prime self, and the Yankees can only hope he keeps up this pace, especially while Giancarlo Stanton is out (7:58). Plus, reactions to that huge home run from Jasson Domingue
Full Show: Mets Fans Revolt Over Pete Alonso Chants and Stearns’ Failures
Carton and Big Mac dissect the New York Mets’ historic defensive failure and the fan base's growing frustration with President of Baseball Operations David Stearns. They discuss the significance of the Pete Alonso chants and evaluate the team's trade assets as the season slips away. Additional topics include Nike's marketing of Victor Wembanyama and controversial rumors surrounding Hollywood legen
Hour 1: Mets Hit Rock Bottom: Fans Chant for Alonso After 6-Error Disaster
Craig and Big Mac vent about the New York Mets' embarrassing doubleheader loss, focusing on a historically bad six-error performance and the subsequent fan revolt. They discuss the viral Pete Alonso chant, criticize the front office's roster construction, and debate if a leadership change is necessary to salvage the franchise's culture.
01:45 - Mets Hit Rock Bottom
05:02 - The Pete Alonso Decisio
Hour 2: Craig Carton Blasts Nike's "Embarrassing" Victor Wembanyama Shoe
Craig Carton reacts to his daughter's decision to attend a Mets game despite the team's ongoing struggles and recent blowout losses. They also debate a caller's claim that older fans may never see another Mets championship before discussing the Knicks revoking season tickets for playoff resales. Finally, the conversation turns to Nike's new Victor Wembanyama sneakers and a rumor about Jamie Lee Cu
Hour 3: NY Mets Irrelevance, Clubhouse Leadership & Plaxico Burress' Return
They evaluate the New York Mets' current irrelevance compared to the long-standing standard of the New York Yankees. The conversation touches on the leadership vacuum in the Mets' clubhouse following Steve Cohen's comments on team captains. They also preview an upcoming show featuring Plaxico Burress and Paul Virzi while debating viral social media trends and personal anecdotes.
01:50 - Mets Irre
Hour 4: Craig Slams David Stearns Over Mets' Roster Failures
Craig slams David Stearns over his roster construction as the Mets struggle with mounting defensive errors and failed reclamation projects. They highlight the massive run differential gap between the Yankees and the rest of the American League while discussing Paul Goldschmidt's MVP-level resurgence. The conversation also touches on past front office scandals and upcoming guests Paul Virzi and Pla
THE COHEN CASUALTY! Craig Carton and Big Mac Declare the 2026 Mets SEASON OVER
It is June 25, 2026, and the New York Mets are officially a $370 million disaster zone. Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle pull no punches as they declare the Mets completely irrelevant before the summer even gets rolling.
HE'S CHANGED! Craig Carton Calls Out Big Mac’s Massive Ego Over Yankee Stadium Prank!
When Craig Carton suggests his co-host Chris McMonigle should throw out the first pitch at Yankee Stadium, things take a hilarious turn! Craig claims the fame is going straight to Chris's head, leading to an impromptu studio acting challenge to see how a "normal person" would actually react to the offer. Watch the chaos unfold as the Hoff, the intern, and an entirely clueless Gallo get dragged int
Plaxico Burress Guest Hosting and Marilyn Manson Urban Legends
Craig and Pete preview Plaxico Burress' upcoming guest appearance before diving into bizarre urban legends like the Marilyn Manson rib rumor. The conversation shifts to a viral video involving a JP Morgan executive and a heated debate over The Beatles' discography. They also discuss the Mets' bleak future compared to the 1990 Yankees and upcoming vacation plans.
01:00 - Plaxico Burress Guest Host
Nike Just TROLLED Knicks Fans?! Craig Carton LOSES IT Over Wemby's New Shoe
Craig Carton goes OFF after Nike unveils a Statue of Liberty-themed sneaker for Victor Wembanyama featuring "You're Welcome" in English and French. Carton sees it as a slap in the face to Knicks fans after New York's NBA Finals victory, while Chris McMonigle thinks the shoe is actually hilarious because Wemby just lost to the Knicks.
Knicks Fans Are FURIOUS! Season Ticket Holder BANNED After Selling NBA Finals Tickets?!
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a longtime Knicks season ticket holder who says the team revoked his tickets after he sold his NBA Finals seats. Is the organization cracking down on ticket resellers, or is this unfair to loyal fans who've supported the team for decades?
Craig Carton Demands Wally Backman Replace Carlos Mendoza
The Carton Show and several callers vent about the New York Mets' embarrassing performance and growing fan apathy following a six-error game. They discuss the potential firing of manager Carlos Mendoza and whether Wally Backman or David Stearns can fix the franchise's clown show culture.
01:00 - Mets Fan Apathy
04:39 - Hiring Wally Backman
08:34 - David Stearns' Future
13:48 - Jeff Wilpon's React
METS FANS TURN ON STEARNS! The Pete Alonso Revenge Game Is Going To Be BRUTAL
After a disastrous Mets collapse, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the fan who started the viral "Pete Alonso" chant and explain why September could become a full-blown nightmare for David Stearns and the Mets front office.
Will Mets fans give Alonso a hero's welcome when he returns to Citi Field with Baltimore? Could it become the loudest anti-management statement in franchise history?
Recommended
Saints‘ Hill Church Podcast
The Arab Film Club Podcast
AI Fire Daily
The Fifteenth Page Show | AI Systems, Marketing Tips, andContent Marketing Strategy for Busy Teams
Intrigue Outloud
The Daily
Doctor Zhivago Slow Read
Conspiracy Files with Paige Carter
This Past Weekend w/ Theo Von
The Theory of Psychoanalysis - Carl Jung
A Life Engineered
پادکست بهزاد بلور | Behzad Bolour's Podcast
