Home Podcasts True Crime Recaps
True Crime Recaps

True Crime Recaps

Unknown 334 Episodes Oct 14, 2026

Hosts Chris Nathan and Amy Townsend recap the most gripping true crime cases, from infamous serial killers to headline-making mysteries. They provide thorough research and smart commentary in a format that covers all the crime in half the time.

Episodes

Christa Pike’s Execution Failed. Could Tennessee Try Again?
Christa Pike’s Execution Failed. Could Tennessee Try Again? Oct 14, 2026 1004 In 1995, 18-year-old Christa Pike and her 17-year-old boyfriend Tadaryl Shipp were involved in the brutal killing of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer. Both were later convicted of first-degree murder and conspiracy, but their sentences sent them down very different paths. Christa was sentenced to death, while Tadaryl received life with the possibility of parole. More than 30 years later, Tennessee att
Police Had His DNA for 36 Years. They Just Didn’t Know His Name
Police Had His DNA for 36 Years. They Just Didn’t Know His Name Oct 13, 2026 1804 In August 1990, 22-year-old Cheryl Henry and 21-year-old Andy Atkinson drove out to a secluded Houston area known as "Lovers Lane." They were never seen alive again. When a security guard found their abandoned white Honda with the keys still in the ignition, search dogs were brought in to scour the nearby woods. What they discovered was a horrific and incredibly bizarre crime scene involving defla
Nolan Wells: No Charges, But His Death Remains Undetermined
Nolan Wells: No Charges, But His Death Remains Undetermined Oct 10, 2026 628 18-year-old Nolan Wells disappeared during a Fourth of July boat outing on Horn Island, Mississippi. Two days later, his body was found in the water. After reviewing testimony from 43 witnesses, phone records, GPS data, videos and forensic evidence, a grand jury declined to indict anyone, finding no credible evidence that a crime had been committed. The circumstances were considered consistent wi
Amanda de Oliveira: The Woman Who Pretended to Be a Child
Amanda de Oliveira: The Woman Who Pretended to Be a Child Oct 8, 2026 1120 For 14 months, a family in Brazil believed they were caring for a 12-year-old girl named Gabriele. They gave her a bedroom, bought her clothes, celebrated her birthday and even considered adopting her. But Gabriele was actually Amanda Maria Souza de Oliveira, a woman approaching her 38th birthday. And it wasn't the first time Amanda had assumed the identity of a child. Over more than a decade
Caleb Flynn: From American Idol to a Murder Conviction
Caleb Flynn: From American Idol to a Murder Conviction Oct 6, 2026 1717 In 2013, Caleb Flynn appeared on American Idol, encouraged by his wife, Ashley. Thirteen years later, he was on trial for her death. Investigators uncovered a secret relationship, more than 100,000 messages, a staged break-in and digital evidence that challenged Caleb’s account of what happened inside their Ohio home. Just hours before Ashley was killed, he sent a message saying: “I choose you. I
Raymond Horsch and the Investigation Into Seven Missing Women
Raymond Horsch and the Investigation Into Seven Missing Women Oct 3, 2026 1179 Police investigating Philadelphia artist and filmmaker Raymond Horsch are examining an enormous collection of digital material as they try to determine whether his disturbing fictional work may have connections to real missing women. The investigation began after Horsch’s son, Eugene, was arrested following an encounter involving identification belonging to a missing woman. A subsequent search of
Laura Owens: The Pregnancy Claims That Ended in Felony Charges
Laura Owens: The Pregnancy Claims That Ended in Felony Charges Oct 1, 2026 1012 In 2023, former Bachelor star Clayton Echard became involved in a highly publicized paternity dispute after Laura Owens claimed she was pregnant with twins following an intimate encounter between them. Echard disputed the pregnancy and requested DNA testing. As the case moved through family court, questions emerged about the pregnancy evidence Owens had provided and whether the paternity proceedi
Jeanne Clery: The Case That Changed Campus Safety in America
Jeanne Clery: The Case That Changed Campus Safety in America Sep 29, 2026 707 In 1986, 19-year-old Jeanne Clery was a student at Lehigh University when another student gained access to her dormitory through security doors that had been propped open. Joseph Henry was later convicted in connection with Jeanne's death, but for her parents, Howard and Connie Clery, the case exposed much bigger questions about campus security and what colleges were required to tell students abo
Her Family Tracked Her Jeep With an AirTag and Uncovered a Crime
Her Family Tracked Her Jeep With an AirTag and Uncovered a Crime Sep 26, 2026 994 In August 2026, 18 year old Karoline Heintz had dinner with her family before heading back to college. The freshman soccer player was studying at PennWest California with hopes of becoming a doctor. But when she suddenly stopped responding to calls and messages, her family began searching for her. An AirTag inside Karoline’s Jeep eventually helped her family locate the vehicle near a library. Aft
Martha McKay: The Snowden Estate Case That Spanned 24 Years
Martha McKay: The Snowden Estate Case That Spanned 24 Years Sep 24, 2026 773 In 1996, a fire at the historic Snowden Mansion in Arkansas led investigators to discover that Sally Snowden McKay and her nephew, musician Joseph “Lee” Baker, had died before the fire began. The investigation soon focused on 16-year-old Travis Lewis, who lived on the same estate with his family. Lewis eventually pleaded guilty to two counts of capital murder and was sentenced to prison. But the
Three Missing Child Cases That Changed America
Three Missing Child Cases That Changed America Sep 22, 2026 3280 Three disappearances. Three families searching for answers. And three cases that became part of the history of missing child investigations in America. In this extended episode of True Crime Recaps, we revisit the cases of Johnny Gosch, Etan Patz and the Lyon sisters, bringing together our previous coverage with new narration and case updates. Johnny Gosch disappeared while delivering newspapers
Janet Dennis: The Investigation That Led Back to the Family Ranch
Janet Dennis: The Investigation That Led Back to the Family Ranch Sep 19, 2026 1395 Janet Dennis was a devoted school nurse and mother who disappeared shortly before Christmas. Her vehicle was later found at an airport with Christmas presents for her children still inside, leaving investigators trying to understand where she had gone and what had happened. Early attention focused elsewhere, but the investigation changed direction when information emerged about activity at the sp

Recommended