Least of These

254. “A Safe Place” - The Case of Morgan Bauer - Newton County, Georgia - [Part 1] Oct 8, 2026 2323 $20, a tax return, and a fresh new start. Morgan Bauer was 19 years old when she left her hometown of Aberdeen, South Dakota, dreaming of starting a new life in Atlanta. But within weeks of arriving in Georgia, Morgan vanished. As the search for Morgan began, investigators were led to 19-year-old Katelyn Goble and 26-year-old Jonathan “Alex” Warren. The stories they told about Morgan’s final hours

253. “Two Men, Two Paths” - The Case of Donald Bowers - Lebanon, Indiana Oct 1, 2026 1113 A fall, A blanket, and a confession that shocked everyone.In September of 2025, two witness came forward to report a possible homicide. Police found 64-year-old Donald “Donnie” Bowers was murdered inside his home. 37-year-old Jacob Cram was quickly identified as the suspect. When Cram sat down to talk to police, it became evident that what happened inside Donnie’s home was more horrific than anyon

252. "Fugitive" - The Case of Theresa Green - Orlando, Florida - [Part 2 of 2] Sep 24, 2026 2520 Two trials, two medical examiners, and two different opinions.DeMorris Hunter was tried for the murder of two different women in two separate states.Ivora “Ivory” Huntley in Oakland, California and Theresa Ann Green in Orlando, Florida. After decades of committing violent crimes, would Hunter’s reign of terror finally come to an end? SOURCES:Long-awaited 2002 Central Florida Murder Trial Starts Mo

251. “Fugitive” - The Case of Ivora “Ivory” Huntley - Oakland, California - [ Part 1 of 2] Sep 10, 2026 1489 A twice convicted murderer, an alias, and a fugitive on the run. In 2002, Ivora “Ivory” Huntley was murdered in Oakland, California after stepping in to protect a friend from an abusive boyfriend. The man accused of killing her, DeMorris Hunter, disappeared. Months later and nearly 3,000 miles away, another woman was murdered.As investigators began piecing together the connections between the two

250. "The House Party" - The Case of Alexis Camry Scott - Peoria, Illinois Sep 3, 2026 1314 A kidnapping, sex trafficking, and a house party. In September of 2017, 20-year-old Alexis Camry Scott disappeared from Peoria, Illinois. Weeks earlier, Alexis had returned home from a trip to Las Vegas claiming she had been kidnapped and sex trafficked. After her disappearance, investigators uncovered conflicting accounts surrounding a house party, surveillance footage that didn’t match witness s

249. “Culpable” - The Case of Rena Nguyen - Orem, Utah Aug 27, 2026 1952 A tumultuous relationship, a single gunshot, and a secret recording. On October 1st, 2021, 20-year-old Rena Nguyen was found dead from a single gunshot wound in the upstairs bedroom of her boyfriend, Caleb Rees’ home. Rena’s death was initially ruled a suicide. While it was true, that Rena had pulled the trigger, three years later, a secret recording was discovered that changed the entire course o

248. “Soap Opera” - The Case of Diane Wolf - Hanover, Pennsylvania Aug 13, 2026 1407 A missing woman, a hotel card, and a fax number. On January 29th, 1999, 45-year-old Diane Wolf vanished after a shift at Hanover Foods. She was last captured on surveillance video making a $300 deposit at the drive through ATM at Allfirst Bank. Her 1994 teal Pontiac Grand Prix was later found at Weis Market. As investigators re-examined the case a decade later, new clues surfaced. Perhaps Diane’s

247. “Ten Minutes of Violence” - The Case of Julian Wood - North Olmsted, Ohio - [Part 3 - The Defense & Verdict - FINAL] Aug 6, 2026 3064 El Chapo, a bowl of ants and a unanimous verdict.On June 3rd, 2024, 38-year-old Margot Wood and her son, Julian, stopped at the Giant Eagle in North Olmsted, Ohio, to pick up groceries. As Margot pushed Julian in the shopping cart to her silver minivan, the mother and son were attacked by a woman wielding a knife. Three-year-old Julian was killed. 32-year-old, Bionca Ellis had a history of mental

246. “Ten Minutes of Violence” - The Case of Julian Wood - North Olmsted, Ohio - [Part 2 - The Prosecution] Jul 30, 2026 1812 Multiple witnesses, heartbreaking testimony, and questions of sanity. On June 3rd, 2024, 38-year-old Margot Wood and her son, Julian, stopped at the Giant Eagle in North Olmsted, Ohio, to pick up groceries. As Margot pushed Julian in the shopping cart to her silver minivan, the mother and son were attacked by a woman wielding a knife. Three-year-old Julian was killed. 32-year-old, Bionca Ellis had

245. "Ten Minutes" - The Case of Julian Wood - North Olmsted, Ohio - [Part 1] Jul 23, 2026 1653 A shopping trip, two knives, and questions of competency. On June 3rd, 2024, 38-year-old Margot Wood and her son, Julian, stopped at the Giant Eagle in North Olmsted, Ohio, to pick up groceries. As Margot pushed Julian in the shopping cart to her silver minivan, the mother and son were attacked by a woman wielding a knife. Three-year-old Julian was killed. 32-year-old, Bionca Ellis had a history o

244. "Dead Man Talking" - The Case of Nicholas (Alahverdian) Rossi - [Part 2 - FINAL] Jul 16, 2026 1997 An extradition, two trials, and a second death. In a Scottish courtroom, authorities try to prove that Arthur Knight is actually Nicholas Alahverdian Rossi.After his extradition to the United States, Rossi faces justice in two Utah courtrooms.Just when authorities think they’ve heard it all, more victims come forward. SOURCES:Statement on the Death of Nicholas Rossi - District Attorney | Salt Lake

243. “Dead Man Talking” - The Case of Nicholas (Alahverdian) Rossi - [Part 1] Jul 9, 2026 1678 Arthur Knight, distinctive tattoos and a burial at sea.In 2021 a patient named Arthur Knight was admitted to Queen Elizabeth’s Hospital in Glasgow, Scotland. Healthcare workers noticed that his tattoos were strikingly similar to an American born man wanted for rape charges out of Utah. That man was Nicholas (Alahverdian) Rossi. When the man in the hospital was awake and conscious, he claimed he wa

242. “I’m Gonna Die” - The Case of Grace Ryan - Arvada, Colorado Jul 2, 2026 1595 173 empty bottles, text messages, and an iPad on the floor. On March 9th, 2026, 55-year-old Gretchen Ryan called 911 to report that she had found her 16-year-old daughter Grace unresponsive on the bathroom floor. First responders arrived and Grace Ryan was pronounced deceased at the scene. Investigators found empty bottles of alcohol hidden throughout the teenage girl’s room. At first her mother c

241. “Behind Closed Doors” The Case of Raechyl & Jayla Blackshear - Anchorage, Alaska Jun 25, 2026 1985 An allegation, a double murder, and a gold chain necklace. In April of 2022 concerned family members requested a welfare check at the home of 35-year-old Raechyl Blackshear. Weeks earlier Raechyl had brought her 14-year-old daughter, Jayla to the Anchorage Police Department. Jayla told officials she had been sexually assaulted by a male family member. When the family began receiving text messages

“A Justified Homicide” - The Case of Aaron Spencer - Lonoke County - CASE DISMISSED [Final Update] Jun 18, 2026 2912 The second degree murder case against Aaron Spencer has been dismissed. Here’s my complete coverage of the case, with the update at the end. You can skip to around 38 minutes for update. SOURCES:Interview with Erin Cassinelli and Aaron Spencer - Arkansas Democrat Gazette https://youtu.be/YFtfVVzZk6MJudge dismisses criminal charges against Aaron Spencer, the dad who killed daughter’s alleged moles

239. “Murder by Parole” - The Case of Susan Leyden - Brooklyn, New York - [Part 3 FINAL] Jun 11, 2026 2035 A trip to the 99 cent store, a saw, and the state’s star witness. After murdering Jacquelin Bonds in 1963 and Ana Laura Sierra in 1985, Harvey Marcelin was paroled again. Soon after his release he became obsessed with a woman he seemingly met at a women’s shelter. Two years after being set free, Harvey Marcelin was charged with the murder of 68-year-old Susan Leyden. SOURCES:Senior serial killer H

238. "Murder by Parole" - The Case of Ana Laura Sierra - Manhattan, New York - [Part 2] Jun 4, 2026 1369 A wannabe pimp, a shopping cart, and a bag of body parts. After the murder of Jacqeline Bonds in 1963, after receiving a life sentence, Harvey Marcelin was released on lifetime parole. About a year after his release, a man walking in Central Park discovered a bag of dismembered remains. The victim was later identified as 29-year-old Ana Laura Sierra. Marcelin plead guilty to manslaughter. But once

237. “Murder by Parole” - The Case of Jacqueline Bonds - Manhattan, New York - [Part 1] May 28, 2026 1715 Allegations, an alibi witness, and a lifetime sentence.On April 18th, 1963, 21-year-old Jacqueline Bonds was supposed to testify in front of the grand jury as an alibi witness for a first-degree rape case.She had been subpoenaed by the defendant, 24-year-old Harvey Marcelin.But Jacqueline didn’t show up for court that day. Hours later she was shot to death in her Manhattan Apartment. SOURCES:Senio

236. "Monroe’s Little Angel" - The Case of Nevaeh Buchanan - Monroe, Michigan May 21, 2026 3582 A scooter, a changing story, and so many sex offenders.On May 24th, 2009, five-year-old, Nevaeh Buchanan vanished from her Charlotte Arms Apartment complex.Days later her body was found near the River Raisin.From the very start, police were looking into several persons of interest, most of whom, were associated with her mother, Jennifer Buchanan.SOURCES: Autopsy Results Show Nevaeh Buchanan May Ha

MURDERED: Carla Walker with Crime with Holly Apr 23, 2026 3690 Due to a family emergency, I’m taking this week off. But Holly with Crime with Holly is here to fill in with the story of Carla Walker.In 1974, 17-year-old Carla Jan Walker was abducted from a parking lot in Fort Worth, Texas after a night out with her boyfriend.Her murder shocked the community and left investigators with more questions than answers. For decades, the case went cold… and suspicion

235. “Call for Help” - The Case of Denise Lee - North Port, Florida - [Part 2 FINAL] Apr 16, 2026 2009 Another witness, another 911 call, and a two-hour deliberation.The murder trial for 36-year-old Michael King began in August of 2008. Prosecutors presented overwhelming evidence against King, much of it recovered due to Denise Lee’s heroic actions. It only took two hours for the jury to return their verdict.In the years after Denise’s murder countless lives have been saved through the Denise Ambe

234. "Call for Help” - The Case of Denise Lee - North Port, Florida - [Part 1] Apr 9, 2026 2736 A series of 911 calls, a green Camaro, and a missed opportunity.In January of 2008, 21-year-old Denise Lee was abducted from her home in North Port, Florida.As the crime unfolded a series of 911 calls were placed, one by Denise herself. Covertly she told the operator that she had been abducted from her home on Latour Avenue. Another witness called to report a kidnapping in progress but a deputy wa

The William 'Jake' Embert Act - An Urgent Request Apr 3, 2026 432 In 2014 Jake Embert was murdered at the hands of his new wife. His death was initially ruled a suicide after police spent less than an hour "investigating" at the scene.Jake's family pushed for answers.A decade and three trials later, Jake Embert finally got justice.Now, his family is fighting for justice for other families of victims of violent crime with the William 'Jake' Em

[Vigil] - Mary's Voice - The Case of Mary Collins - Charlotte, North Carolina Mar 26, 2026 7797 March 28th, 2025, marks six years since Mary Collins was brutally murdered at the hands of people she trusted.In those six years, only one of the four perpetrators, Kelly Lavery, has been convicted. Lavi Pham, James Salerno, and America Diehl are still awaiting trial.America Diehl is currently free on bond.Every year from March 28th - April 5th Mary's family holds an online candlelight vigil m

233. “Murder on the Mahned” - The Case of William Hatcher, Robbie Bond, & Michael Lee - Petal, Mississippi - [Part 3 - FINAL] Mar 19, 2026 2521 Trial delays, conflicting stories, and post conviction relief.After the 1995 murders of William Hatcher, Robbie Bond and Michael Lee, the cases began to make their way to trial.Kenneth Moody placed the blame on his 14-year-old cousin, David.But David Moody pointed the finger right back at Kenneth. SOURCES:https://www.deseret.com/2001/9/17/19607010/murderer-cuts-his-way-out-of-mississippi-jail/Mood

232. “Murder on Mahned Bridge” - The Case of William Hatcher, Robbie Bond & Michael Lee - [Part 2] Mar 12, 2026 1966 A necklace, a puddle of blood, and criminal cousins. In May of 1995 co-workers and friends 21-year-old Robbie Bond and 27-year-old William Hatcher went out to the Mahned Bridge to look at the stars. William’s vehicle was later found abandoned on the bridge. Days later 14-year-old David Moody would come forward and confess that he and his 20-year-old cousin, Kenneth Moody had murdered Robbie and Wi

231. "Murder on Mahned Bridge" - The Case of Angela Freeman - Petal, Mississippi Feb 12, 2026 1695 A puddle of blood, missing keys, and a note.In September of 1993, 17-year-old Angela Freeman vanished in Petal, Mississippi. All she left behind was a note, telling her friend that she was going to the local Pizza Hut to talk to her ex-boyfriend. Her 1984 Honda Accord was later found abandoned near the Mahned Bridge.Angela Freeman remains missing to this day.If you have any information about the d

230. “Monster in the Swamp” - The Case of Quatisha and Shandelle Maycock - Miami-Dade, Florida Feb 5, 2026 2894 A phone call, Alligator Alley, and an overturned ruling.On November 7th of 1998, motorists in south Florida saw a young woman, beaten, bleeding, stumbling, and barely able to signal for help on the side of the highway. She was severely wounded and covered in bug bites. She was 22-year-old Shandelle Maycock. When police arrived, Shandelle told them that she had been kidnapped, attacked and left for

229. "Footprints in the Snow" - The Case of Steven Kraft II - Benton Harbor, Michigan Jan 29, 2026 1584 Two dogs, an icy pond, and a lack of clues.On February 15th of 2001, 12-year-old Steven Kraft II left his home on Holly Drive in his Benton Heights neighborhood. He was headed over to a friend’s house. When Steven didn’t return, an all-out search was launched. There were few clues as to where the 12-year-old could have gone. All that was left were some footprints in the snow. Where is Steven Earl

228. “A Night Out” - The Case of Pamela Cabriales - Denver, Colorado Jan 23, 2026 1750 A shooting at the drive-through, a fender bender, and the floor of a shed. On February 20th, 2021, 32-year-old Pamela Cabriales was on her way home after a night out with a friend. After a minor fender bender at Colfax Avenue and I-25, a male exited the passenger side of the vehicle and shot into Pamela’s car, killing her. Police later apprehended 14-year-old Remi Cordova, 18-year-old Neshan Johns

227. “The Three Amigos” - The Case of Qaunique Robinson, Danesha Sims, and Wynshay Roddey - Lawtey, Florida Jan 15, 2026 1438 A 911 hang up, knives, and a locked bedroom door.In the early morning hours of March 12th, 2024, police were dispatched to a home in Lawtey, Florida after a 911 hang up call.When officers arrived, they found 46-year-old Johnnie Brown outside with a laceration to his arm.As officers spoke to Brown, an 11-year-old girl ran outside and told police that her grandmother and two of her aunts were dead.

226. "Alexa, Call 911" - The Case of Doctor Christopher Osborn - Dublin, Ohio Jan 8, 2026 3061 A doctor, a nurse, and a strained relationship. On July 18th of 2018 a 911 call came into the Dublin County Emergency Dispatch. On the line was a man in another county reporting that a deceased person had been found in an upscale home on Ennishannon Drive. When officers arrived, they found 50-year-old physician, Doctor Christopher Osborn dead from multiple gunshot wounds. The only other person in

Jordan DeMay's Story and the Dangers of Sextortion with Crime with Holly Jan 1, 2026 2902 In this episode of Crime with Holly, Holly speaks with Jenn Buta, mother of Jordan DeMay, a 17-year-old who tragically took his life on March 25, 2022, after being targeted in a financial sextortion scheme.This crime is rapidly growing, the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children received over 26,000 reports in 2023, with most victims being teen boys between 14 and 17 years old. But g

The Answering Machine Message: The Unsolved Murder of Jennifer Clemmings with A Simpler Time True Crime Dec 18, 2025 2966 A beautiful and vivacious 32-year-old woman had hit a sweet-spot of success in her life. She was a high-ranking sales consultant for the beauty company Mary Kay and on pace to be one of the top ranks in the company. But one evening in 2003, all of her momentum would be halted when her life was snuffed out by a violent sexual predator. When she realized she was in danger, she heroically placed a co

Vanessa Ladouceur - With A Million Other Choices Dec 11, 2025 3546 On March 18, 2022, 30-year-old fitness instructor Vanessa Ladouceur was just steps from her downtown Calgary workplace when she was brutally attacked by a stranger—broad daylight, a regular morning, people everywhere.Want A Million Other Choices in your life?Listen on Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/a-million-other-choices/id1579267886Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3RdPyinzu3D

225. “Missing in Manitoba” - The Case of Amber McFarland - Portage La Prairie, Manitoba - Canada Dec 4, 2025 1523 A night out, two missed shifts, and the Cat & Fiddle.On October 18th, 2008, 24-year-old Amber McFarland vanished after a night out with her friends. She was last seen in the company of her ex-boyfriend, Kelly Garrioch and another man.Kelly Garrioch says Amber called someone for a ride home from his home on Yellowquill Trail, but is that the truth?Where is Amber McFarland? If you have any info

Missing In Hush Town - Season Two - Bethany Markowski - Prologue Nov 27, 2025 749 Happy Thanksgiving, ya'll. I took this week off but am bringing you a special episode. Jules Thorpe is here with Season Two of Missing in Hush Town!Fifteen years after her 11-year-old Bethany Markowski vanished without a trace, her mother - Jonnie Carter’s phone rings. The number is one she knows all too well - the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation’s Missing Children’s Unit. Every call bring

224. “Clandestine Operation” The Case of the Skelton Brothers - Morenci, Michigan [Part 2 of 2] Nov 20, 2025 3053 A baseball, Mose Gingrich, and a pre-programmed cellphone.After the disappearances of nine-year-old Andrew, seven-year-old Alexander, and five-year-old Tanner Skelton, their father, 39-year-old John Skelton kept changing his story.After investigators proved that Joann Taylor didn’t exist, John kept changing his story, even from behind bars. Over a decade passed when the boys' mother, Tanya Zuv

223. “Clandestine Operation” The Case of the Skelton Brothers - Morenci, Michigan [Part 1] Nov 14, 2025 1983 Three missing boys, a noose, and a woman named Joann Taylor.In the fall of 2010, 43-year-old Tanya Skelton and 39-year-old John Skelton were going through a bitter divorce.Caught in the middle were their three boys: nine-year-old Andrew, seven-year-old Alexander, and five-year-old Tanner Skelton.Over the Thanksgiving Holiday while the boys were with John Skelton, they mysteriously vanished. John c

222. “Just Leave” - The Story of Latifa Brown - Saint Paul, Minnesota Nov 6, 2025 1955 An upstairs neighbor, a single gunshot, and two weapons. On January 22nd, 2022, police arrived at a duplex in the Twin Cities. Outside they found 31-year-old Latifa Brown deceased next to a minivan. Inside the home, police found Latifa’s longtime boyfriend, 35-year-old Mark Bell Junior and his friend. Bell and his friend told investigators a harrowing story, but an upstairs neighbor captured the c

MURDERED: Gail & Rick Brink with Crime with Holly Oct 30, 2025 3499 It was November 1987 when newlyweds Gail and Rick Brink’s promising future was suddenly stolen in the most brutal way imaginable. Found murdered at their Michigan home, the crime shook a quiet community and left investigators scrambling for answers. For decades the case remained unsolved and behind it all was a secret that someone thought was worth killing for.Listen to their story now!Want more C

221. “Brothers” - The Case of Tina Livernash Heins - Mayport, Florida Oct 23, 2025 2169 An open door, a “confession”, and a bloody fingerprint. On April 17th, 1994, 19-year-old Tina Livernash Heins was found brutally murdered in her apartment in Mayport, Florida. Tina was a newlywed and four months pregnant at the time. Her husband, Jeremy Heins was serving in the Navy and on duty on the USS Leyte Gulf the night his wife was murdered. That left Tina alone in the apartment with her br

220. “The Only Son” - The Case of Debra Fink - Kernersville, North Carolina Oct 16, 2025 1400 A busted door frame, a stolen gun, and gun shot residue. In June of 2023 police were called to the 500 block of Clubb Road in Kernersville, North Carolina for a report of a break-in and shooting. When officers arrived, they found 65-year-old Debbie Fink murdered in her own home. Her 25-year-old son, Donald Fink, told police someone had broken in and shot his mother, but there was far more to the s

219. "Pickin' Peaches" - The Case of Crystal Ann Tymich - Los Angeles, California Oct 9, 2025 1644 A summer afternoon, an ad in the paper, and a crawlspace.On June 30th, 1994, six-year-old Crystal Tymich was playing with her three older brothers in her neighborhood in Hyde Park, California. As the children made their way back home, Crystal vanished without a trace. After more than 30 years the mystery remains. Where is Crystal Ann Tymich? If you have any information about the disappearance of

218. "The Neighborhood Grandpa" - The Case of Kenneth Peterson - Phoenix, Arizona Sep 25, 2025 1534 A stolen truck, a welfare check, and a pawn shop. In the fall of 2022, family and friends called the Phoenix Police concerned about the welfare of 79-year-old veteran, Kenneth Peterson. After a month, police finally made entry into the home and made a grisly discovery. Kenneth had been murdered and his truck and two roommates, 54-year-old Ramona Gonzalez and 58-year-old Thomas Wallace were

The Battle for Our Children's Souls: A Message to My Listeners Sep 17, 2025 1573 The Assassination of Charlie Kirk, Minnesota State Representative Melissa Hortman and the stabbing of Iryna Zaretska. In light of recent events, I'm coming to you not with a case but a message from the heart. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices Our Sponsors:* Check out BetterHelp: https://www.betterhelp.comAdvertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/bra

217. “Marked with an X” - The Case of Sophie Reeder - Fort Lauderdale, Florida Sep 11, 2025 2067 An “X” on the calendar, a burning pink candle, and $300 in cash. On May 19th, 2017, 15-year-old Sophie Reeder left her home in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. She was never seen again. Initially Fort Lauderdale Police thought Sophie was just another teenage runaway. But cell phone records tracked Sophie to the home of 37-year-old Leonard “Jay” Jennings. Jennings and his family denied ever knowing Sop

216. "Heavy Metal" - The Case of the Brom Family - Rochester, Minnesota - [Part 2 of 2] Aug 21, 2025 1957 Two pleas, two verdicts, and a work release program. On February 18th, 1988, a welfare check led to the discovery of four bodies inside the Brom Home in Rochester, Minnesota. Bernard and Paulette Brom along with two of their four children, 13-year-old Diane and 11-year-old Ricky, had been murdered with an axe. Their 16-year-old son, David Brom, was charged in their murders. After a two-phase tr

215. "Heavy Metal" - The Case of the Brom Family - Rochester, Minnesota [Part 1 of 2] Aug 14, 2025 1823 A welfare check, a notebook, and black hair dye. On February 18th, 1988, a welfare check led to the discovery of four bodies inside the Brom Home in Rochester, Minnesota. Bernard and Paulette Brom along with two of their four children, 13-year-old Diane and 11-year-old Ricky, had been murdered with an axe. One of their surviving sons, 16-year-old David, was missing. As investigators pieced

214. "Extended Visit" - The Case of Julissia Batties - Bronx, New York Jul 31, 2025 2404 A documented history of abuse, dropped charges, and courtroom outbursts. In the spring of 2020, seven-year-old Julissia Batties went for a court ordered weekend visit with her biological mother, 36-year-old, Navasia Jones. She was supposed to return home to her paternal grandmother. But child services enacted a different plan. Julissia was found months later, deceased in her mother's apartm

213. "A Justified Homicide" - The Case of Aaron Spencer - Lonoke County, Arkansas - [UPDATE] Jul 24, 2025 2458 A barking dog, a father, and a pursuit. In the early morning hours of October 8th, 2024 the Spencer family awoke to find their teenage daughter missing. The girls father, 36-year-old, Aaron Spencer set out to find his daughter. In a matter of minutes he located the girl in a vehicle with 67-year-old Michael Fosler. Before deputies made their way to the scene, one man was dead and the other was cha

Melonie Biddersingh - with A Million Other Choices Jul 17, 2025 2980 On Labour Day 1994, the emaciated and burned body of a teen girl was found - it would take almost 20 years to identify her. What she endured will haunt you. Music Credit: Music from #Uppbeat (free for Creators!):https://uppbeat.io/t/pecan-pie/big-ironLicense code: FSLHQGSEBZV8JWBU Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices Our Sponsors:* Check out BetterHelp: https

212. “90 Percent Lie” - The Case of Mandey Noe - Weakley County, Tennessee [UPDATED] Jul 10, 2025 2852 A missing person's report, a strange story, and a rented tractor. On February 2nd of 2022, 36-year-old Jessica Thompson walked into the Weakley County Sheriff’s Office to report her 38-year-old niece, Mandey Noe, missing. From the very beginning, Jessica’s story seemed suspicious. When deputies realized they already had her husband, 45-year-old, Christopher Thompson in custody on un

You Should Be Here - Or No - Natalie Ryan-Fraser - Denver, Colorado Jul 3, 2025 1648 I'm still on break but here's a very special episode of Season Two of You Should Be Here: Or No, a podcaster's give back collaboration, hosted by me, Leah Dee! Natalie Ryan-Fraser was 55 years old when she was murdered at the hands of man who claimed to love her. This is a Podcaster’s Give Back collaboration. All podcasters have donated their time and research to help advocate for v

UNSOLVED: Emily Pike - MMIW - with Crime with Holly Jun 19, 2025 2688 In January 2025, 14-year-old Emily Pike snuck out of her group home in Mesa, Arizona. She was never seen alive again. Nearly three weeks later her dismembered body would be found 100 miles away near Globe, Arizona. What happened to Emily Pike and who could do this to such a sweet young girl? Listen to her story now! If you or anyone you know has information contact the Gila County Sheriffs Offic

211. “Our Girl” - The Case of Wilma June Nissen - Lyon County, Iowa Jun 12, 2025 2554 A single fingerprint, a daughter’s search, and “Sugar”. In October of 1978 a telephone crew working in Rock Rapids, Iowa discovered the body of an unidentified young woman. Twenty-seven years after her murder, a single fingerprint led to her identification. She was 23-year-old Wilma June Nissen. Just before her death, Wilma had abruptly moved to Atlanta, Georgia, so how had she ended up mu

210. "A Perfect Storm" - The Case of Lisa Au - Oahu, Hawaii [Part 2 of 2] Jun 5, 2025 1898 Two failed polygraphs, recovered evidence, and a four-decade long investigation. As the investigation into the murder of 19-year-old Lisa Au continued, the “second suspect” garners suspicion. Evidence is recovered that challenges the initial theory that Lisa was murdered by a police officer… or someone posing as one. Was that recovered evidence an indication of a police coverup? If you have a

209. "A Perfect Storm" - The Case of Lisa Au - Oahu, Hawaii [Part 1 of 2] May 29, 2025 1924 Blue lights, torrential rains, and a dry purse. On January 20th, 1982, 19-year-old Lisa Au finished her shift at the salon and met her boyfriend for dinner. After dinner, the couple went their separate ways, but Lisa never made it back home that night. Ten days later her body was found discarded in a roadside ravine. The entire island was struck with fear when rumors began to swirl that a poli

208. "The Associate" - The Disappearance of Nihar Mehta - Orange, California May 22, 2025 1455 A business associate, an abandoned car, and a warehouse. On June 3rd of 2022, 22-year-old Nihar Mehta vanished from Orange, California. He was last seen at a warehouse he was leasing with his business associate, Manuel "Manny" Chavez Zamudio. When investigators spoke to Zamudio, his story left them with more questions than answers. Where is Nihar Mehta? If you have any information r

206. “The Postcard” - The Case of Maryann Bagenstose - Lancaster, Pennsylvania May 8, 2025 2875 A postcard, handwriting analysis, and a hole in the garage floor. In June of 1984 25-year-old Maryann Bagenstose vanished from her home in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. For nearly four decades her case remained unsolved. Her estranged husband, Jere Bagenstose remained the chief suspect in her disappearance. Forty-years after her disappearance, now 70-year-old Jere stood trial for her murder.

205. "I'll Go Back to Prison" - The Case of Mary Schaivone - Naples, Florida May 1, 2025 1766 A phone call, a housekeeper, and a crackpipe. On May 17th, 2023, 34-year-old Anthony Corrado called his grandparent's housekeeper and told her he needed help cleaning up a mess at the home. When the housekeeper arrived, she stumbled into a horrific scene. 82-year-old, Mary Schaivone had been brutally murdered. As the housekeeper went for help, 74-year-old, Tony Schaivone arrived home.

204. “Haunted House” - The Case of Rhonda “Chantay” Blankinship - Brownwood, Texas Apr 24, 2025 2464 An evening walk, a phenotype report, and a public confession.On May 13th, 2016, 25-year-old Chantay Blankinship, went for a walk around her North Lake neighborhood as she did all the time. But this time Chantay didn’t make it back home.Two days later, she was found murdered at an abandoned farmhouse. Despite the fact that the killer had left behind DNA, for nearly two years Chantay’s case remained

MISSING MONDAYS: Jodi Huisentruit with Crime with Holly Apr 17, 2025 2933 I'm off for Holy Week! But our friend, Holly, with Crime with Holly is here!On June 27, 1995, TV news anchor Jodi Huisentruit vanished without a trace from the parking lot of her Mason City, Iowa, apartment complex. Signs of a struggle were left behind, but no definitive answers have surfaced in nearly three decades. Who took Jodi, and why? In this episode, we explore the haunting details, th

203. “Lost in the Woods” - The Case of Sarah Cherry - Bowdoin, Maine [Part 3 - FINAL] Apr 10, 2025 2957 A trip to the bathroom, speed, and DNA evidence.Dennis Dechaine takes the stand in his own defense.This time he has a whole new story as to what he was doing in the woods when Sarah Cherry was abducted and murdered.Dechaine is ultimately convicted but as he sits in prison, is there new DNA evidence that will lead to his exoneration? Sponsors:Gabb Protecting your kids has never been easier. For th

202. "Lost in the Woods" - The Case of Sarah Cherry - Bowdoin, Maine [Part 2] Apr 3, 2025 2809 Confessions, denials, and a trial. After 12-year-old, Sarah Cherry was found murdered, Dennis Dechaine was taken into custody.The statements he made to police after those cuffs were slapped on were concerning to say the least. By the time the case made it to trial, the evidence was stacked against Dechaine. But his defense team had a trick card up their sleeve. Would the jury believe Dennis'

[VIGIL] - Mary's Voice - The Case of Mary Collins - Charlotte, North Carolina Mar 27, 2025 7589 March 28th, 2025, marks five years since Mary Collins was brutally murdered at the hands of people she trusted.In those five years, only one of the four, Kelly Lavery, has been convicted. Lavi Pham, James Salerno, and America Diehl are still awaiting trial.Salerno and Diehl are currently free on bond.Every year from March 28th - April 5th Mary's family holds an online candlelight vigil marking

201. “Lost in the Woods” - The Case of Sarah Cherry - Bowdoin, Maine [Part 1 ] Mar 20, 2025 2367 An auto repair receipt, a red Toyota, and a dog named Major. On July 6th of 1988, 12-year-old Sarah Cherry had landed her first babysitting job for a family in Bowdoin, Maine. Sarah was excited as she headed over to the Henkel home to watch their 10-month-old daughter. But when Mrs. Henkel returned home from work that day, she found her baby sound asleep in her crib but no sign of her babysitter.

200. "Video Evidence" - The Case of Sonja Moen - West Fargo, North Dakota Mar 13, 2025 2631 A call home, bruised knuckles, and two small witnesses. On the morning of August 10th, 2023, 32-year-old Spencer Moen called to report that his 30-year-old wife, Sonja Moen, was unresponsive and not breathing.When officers arrived on scene, Spencer suggested that his wife had fallen up the stairs and in the bathtub. But Sonja's injuries were extensive and soon Spencer told a whole different

199. "The Seneca Jane Doe" - The Case of JoAnn "Vickie" Smith - Grundy County, Illinois Mar 6, 2025 1721 A farmer, a geneticist, and a coroner. On October 2nd, 1976, a farmer and his 12-year-old granddaughter made a grisly discovery. They found the body of a woman in a ditch off Highway 6 in Grundy County. For over 47 years, the victim remained unidentified and known only as the Seneca County Jane Doe. The summer of 2024, the Seneca County Jane Doe was finally identified as 20-year-old, JoAnn

198. “The Neighbors” - The Case of Jessica Mast - Benton County, Missouri Feb 27, 2025 2880 Surveillance cameras, a freezing pond, and three plea deals. On December 20th of 2020, the Benton County Sheriff’s Department was called to a home in Cole Camp. James Mast claimed his four-year-old daughter, Jessica Mast was deceased, and he and his entire family had been beaten by their neighbors, Jessica Aumen and Ethan Mast. Initially it was believed that James and his wife were also victims

197. "One Chapter Closes" - The Case of The Allenstown Four - Allenstown, New Hampshire Feb 20, 2025 1703 A podcast, a librarian, and a genetic genealogist. After police identified Terry Peder Rasmussen as the man who had killed at least six people across the United States, they were still working to identify the four victims found outside of Bear Brook Park. Thirty years after the first two blue barrels were found, the case was cracked twice independently and nearly simultaneously in the span of

196. "A Killer is Identified" - The Case of The Allenstown Four - Allenstown, New Hampshire Feb 13, 2025 1714 A serial killer, a trail of destruction and a name police had never heard. In 1985 in Allenstown, New Hampshire, a blue barrel with the remains of a woman and a young child were discovered in the woods near Bear Brook State Park. Fifteen years later, a cold case detective made another grisly discovery, another blue barrel and two more victims, both of them children. As investigators began to

195. "From New Hampshire to California " - The Case of Eunsoon Jun - Richmond, California Feb 6, 2025 1788 A surprise plea, two blue barrels, and cat litter. In 2002, 45-year-old, Eunsoon Jun, stopped taking her friend's phone calls. Her boyfriend, Larry Vanner, gave all kinds of excuses, none of them good ones. After two months, her friend, Renee, reported Eunsoon missing. Eusoon was found deceased in her home. As police were questioning her boyfriend, Larry, his fingerprints were run at the

194. “A Tale of Two Denises’” - The Cases of Denise Daneault & Denise Beaudin - Manchester, New Hampshire Jan 30, 2025 1703 A social club, two more disappearances, and an abandoned five-year-old.Six weeks after Laureen Rahn vanished from her apartment in Manchester, on June 8th of 1980, 25-year-old Denise Daneault disappeared after spending a night out at a social club. For years investigators didn’t take her disappearance seriously. What they didn’t know was that another Denise, Denise Beaudin, also vanished from the

193. "Voices in the Hall" - The Case of Laureen Rahn - Manchester, New Hampshire Jan 23, 2025 1823 A pay phone, three calls, and unscrewed lightbulbs. On April 26th, 1980, 14-year-old Laureen Rahn vanished from her apartment n Manchester, New Hampshire. A neighbor reported hearing voices in the hallway of the apartment building...followed by silence and Laureen Rahn seemingly vanished into thin air.Not long after her disappearance, her mother, Judith, reported a flurry of 3:45 am phone calls w

192. "42 Purple Stones" - The Case of Riley Whitelaw - Colorado Springs, Colorado Jan 16, 2025 2424 A man in a dumpster, a bottle of bleach, and a couple social security numbers. During the summer of 2022, 17-year-old, Riley Whitelaw clocked in for a shift at Walgreens in Colorado Springs. Riley took a 15-minute break but never returned. Hours later, her co-worker, 28-year-old, Joshua Johnson claimed he and Riley had been attacked by a masked man. But what really happened? Learn more abou

191. "The Upstairs Neighbor" - The Case of Bryan Hall - Angola, Indiana Dec 19, 2024 1902 Two 911 calls, a salon, and witches. In the fall of 2023, 30-year-old Yoshua Monday moved into an apartment with friends in Angola, Indiana. Less than a month after he moved in, 56-year-old Bryan Hall was shot dead inside his apartment. Investigators were able to piece the puzzle together quickly, but what was the motive? If you or someone you know is struggling, resources are available in the

190. "The Deputy & The Missing Men" - The Case of Felipe Santos & Terrance Williams - Collier County, Florida | [Part 2 - FINAL] Dec 5, 2024 2717 Keys on the ground, a jacket, and a recording device. After Felipe Santos and Terrance Williams vanished in Naples, Florida, investigators turned their attention to the last person both men were known to have contact with and that was Collier County Deputy Steve Calkins. When Calkins sat down to talk, his stories about his interactions with the missing men left more questions than answers. As t

MURDERED: Jared Bridegan with Crime with Holly Nov 28, 2024 2804 Happy Thanksgiving, y'all. Enjoy this special episode of Crime with Holly!A 33-year-old father of four was gunned down in Florida, with his 2-year-old daughter in the back seat of the car. Jared was a loving husband and father. He was a well respected member of his church and a Microsoft executive. Who could want him dead?Listen to his story now!GoFund Me to help Gaylord & JoAnne Bridegan

189. “The Deputy & The Missing Men” - The Case of Felipe Santos & Terrance Williams - Collier County, Florida | [Part 1] Nov 21, 2024 2123 A white Cadillac, Circle K, and two internal investigations.In the fall of 2003, 23-year-old, Felipe Santos disappeared after a minor traffic accident in Naples, Florida.Three months later, 27-year-old Terrance Williams also vanished, leaving behind the white Cadillac he had just bought.There was only one connection between the two men, they had last been seen with Collier County Deputy Steven Cal

Episodes

Recommended