Home Podcasts Assess THAT with Tom & Nat! (Assessment, Feedback, Grading, and Learning)
Assess THAT with Tom & Nat! (Assessment, Feedback, Grading, and Learning)

Assess THAT with Tom & Nat! (Assessment, Feedback, Grading, and Learning)

Tom Schimmer 100 Episodes Jul 6, 2026

The Tom Schimmer Podcast is a show about learning, leadership, and life, primarily focusing on current topics in K-12 education. Each week, Tom Schimmer, a best-selling education author and consultant, draws on his 30 years of experience to discuss prevailing stories in teaching and learning. The podcast also explores educational leadership and occasionally delves into success and happiness in various walks of life. Through interviews, commentary, news stories, and listener questions, it aims to equip educators and leaders with insights to meet learners' needs.

Episodes

37 - End of Year Assessment Audit (10 Questions Every Teacher Should Ask)
37 - End of Year Assessment Audit (10 Questions Every Teacher Should Ask) Jul 6, 2026 2499 As a school year is completed, it's natural to reflect on what worked, what didn't, and what you'd like to do differently next year. But beyond lessons, units, and classroom management, there's another area that deserves our attention: assessment. In this episode, Tom and Natalie guide listeners through an end-of-year assessment audit built around 10 powerful questions designed to help teachers ex
36 - Why Self-Assessment Fails (And How Students Actually Learn Quality)
36 - Why Self-Assessment Fails (And How Students Actually Learn Quality) Jun 17, 2026 3229 Self-assessment has become one of the most widely embraced practices in education. We want students to reflect on their learning, understand success criteria, monitor their progress, and take ownership of their growth. But what if we've underestimated how difficult self-assessment actually is? In this episode, Tom and Natalie explore the idea that students don't become effective self-assessors sim
35 - Why Grading Reform Fails in Schools (And What Leaders Get Wrong)
35 - Why Grading Reform Fails in Schools (And What Leaders Get Wrong) May 25, 2026 1561 What happens when grading reform moves beyond theory and starts colliding with real people, real beliefs, and real resistance? In this episode, Tom and Natalie unpack the leadership side of grading reform, the part that often gets overlooked in conversations about standards-based grading, assessment reform, and reporting practices. They explore why so many initiatives lose momentum, not because th
34 - Why Participation Grades Don’t Belong in Your Gradebook (And What To Do Instead)
34 - Why Participation Grades Don’t Belong in Your Gradebook (And What To Do Instead) Apr 29, 2026 2505 Participation grades are still widely used in education. In this episode, Tom and Nat challenge the assumption that participation belongs in academic grades by unpacking a critical distinction: participation may support learning, but it is not the same as learning. Through a candid and thought-provoking conversation, they explore what participation grades often end up measuring: personality, confi
33 - Interview w/ Jon Asbury, Edsby Destinations
33 - Interview w/ Jon Asbury, Edsby Destinations Apr 19, 2026 2988 In this episode, Tom & Natalie are joined by Jon Asbury, co-founder of Edsby, to discuss their new platform, "Edsby Destinations." Previously, Jon was one of the three co-founders of a company called SoftArc. SoftArc built an email and collaboration system called FirstClass back in the 90s that took the world by storm and is credited as, among other things, the first learning management system
32 - Why Feedback Fails (And What Actually Makes It Work)
32 - Why Feedback Fails (And What Actually Makes It Work) Mar 30, 2026 2024 In this episode, Tom and Nat take a hard look at one of the most celebrated and misunderstood elements of teaching: feedback. While research consistently shows that feedback can significantly improve student achievement, the reality in many classrooms is very different. Too often, feedback is given but not used, leaving teachers frustrated and students unchanged. Together, they unpack five
31 - Averaging Is Statistically Convenient and Educationally Misleading
31 - Averaging Is Statistically Convenient and Educationally Misleading Mar 16, 2026 2070 Averaging feels neutral, objective, and mathematically sound, but in the context of student learning, it can quietly distort the story a grade is meant to tell. In this episode, Tom and Natalie take a deep dive into the statistics that dominate most gradebooks (mean, median, and mode) and unpack why tools designed to summarize stable data can mislead us when applied to something as dynamic
30 - Assessment Literacy Is the Real "Teacher Shortage"
30 - Assessment Literacy Is the Real "Teacher Shortage" Mar 5, 2026 3024 Across education, we hear constant concern about teacher shortages. On the surface, it seems like recruitment pipelines, retention rates, burnout, and workload are the issues. But beneath those very real challenges lies a quieter, more systemic issue: many educators have never received deep, sustained support for developing assessment literacy. When teachers lack clarity around evidence, criteria,
29 - Lowering the Bar Isn’t Compassion: Rethinking Assessment and Care
29 - Lowering the Bar Isn’t Compassion: Rethinking Assessment and Care Feb 16, 2026 2548 In this episode, Tom and Nat explore a tension many educators are feeling right now: our deep desire to be compassionate in assessment and the unintended consequences that can arise when compassion gets confused with lowering expectations. Responding to student stress, disengagement, and inequity is real and necessary work. But when clarity fades, standards soften, and expectations become negotiab
28 - AI Didn’t Break Assessment; It Exposed It (and What That Means for Integrity)
28 - AI Didn’t Break Assessment; It Exposed It (and What That Means for Integrity) Feb 2, 2026 2095 AI has sparked fear, urgency, and a wave of reactionary policies in schools, but what if the real issue isn’t the technology itself? In this episode, Tom and Natalie argue that AI didn’t break assessment; it exposed long-standing weaknesses in task design, clarity, and how we define academic integrity. Rather than framing AI as a cheating problem to be solved through bans and detection tools, they
27 - The Hidden Cost of Implementation Errors in Assessment & Grading
27 - The Hidden Cost of Implementation Errors in Assessment & Grading Jan 19, 2026 2444 When educators say, “We tried that… and it didn’t work,” the conversation often stops there. But what if the problem isn’t the idea itself (e.g., feedback, reassessment, rubrics, or standards-based grading) but the way it was implemented? In this episode of Assess THAT, Tom & Nat explore the often-overlooked distinction between sound assessment ideas and the implementation choices that bring t
26 - Motivation and Assessment: Designing the Conditions for Learning with Josh Ogilvie
26 - Motivation and Assessment: Designing the Conditions for Learning with Josh Ogilvie Jan 5, 2026 3716 In this episode, Tom & Natalie are joined by CAC consultant Josh Ogilvie for a thoughtful and energizing conversation about the relationship between student motivation and sound assessment practices. Josh challenges the idea that motivation is something students either have or don’t have, and instead invites us to look closely at the conditions we design in classrooms (e.g., through purpose, c

Recommended