Secondhand Confessions
Join best friends Pugly and Mickey as they sift through the internet's most compelling stories, offering listeners a unique blend of laughter, self-discovery, and therapeutic insights. Their engaging tales of humor and healing make every episode feel like an insightful conversation with friends.
Episodes
Episode 37: My Husband Is a Different Person Online
In this episode, we explore what happens when the person you know and the person they become behind a screen seem impossible to reconcile. A pregnant woman accidentally discovers that her seemingly kind, gentle husband has a secret life as a vicious internet troll—using anonymous accounts to insult strangers, harass teenagers, and deliberately tear people down for his own amusement. The discovery
Episode 36: My Boyfriend Put Benadryl in My Drink
In this episode, we explore what happens when the people closest to you start treating your autonomy like something they get a vote on. A woman becomes alarmed after learning that her boyfriend secretly put Benadryl in her drink before an eight-hour road trip because he wanted her to sleep rather than argue with him—an admission that takes on even more troubling dimensions alongside his efforts to
Episode 35: He Wants to Propose. His Girlfriend Wants to Leave.
In this episode, doing the "right thing" gets complicated when every available option comes with collateral damage. A woman is caught between two close friends when her best friend announces that he's ready to propose—just days after his girlfriend privately confides that she's considering ending the relationship. Now she's holding a secret that could save him from a devas
Episode 34: My Fiancé Left Me for "The One That Got Away"
In this episode, we explore the seductive pull of “the one that got away” and what happens when nostalgia collides with the life you’ve already built. A bride-to-be is blindsided when her fiancé reconnects with his high school sweetheart, abruptly ends their three-year relationship, and walks away from their wedding for what he believes is a second chance at true love. Weeks later, he returns full
Episode 33: My Wife Catfished My Ex-Girlfriends
In this episode, deception isn’t loud—it’s strategic. A husband discovers that someone has been impersonating him online, friending exes and digging into his past. The culprit isn’t a scammer or a stranger, but his own wife, driven by jealousy and paranoia. What begins as confusion spirals into gaslighting, confession, and a marriage hanging by a thread.Then, a young woman falls hard for a charmin
Episode 32: My Husband's Former Fiancée Wore the Dress She Almost Married Him In
In this episode, we dive into confessions shaped by grief, boundaries, and the aftermath of unspoken truths. First, a grieving mother recounts the devastating loss of her child and the years of emotional abuse that followed her marriage—culminating in a darkly ironic act of defiance when her ex-husband weaponizes grief and demands “his half” of their child’s ashes. What unfolds is a story about su
Episode 31: My Stepsister Mocked My Fiancé’s Facial Scars
In this episode, boundaries and appearances collide in ways no one sees coming. First, a college roommate refuses to disappear for a day just to satisfy his friend’s conservative mother—sparking a clash between cultural expectations, personal space, and what it really means to feel at home. Meanwhile, in a far more volatile family, a woman finally snaps after years of cruelty, firing back at a ste
Episode 30: My Dad Told Me I Was a "Broken Condom" Baby
In this episode, honesty doesn’t just set people free; it cuts deep. A teenage daughter learns she wasn’t part of a careful plan but the result of a broken condom, thanks to her father’s careless joke. What begins as laughter leaves lasting scars, as she wrestles with feelings of rejection and questions her place in the family. Across another dinner table, a son turns the spotlight back on his ver
Episode 29: My Boyfriend Says I Need to Get Over My Childhood Trauma
In this episode, one closed closet door hides more than just clothes—it holds years of trauma, healing, and the fragile trust between two people. A girlfriend, haunted since childhood by the night a man emerged from her closet, finds comfort in glow-in-the-dark stars and a simple request: keep the closet door shut at night. For years, her boyfriend respects this boundary—until he decides to “test”
Episode 28: My Husband Bought Me the Earrings I Already Wear
In this episode, the little things turn out to be anything but little—as one Redditor’s Valentine’s Day takes an unexpectedly painful turn. First, a wife asks her husband for something sweet and simple: a thoughtful pair of earrings. What she unwraps instead? The exact same earrings she’s worn every day for two years—including the day they met, the day he proposed, and the day they got married. He
Episode 27: My Coworkers Wanted My Homeless Friend Banned
In this episode, workplace politics get personal—and painfully real—as three Redditors learn what happens when professional boundaries blur and basic human decency is left off the meeting agenda. First, a new mom is forced to sit through a two-hour meeting while in active labor because her boss decided his agenda was more urgent than childbirth. Then, an employee uses their lunch guest privileges
Episode 26: My Family Got Mad Because I Took My Own Cake Home
In this episode, love and loyalty are measured not in words, but in slice of cake—served with a side of disappointment and dashed expectations. First, a woman celebrates one year of sobriety with her favorite berry chantilly cake, only to have her family steamroll the moment with gymnastics news and wine. Then, a stepmom’s homemade birthday cake becomes a battleground when her husband trashes it f
Episode 25: My Boyfriend Hasn’t Been to the Dentist in Six Years
In this episode, love is tested not by grand betrayals or secrets, but by sinus infections and stubborn plaque. First, a woman grapples with the slow erosion of intimacy in her otherwise solid relationship, thanks to her partner’s six-year dental care boycott and the olfactory fallout that follows. Then, a man re-evaluates his entire marriage after being hospitalized with a severe infection—only t
Episode 24: My Daughter Refuses to Tell Her Boyfriend Her Dark Secret
In this episode, boundaries get blurred and secrets run deep. First, a college student finds himself at the center of an apartment cold war after watching Jurassic Park—a move that his roommate’s deeply religious girlfriend takes as a personal attack. As prehistoric drama turns into modern-day roommate regret, the lease isn’t the only thing that’s ending. Then, a devoted father faces an ethical di
Episode 23: My Ex Showed Up at My Door the Night Before His Wedding
In this episode, exclusion and regret take center stage. First, a father’s “guys only” trip leaves his tomboy daughter feeling abandoned, leading to a fractured bond that might not be easily repaired. Then, when the fallout begins, his wife refuses to help him fix the mess he created. Finally, a groom-to-be shows up drunk at his ex’s doorstep the night before his wedding—only to disappear on the b
Episode 22: I Paid $400 to See If My Sister's Boyfriend Would Cheat
In this episode, tough choices blur the lines between right and wrong. A man plans a secret vasectomy to escape his wife’s control—should his friend help? A woman’s boyfriend faces an ultimatum from his dying ex—does love or loyalty win? And when a sister goes to extreme lengths to expose a toxic boyfriend, was it justice or betrayal? Tune in for shocking stories of love, deception, and impossible
Episode 21: My Friend "Lost" My Wedding Dress
Weddings should be about love, but sometimes, they bring drama. A missing wedding dress sparks a heated debate over trust, a groom tricks his always-late parents into being on time, and a dressmaker faces backlash for setting boundaries with an entitled bride. Tune in for wedding woes, tough choices, and unexpected betrayals!Send us Fan MailShare your confessions with us on our website or on Insta
Episode 20: I Destroyed My Wife's Late Husband's Wedding Ring
In this episode, we explore the weight of love, loss, and loyalty in relationships. First, a husband’s well-intentioned Valentine’s Day surprise unearths years of unspoken grief, leading to an explosive confrontation that shatters his marriage beyond repair. Next, a man honors his wife’s late husband in an act of kindness that redefines love and respect in blended pasts. Finally, a seemingly harml
Episode 19: Grandma Deliberately Gave My Baby Chickenpox
In this episode, family and friendship take a dark turn. A mother-in-law secretly infects her granddaughter with chickenpox, sparking outrage and exposing a husband’s misplaced loyalty. Then, a woman discovers that her friend has been sneaking into her house while she’s away—caught on camera. When trust is shattered, is there any way back? Tune in for these shocking stories of deception and tough
Episode 18: My Family Ordered 20 Pizzas at My Vegan Wedding
In this episode, pizza becomes the unlikely catalyst for chaos and tough decisions. First, a parent confronts their son’s friend, who might only be sticking around for the pizza. Then, a vegan wedding feast turns into a family fiasco when unexpected pizzas crash the party. Finally, a delivery guy’s unsettling behavior sparks a heated conflict between a couple. Join us as we slice into these juicy
Episode 17: My Boyfriend's Late-Night Hobby Is a Giant Red Flag
In this episode, we explore holiday tensions and fractured relationships. First, a woman feels sidelined as her boyfriend prioritizes his ex-wife during Christmas. Next, a car accident reveals a young adult’s lingering resentment toward her parents’ rigid boundaries. Finally, a PhD student’s unusual coping mechanism strains his relationship and raises tough questions. Join us for stories of trust,
Episode 16: My Sister's Cooking Is Ruining Thanksgiving
In this episode, we dive into the chaos of Thanksgiving, where family traditions clash with unexpected dilemmas and tough decisions. First, a woman struggles to break a hosting promise to her mother with Alzheimer’s, whose house isn’t holiday-ready. Next, a sister’s questionable cooking sparks conflict over contributions to the meal. Finally, a father supports his daughters’ decision to skip famil
Episode 15: My Husband Gave Me a Hall Pass I Never Asked For
In this episode, we navigate the intricate dynamics of misunderstandings, assumptions, and unconventional compromises. First, we meet a teenager battling both her father’s denial of her Celiac Disease and her new friend group’s mistaken belief that she has anorexia—leading to a well-meaning but misguided intervention. Next, we explore the complexities of a marriage facing the challenges of Multipl
Episode 14: My Girlfriend's Pokémon Obsession Embarrasses Me
In this episode, we delve into the blurred boundaries between passion, obsession, and control. First, we meet a boyfriend who is embarrassed by his girlfriend's Pokémon obsession, as he struggles with peer pressure and the clash of hobbies in their relationship. Next, we explore the tense dynamic between a volunteer EMT and his wife, whose obsession with neatness leads to a frustrating battle
Episode 13: I Stalked My Husband for Two Years Before We Met
In this episode, we explore the fine line between passion, obsession, and deception. A husband discovers his wife’s strange hobby: a conspiracy board tracking the alleged infidelities of their neighbors, with shockingly personal consequences. As tensions rise, so do questions about trust and boundaries in their marriage. Next, we unravel the unsettling tale of a woman who secretly stalked her husb
Episode 12: My Boyfriend’s Ex Left a Warning for Me
In this episode, we dive into the complexities of love, communication, and the impact of past relationships. A woman discovers a note from her boyfriend’s ex, warning her about his cleaning habits. This revelation spirals into a confrontation that forces her to reconsider the future of her relationship. Meanwhile, a Reddit user grapples with her fiancé’s explosive reactions to minor mistakes, leav
Episode 11: I'm an Escort Who Fell in Love with a Client
In this episode, we dive into the gripping story of an escort who finds herself falling for one of her clients—a kind and charismatic widower who blurs the lines between professional and personal. As their relationship shifts from transactional to emotional, she faces a heart-wrenching dilemma: risk her career and take a chance on love, or keep her feelings hidden to maintain the safety of their c
Episode 10: My Pregnant Wife Left Me for Her Gym Partner (Part 2)
In this episode, we continue to explore the unraveling of a marriage caught between obsession and betrayal. A husband worries that his wife’s intense gym routine has become an unhealthy obsession and a form of escapism.Send us Fan MailShare your confessions with us on our website or on Instagram.
Episode 9: My Pregnant Wife Left Me for Her Gym Partner (Part 1)
In this episode, we explore the unraveling of a marriage caught between obsession and betrayal. A husband worries that his wife’s intense gym routine has become an unhealthy obsession and a form of escapism.Send us Fan MailShare your confessions with us on our website or on Instagram.
Episode 8: My Fiancé Laughed While His Family Mocked Me
In this episode, we explore marital loyalty, personal values, and the ripple effects of infidelity on friendships and family. A woman faces her husband's ultimatum to cut ties with her cheating best friend, mirroring a decision she enforced years ago about his friend. Couples describe their experiences of navigating significant differences and share how these challenges influenced their relat
Episode 7: My Marriage Might End Over the Jar Lids
In this episode, we explore secret affairs, jar lids, and second chances. First, a man faces guilt after his affair partner’s tragic death. Next, a woman decides to divorce her husband over his obsessive jar-tightening. Lastly, a woman reconnects with her ex-boyfriend after discovering her friends orchestrated their breakup. Tune in for these compelling stories of love, deception, and the struggle
Episode 6: I Almost Lost a Testicle While My Girlfriend Was Clubbing
In this episode, we explore two stories of trust tested by emergencies. A young man suffering a severe medical crisis is ignored by his girlfriend, which forces him to face his pain alone. Meanwhile, a pregnant woman stages a birth emergency to test her husband's commitment against his mother's influence.Send us Fan MailShare your confessions with us on our website or on Instagram.
Episode 5: My Boyfriend Put Slugs in My Food
In this episode, we unravel three gripping tales of boundaries pushed to the brink. Witness the fallout of a roommate feud sparked by clashing views on acceptable home attire. Experience the chilling betrayal of a man manipulating his girlfriend's diet in secret. Brace yourself for a casual game night turned shocking threesome, leaving relationships shattered. These raw, unflinching stories e
Episode 4: I Was Buying Her Engagement Ring When I Caught Her Lying
In this episode, a romantic plan takes a jarring turn. A man, on the verge of proposing, enlists the help of his girlfriend's best friend to choose the perfect ring. But a shocking text from his girlfriend throws everything into disarray. She claims to be out shopping with the very same friend who's sitting right next to him. Caught in a web of deceit, he must decide whether to expose th
Episode 3: My Boyfriend Has Been Unemployed Our Entire Relationship
In this episode, we explore the turbulent waters where love collides with personal boundaries. Witness a bride's battle against her controlling, affluent mother-in-law, as wedding dreams clash with familial expectations. Feel the frustration of a woman grappling with her partner's chronic unemployment, testing the limits of love and ambition. Experience the heartache of a jiu-jitsu enthu
Episode 2: The First Episode
Join us as we explore the heart-stopping excitement of breaking up over political apathy, the excitement of excluding your significant other from work dinners, the thrill of religious ultimatums, and the romance of a prenuptial agreement.Send us Fan MailShare your confessions with us on our website or on Instagram.
Recommended
Dark Night Tales with Brian King
Fantasy Flex
زن بودن
Medicine with Meaning
Yours Truly Johnny Dollar Collection
Take Back Your Health®
CBS Radio Mystery Theater | Old Time Radio
Solved Murders - True Crime Stories
紐約鳥｜New York Aperture
The Swerve Podcast: Obscure Topics | Conspiracy Theories
The Bread and Banter Podcast
The Church of What's Happening Now: The New Testament
