Stop, Who DOES That?!
Dive into the dark, bizarre, and jaw-dropping corners of the true crime world with Jenna and Jackie, two friends who turn every "wait, what?" headline into a wild ride of curiosity, chaos, and sharp-witted commentary. The podcast covers chilling new cases and outrageous criminal moments making headlines. It blends real-world crime with humor, disbelief, and the recurring question: who does that? Each episode offers a mix of true crime storytelling and conversational reactions.
Episodes
The Exorcism at Gracedale Nursing Home
In the early morning hours of June 23, 2025, police arrived at Gracedale Nursing Home in Northampton County, Pennsylvania, and encountered a scene almost impossible to believe. Prosecutors allege that a registered nurse was attempting to perform an exorcism on a bedridden, non-verbal elderly resident she believed was possessed by demons.
But the disturbing allegations were only the beginning.
Jo
Stop! Who Does That? x Our True Crime Podcast: The Unsolved Murder of Joy Hayward |
This week, Jackie and Jenna are joined by the ladies of Our True Crime Podcast for a special crossover episode centered on a case that deserves more attention: the unsolved murder of Joy Hayward.
Together, we revisit Joy’s case, the evidence, the unanswered questions, and the frustrating roadblocks that have left her loved ones waiting for justice. We also discuss why advances in forensic DNA an
The Case After Lindsay Clancy: Kevin Reddington Defends Kelsie Cote
On Halloween night in 2022, 74-year-old Doris Cote was last seen alive inside her North Adams, Massachusetts home with her granddaughter, Kelsie Cote. The next day, Doris was found dead at the bottom of her basement stairs—but investigators say the evidence pointed to something far more violent than an accidental fall.
In this episode, Jackie and Jenna break down the disturbing allegations agains
ROAD TRIP RECORDING: Lindsay Clancy Mistrial, Mica Miller, Kohberger and more!
Recorded live on Instagram on September 17, 2026
Hop in the backseat with Jackie and Jenna as they hit the road from Pennsylvania to the Ed and Lorraine Warren House & Occult Museum for a paranormal investigation!
They weren’t about to let a road trip keep them from dropping an episode, so this one is completely off the cuff. Jackie and Jenna catch up on the latest developments in the Lindsay Cl
The Funeral Director, the Affair & the Body in the Pool | The Jan Roseboro Murder
From the outside, Michael and Jan Roseboro appeared to have built an idyllic life in quiet Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. They had four children, a successful family business, and a beautiful home complete with a brand-new swimming pool.
But behind closed doors, Michael was hiding an intense affair—and talking about starting an entirely new life with another woman.
Then, on July 22, 2008, Jan w
Four Missing Women & One Philadelphia House: The Eugene Horsch Investigation
What began as a routine traffic stop in Philadelphia quickly unraveled into something far more disturbing.
Investigators were led to a home in the city’s Olney neighborhood, where authorities say they uncovered weapons, fake federal credentials, chemicals, cremated remains, and an enormous cache of disturbing digital evidence. Soon, the names of multiple missing women became connected to the inve
DEEP DIVE: The Philadelphia House of Horrors | Gary Heidnik
Behind the walls of an ordinary Philadelphia row home was a nightmare no one could have imagined.
Between 1986 and 1987, Gary Heidnik kidnapped six women and imprisoned them in a horrifying basement dungeon—chaining them inside pits beneath his home and subjecting them to unimaginable abuse. Two women would never make it out alive.
But Heidnik underestimated one of his captives. Josefina Rivera
SPECIAL: Bryan Kohberger Reverses Guilty Plea and Lindsay Clancy Trial Recap
This week on Stop! Who Does That?, Jackie and Jenna are breaking down two major true-crime cases making headlines.
First, Bryan Kohberger is back in the news—more than a year after pleading guilty to the murders of Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle and Ethan Chapin. Kohberger is now seeking to withdraw that plea, claiming he received bad legal advice and was pressured into accepting
DEEP DIVE: The 1963 Disappearance of George Carroll (LONG ISLAND NY)
In the early 1960s, George Carroll seemingly vanished without a trace, leaving behind a wife and four young children on Long Island. For decades, his children were told the same story: their father had gone out for cigarettes and simply never came back.
But as they grew older, that explanation stopped making sense.
Why had no missing persons report ever been filed? Why had George never picked up
The DJ Who Hid in Plain Sight for 26 Years: The Murder of Christy Mirack
Just days before Christmas in 1992, beloved sixth-grade teacher Christy Mirack was found brutally murdered inside her Lancaster County, Pennsylvania apartment. Her killer left DNA behind, but for more than 25 years, his identity remained a mystery.
Then, a groundbreaking use of investigative genetic genealogy led detectives to Raymond “DJ Freez” Rowe, a popular local DJ who had been living and wo
The Other Lehigh Valley Family Murders: Jeffrey Howorth Killed His Parents Days After the Freemans
Just days after the Freeman brothers murdered their parents in Pennsylvania’s Lehigh Valley, another local family was destroyed by an eerily similar crime.
On March 2, 1995, George and Susan Howorth returned to their quiet suburban home after work. Police say that before they could even take off their coats, their 16-year-old son, Jeffrey Howorth, opened fire. George was shot five times. Susan wa
DEEP DIVE - Lindsay Clancy: Mental Illness or Maternal Filicide?
She was a respected labor and delivery nurse, a devoted wife, and a mother of three young children. But on January 24, 2023, an unimaginable tragedy unfolded inside the Clancy family’s Duxbury, Massachusetts home.
In this episode, we examine the case of Lindsay Clancy, who is accused of killing her children—five-year-old Cora, three-year-old Dawson, and eight-month-old Callan—before attempting to
Headline Highlights 7/12/2026: Nolan Wells, Tamla Horsford, pop culture ramblings and more!
This week on Stop! Who Does That?, we're kicking back with another Headline Highlights episode!
We're covering the latest true crime headlines making waves, including the mysterious case of Nolan Wells and revisiting the unanswered questions surrounding the death of Tamla Horsford. We also dive into some of the biggest stories in pop culture, share our thoughts on what's been trending all week, a
DEEP DIVE: The Lost Boys of Bucks County PART ONE (re-released)
***A NOTE FROM JACKIE AND JENNA: We had received a review about this episode with attention called out to our information on Jimi Patrick, stating that Jimi did not have a history of being troubled or kicked out of high school and was a student in college at the time of the murders. We take getting the facts seriously, and we removed this episode pending review of our sources that were cited for t
DEEP DIVE: The Mysterious Death of Terron Evans Jr. PART ONE
Two empty pill bottles. A young man found dead in bed. A case quickly ruled an overdose.
But Terron Evans Jr.’s mother says the evidence tells a very different story.
On January 8, 2021, 26-year-old Terron Evans Jr. was found dead inside a home in Potsdam, New York. Authorities concluded his death was caused by a heart attack connected to a Wellbutrin overdose — but from the beginning, Terron’s
Exclusive Interview: Karen & Michael Reinert’s Step-Sister Speaks | The Main Line Murders PART THREE
The Main Line Murders shocked Pennsylvania in 1979 after the body of schoolteacher Susan Reinert was discovered in the trunk of her car outside a Harrisburg-area motel. Her two children, 11-year-old Karen and 10-year-old Michael, were never found. What followed was a deeply disturbing investigation filled with betrayal, manipulation, allegations of conspiracy, and lingering questions that continue
DEBRIEF: MATERNAL INSTINCTS (live stream)
Last night, Jackie and Jenna hosted an Instagram live to debrief Maternal Instincts, the Netflix documentary that covers the story of Taylor Parker and her brutal murder of Reagann Hancock and her unborn baby, Braxlynn. We discussed our reactions as well as fill in some backstory and gaps to the documentary on this live Instagram and are uploading it unedited for those who may have missed it. If y
DEEP DIVE: Shannon Schieber - The 911 Call Police Walked Away From
On May 7, 1998, 23-year-old Wharton graduate student Shannon Schieber was found murdered inside her Philadelphia apartment after failing to show up for work. Hours earlier, a neighbor had called 911 after hearing screams, cries for help, and choking sounds coming from Shannon’s apartment — but police left without forcing entry.
Shannon’s murder terrified Philadelphia, especially as investigators
The Abt Family Massacre: The Neighbor Who Waited Inside Their Home (BUCKS COUNTY)
In this episode of Stop! Who Does That?, Jackie and Jenna dive into one of Bucks County’s most disturbing crimes: the Abt family massacre.
In March 1976, 24-year-old George Geschwendt broke into the Trevose, Pennsylvania home of the Abt family and waited for hours, armed and hidden inside. One by one, as members of the family returned home, he shot and killed them in a calculated ambush rooted in
DEEP DIVE: A Sister's Fight for Justice - Joy Hayward PART TWO
In Part Two of Joy Hayward’s story, Jackie and Jenna sit down with Joy’s sister, Grace Hayward, for an emotional and powerful conversation about who Joy was, the devastating impact of her murder, and the family’s 22-year fight for answers.
Joy was only 28 years old when she was brutally murdered inside a Chester, Pennsylvania hotel room in February 2004. Despite DNA evidence from an unknown male
DEEP DIVE: The Unsolved Murder of Joy Hayward PART ONE
In this episode of Stop! Who Does That?, Jackie and Jenna examine the unsolved murder of Joy Hayward, a 28-year-old woman whose life was brutally cut short after checking into a Chester, Pennsylvania hotel in February 2004.
What began as a visit to see her boyfriend turned into a nightmare when Joy left after an argument and checked into the Days Inn alone in the early morning hours. Just hours l
DEEP DIVE: West Coast Video Murders - Bucks County, PA
In this episode of Stop! Who Does That?, Jackie and Jenna cover the haunting unsolved case of the West Coast Video Store Murders in Warminster, Pennsylvania.
On November 10, 1993, 20-year-old friends and coworkers Bryan Benson and Seann Campbell were working the closing shift at a West Coast Video in the Rosemore Shopping Center. By the next morning, both young men were found brutally murdered in
Headline Highlights May 8, 2026: Lynette Hooker, d4vd, Anna Kepner, NASA scientists, and Florida Man Google Roulette!
Headline Highlights is BACK!
In this week’s Headline Highlights, Jackie and Jenna break down some of the most disturbing and rapidly developing cases making headlines right now—and trust us, this one is packed.
A Michigan mother vanishes during a romantic getaway in the Bahamas, and her husband’s story immediately raises red flags. With no body, conflicting accounts, and a history of tension beh
DEEP DIVE: The Lehigh Valley's Jessica Padgett
In this episode of Stop! Who Does That?, Jackie and Jenna cover the devastating case of Jessica Padgett—a 33-year-old mother, newly married and building the life she had always dreamed of, when everything suddenly came to a halt.
What started as a quick errand during her lunch break quickly turned into a missing persons case that left her family and community searching for answers. Jessica had no
DEEP DIVE: Jennifer Brown
this episode of Stop! Who Does That?, Jackie and Jenna break down the heartbreaking and shocking case of Jennifer Brown, a 43-year-old Pennsylvania mother who vanished without a trace—only for the truth to reveal a betrayal no one saw coming.
Jennifer Brown was a devoted mom, a successful professional, and an aspiring restaurant owner working toward opening her dream business, “Birdie’s Kitchen,”
DEEP DIVE: The Lehigh Valley's Freeman Brothers
In this episode of Stop! Who Does That?, Jackie and Jenna dive into one of Pennsylvania’s most disturbing family murder cases—the Freeman Brothers.
What began as a quiet night in Salisbury Township in February 1995 quickly turned into a scene of unimaginable violence. When police entered the Freeman home, they discovered a brutal triple homicide—both parents and their 11-year-old son murdered ins
DEEP DIVE: Laci Peterson PART TWO
In this episode, Jackie and Jenna delve into the Laci Peterson case, focusing further on the arguments presented by the LA Innocence Project in defense of Scott Peterson. They explore the eerie similarities between Lacey's case and that of Evelyn Hernandez, discuss new evidence and witness statements that challenge the original narrative, and examine the role of media coverage in shaping public pe
DEEP DIVE - Laci Peterson PART ONE
Formerly available only on YouTube, please enjoy this episode on all the streamers re-released now while we are at Beyond the Crime Convention!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
DEEP DIVE: The Lost Boys of Bucks County PART TWO
In Part 2 of the Lost Boys of Bucks County, Jackie and Jenna uncover the chilling details that transformed a missing persons case into one of the most disturbing murder investigations in Pennsylvania history.
What began with four young men vanishing without a trace quickly escalated when authorities zeroed in on a rural Solebury Township farm. As the investigation intensified, shocking discoverie
DEEP DIVE: The Lehigh Valley's Teen Serial Killer - Harvey Miguel Robinson
In this chilling episode, Jackie and Jenna dive into the terrifying case of Harvey Miguel Robinson, one of Pennsylvania’s youngest serial killers. At just 17 years old, Robinson went on a violent spree that left an entire community shaken, targeting women in a series of brutal and calculated attacks.
Jackie and Jenna unpack the timeline of his crimes, the disturbing patterns that emerged, and how
DEEP DIVE | Kevin Mengel: He Trusted Them Both and They Were Plotting His Murder
In West Chester, Pennsylvania, Morgan Mengel and Kevin Mengel appeared to have a normal life from the outside — a marriage, three children, and a growing landscaping business. But behind the scenes, their relationship was unraveling. Rumors of infidelity, tension at home, and betrayal were building for years.
Then Kevin suddenly vanished.
At first, his wife claimed he had simply left to clear hi
The Main Line Murders Part 2: The Twisted Plot Behind Susan Reinert’s Death
In PART TWO, Jenna and Jackie delve into the chilling details of the Main Line Murders, focusing on the manipulation and deceit surrounding Susan Reinert's tragic death and the subsequent trials of Bill Bradfield and Jay Smith. They explore the complex relationships, financial motives, and the eventual overturning of convictions, leaving listeners with lingering questions about justice and the unr
The Susan Reinert Murder: The Main Line’s Darkest Scandal
In 1979, a beloved English teacher at Upper Merion High School vanished from Pennsylvania’s affluent Main Line community. Days later, Susan Reinert’s body was discovered in a Harrisburg motel parking lot in the back of her own vehicle— but her two young children, Karen and Michael, were nowhere to be found.
What began as a missing persons case quickly unraveled into one of the most controve
DEEP DIVE: Ellen Greenberg
Jackie and Jenna dive into the mysterious death of Ellen Greenberg, who was found stabbed 20 times in her apartment, with her death initially ruled a suicide.
They discuss the background of Ellen's life, the day of the incident, the controversial 911 call made by her fiancé, the autopsy findings, and the subsequent legal battles her family has faced in their quest for justice.
They explore the i
Missing Boys in Philadelphia: The Cases No One Is Talking About | Headline Highlights Special
PLEASE NOTE: This episode may be best viewed on YouTube
In this episode, Jenna and Jackie discuss the alarming issue of missing juvenile males in Philadelphia, focusing on 16 boys who have gone missing in recent months. They highlight the lack of media coverage and public awareness compared to other missing persons cases, particularly those of white children.
The hosts explore individual cases,
Murdered on Valentine's Day : Jodine Serrin
On Valentine’s Day 2007, a quiet coastal neighborhood in Carlsbad, California became the scene of a haunting mystery that would take more than a decade to solve. In this episode of Stop! Who Does That?!, Jackie and Jenna break down the tragic and complex case of Jodine Serrin, a kind-hearted 39-year-old woman found murdered inside her own home after her parents stopped by for a routine check-in.
Meggan Sundwall, Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping, Hailey Buzbee & More | Headline Highlights Feb 9
Most people think they know everything about friendship, betrayal, and the dark secrets lurking beneath seemingly innocent relationships. In this episode, we uncover the shocking case of Megan Sundwell—a nurse accused of convincing her best friend to take her own life for insurance money. Discover how a seemingly close friendship spiraled into a diabolical plan with medical deception, hidden motiv
DEEP DIVE: Richard Greist - Murder of Pregnant Wife, Insanity Defense, and Release
The conversation delves into the shocking case of Richard Greist, a Pennhurst State School Aide, who committed a heinous crime in Sanatoga, PA, on May 10, 1978, resulting in the deaths of his pregnant wife and unborn child.
Jackie and Jenna explore the complexities of his mental illness, the trial that found him not guilty by reason of insanity, and the subsequent years of rehabilitation. They di
Headline Highlights 2.2.2026: PA Family Annihilator, NJ Mansion Murders, OK mother murdered by her adopted son, Gabby Petito, Luigi Mangione and Au Pair Murder Trial RECAP
In this episode of Headline Highlights, hosts Jackie and Jenna discuss several tragic and shocking murder cases, including a family annihilator in Pennsylvania, the murder of an Oklahoma mother by her adopted son, and the ongoing New Jersey mansion murder trial.
They also provide updates on the Brendan Banfield/Au Pair murder trial, reflecting on the complexities of justice and family dynamics i
DEEP DIVE - The Unsolved Murder of Gary W. Redner
In this episode, hosts Jackie and Jenna delve into the unsolved murder of Gary Redner, a successful grocery store executive found dead outside his home in Pennsylvania. They explore the background of Redner, the circumstances surrounding his death, and the ongoing investigation that has left the community in silence.
The discussion highlights the theories surrounding the murder, the potential mot
Headline Highlights 1.27.2026: Therapist Killed, Firefighter Murder Case, Poisonous Thanksgiving Dinner & More
On this episode of Stop! Who Does That? Headline Highlights (January 27, 2026), Jackie and Jenna break down some of the most disturbing and fast-moving true crime stories making headlines right now.
We begin in Orlando, Florida, where a beloved therapist is brutally murdered by her former patient — raising serious questions about safety, accountability, and systemic failures meant to protect ment
Headline Highlights: Hollywood Scandal, Amish Murder Case, and a Hoodie That Confessed
In this episode of "Stop Who Does That? Headline Highlights," hosts Jackie Shuman and Jenna dive into a series of shocking crime stories, starting with the allegations against Timothy Busfield, a former actor from "The West Wing," who faces serious charges of child abuse. The discussion highlights the troubling pattern of accusations against Busfield, including a previous incident from the 1990s,
DEEP DIVE: Jamie Silvonek
In this episode of "Stop Who Does That," now a DARKCAST NETWORK podcast, hosts Jenna and Jackie delve into the tragic case of Jamie Silvonek, a 14-year-old girl who, along with her 20-year-old boyfriend, plotted and executed the murder of her mother, Cheryl. The episode begins with a chilling overview of the events leading up to the crime, highlighting the forbidden romance between Jamie and Caleb
HEADLINE HIGHLIGHTS: A Dentist’s Double Murder, the Murdaugh Case, and a Real-Life Grave Robber
In this episode, the Jackie and Jenna discuss a series of shocking crimes, including the double homicide of a dentist and his wife, updates on Alex Murdaugh's case, and a grave robber in Pennsylvania reminiscent of Ed Gein.
They delve into the details of each case, exploring the implications and societal reactions, while also providing updates on ongoing investigations and legal proceedings from
DEEP DIVE: Kouri Richins
The conversation delves into the chilling case of Kouri Richins, who is accused of spiking her husband's Moscow Mule with fentanyl. The hosts explore the background of the couple, the alleged murder, and the suspicious behavior exhibited by Kouri after Eric's death.
They discuss the disturbing twist of Kouri writing a children's book about grief shortly after the incident, raising questions about
Headline Highlights: Missing Texas Teens, Florida Man NFL Blowup, Ashlee Buzzard & More
In this episode, Jackie and Jenna discuss various true crime stories, including the tragic case of Ashley Buzzard, who pleaded not guilty to murdering her daughter, and a Florida man who shot his wife during a domestic dispute.
They also cover the mysterious disappearance of Camila Mendoza, whose body was found shortly after she went missing. The episode concludes with updates on ongoing trials a
BONUS EPISODE - The Kenny Veach Mystery: M Cave, Conspiracies, and a Vanishing in the Mojave Desert
In this gripping episode of "Stop Who Does That," hosts Jackie and Jenna delve into the mysterious disappearance of Kenny Veach, an avid hiker and YouTuber known for his adventurous spirit.
Joined by special guest Troy, also known as @mrveryscary on Instagram, they explore the chilling tale of Veach's last journey into the Mojave Desert in search of the enigmatic M-shaped cave.
As they unravel t
Headline Highlights 12.22.2025 - Reiner Double Homicide, Doctor Found Dead in Dollar Store Freezer, JP Miller, D4vd & Epstein
In this episode of 'Stop Who Does That', hosts Jackie and Jenna cover several true crime cases, including the Reiner double homicide, the mysterious death of Dr. Helen Garay Sanchez, and the tragic case of Micah Miller.
They also provide updates on various criminal cases such as D4vd and Epstein, and engage in a light-hearted segment of Florida Man Roulette, discussing a bizarre incident that occ
Headline Highlights: Brian Walshe, Joshua Kannin, Rebecca Park, Rob Reiner Tragedy
In this episode, Jackie and Jenna discuss several tragic and shocking true crime cases, including the alleged family annihilator Joshua Cannon, the murder trial of Brian Walshe, the horrific crime against pregnant Rebecca Park, and the recent deaths of filmmaker Rob Reiner and his wife Michelle.
They also provide updates on Morgan Geyser, the Slender Man killer, and engage in a light-hearted segm
DEEP DIVE: Missing in Philadelphia - What Happened to Danielle Imbo and Richard Petrone?
In this episode, Jackie and Jenna delve into the mysterious disappearance of Danielle Imbo and Richard Petrone, a couple who vanished in 2005 after leaving a bar in Philadelphia.
They discuss the background of the couple, the events leading up to their disappearance, and the subsequent investigation that involved multiple law enforcement agencies, including the FBI.
The hosts explore various the
Headline Highlights 12.8.2025 - Slenderman Girl, Texas A+M Cheerleader, Utah Wannabe Family Annihilator and more!
In this episode of 'Stop Who Does That? Headline Highlights', hosts Jackie and Jenna discuss several high-profile true crime cases, including updates on Morgan Geyser from the Slender Man case, the tragic death of Texas A&M student Brianna Aguilera, and the disturbing actions of Micah Smith, a wannabe family annihilator.
They also touch on the ongoing search for Travis Turner, who is missing amid
CASE DEEP DIVE: Devyn Michaels: Ex-Husband Beheading & Stepson Marriage
In this episode, Jenna and Jackie dive into the shocking and twisted case of Devyn Michaels, a former adult film star who became embroiled in a toxic love triangle that led to the brutal murder of her ex-husband, Johnathan Willette on August 7, 2023. The conversation explores the chaotic relationships, the events leading up to the murder, and the subsequent trial, revealing the complexities of hum
Headline Highlights: Massive Case Updates D4vd, missing Travis Turner, Anna Kepner Cause of Death, Luigi Mangione Hearing
In this episode of 'Stop Who Does That', hosts Jackie and Jenna discuss several headline updates including the ongoing investigation into the D4VD case, the tragic murder of Anna Kepner, the mysterious disappearance of football coach Travis Turner, and the latest court updates on Luigi Mangione. They also engage in a light-hearted segment of Florida (Wo)Man Roulette, showcasing the bizarre news st
CASE DEEP DIVE: Anna Maciejewska
Anna Maciejewska was a brilliant, compassionate mother whose life revolved around her young son — until she vanished without a trace in March 2017. In this in-depth episode, Jenna and Jackie take you inside Anna’s world: her journey from Poland to the U.S., her academic achievements and the pressures on her marriage.
As we piece together the days leading up to her disappearance, we explore confli
Stop! Who Does That? True Crime Headline Highlights 11.21.25
In this week’s episode of Stop! Who Does That?!, Jackie and Jenna dive into the most talked-about true-crime headlines of the week. From new twists in the D4vd case and updates surrounding Jeffrey Epstein, to the heartbreaking cruise ship mystery of Anna Kepner and the shocking details of Angie Mock’s story, we’re breaking down what’s fact, what’s speculation, and what still doesn’t add up. Then,
Recommended
Dark Night Tales with Brian King
Fantasy Flex
زن بودن
Medicine with Meaning
Yours Truly Johnny Dollar Collection
Take Back Your Health®
CBS Radio Mystery Theater | Old Time Radio
Solved Murders - True Crime Stories
紐約鳥｜New York Aperture
The Swerve Podcast: Obscure Topics | Conspiracy Theories
The Bread and Banter Podcast
The Church of What's Happening Now: The New Testament
