Home Podcasts The Murderer Killings - A True* Crime Podcast

The Murderer Killings - A True* Crime Podcast

Michael Satow & Jack Canfora 10 Episodes Dec 10, 2025

The Murderer Killings is a comedic, fictional true-crime podcast. It follows Charlie Incarica as he investigates what the show calls the truest crimes ever committed, though the crimes are not actually true. The series mixes crime-spree parody with dessert-themed humor and self-aware jokes. It is hosted by Michael Satow and Jack Canfora.

Episodes

Episode 9 - The Finale Destination Dec 10, 2025 1496 Send us Fan MailBranigan’s instincts start convincing her more and more that they’ve convicted the wrong person. Meanwhile, as Charlie prepares to leave Shady Grove, he starts to suspect Estelle knows more about The Murderer Killings than she’s been letting on. After a farewell dinner, a wild night of close-harmony a Capella, and a serendipitous hot-mic moment, his suspicions are confirmed. Chief

Episode 8 - The Penultimate Episode Dec 10, 2025 1402 Send us Fan MailIt’s Christmas in Shady Grove, and as the trial date looms, Charlie decides to stay in town to take in some holiday traditions, such as Mayor Lyons’s One-Man Christmas Carol. The trial begins as planned on January 6th, but is postponed almost as soon as it begins, as the Judge insists the jury spend the next two days discussing the insurrection at the Capital. After an action-packe

Episode 7 - The Seventh Episode Dec 10, 2025 601 Send us Fan MailAs the murder investigation continues, a power struggle to seize control of the massive Shady Grove Pudding empire intensifies between Teddy Putnam and William Hart. Margaret Mandragora-Jones throws in her lot with Teddy, and tries to win the community over. However, with Governor Hart now having a vested interest in her son William seizing the reins of Shady Grove Pudding, Braniga

Episode 6 - The Sixth Episode Dec 10, 2025 952 Send us Fan MailAfter a brief absence, Charlie returns to Shady Grove to find the town is growing restless due to lack of progress in the investigation. Interim Acting Chief Branigan’s main stumbling block becomes interference from the Governor – who is also the mother of Amanda’s estranged and widowed husband, William Hart. Branigan makes an astonishing discovery about Margaret Mandragora-Jones’s

Episode 5 - The Fifth Episode Dec 10, 2025 1296 Send us Fan MailThe investigation begins to heat up as now Acting Interim Chief Taylor Branigan takes the lead on the case, and applies pressure to Margaret Mandragora-Jones. Teddy’s machinations against his sister come to light. Taylor uncovers the surprising news that Margaret and Teddy Putnam, whom she earlier described as being, “As thick as a glacier with a thyroid condition,” have become rom

Episode 4 - The Fourth Episode Dec 10, 2025 1610 Send us Fan MailCharles gets help untangling family history from Vanessa Holmes, author of the definitive biography of the Putnam Family, Blood Pudding. Unfortunately, Vanessa and Estelle are on sour terms, and when Estelle catches wind, she throws him out of her AirBnB. Charles’s fortunes take another hit as his girlfriend, Amy, has stopped answering his texts. We learn about the life of Amanda P

Episode 3 - The Third Episode Dec 8, 2025 1249 Send us Fan MailCharles is thrilled to announce new sponsors for the podcast, including Amanda’s company Shady Grove Pudding, now both “Proud sponsors and victims of The Murderer Killings.” The investigation of Margaret Mandragora-Jones intensifies, as does her contempt for everyone around her. Deputy Sheriff Branigan trains her sites on two other suspects: Amanda’s estranged husband and Amanda’s

Episode 2 - The Second Episode Dec 8, 2025 1194 Send us Fan MailCharlie dives deep on the history of Shady Grove, and its beloved pudding foundry, which has supported and shaped the community for over a century, and is far more interesting than it sounds. More murders and corruption of the past begin to haunt the present. Prostitutes are briefly discussed. Members of the town offer their help, and the local police department struggles to find a

Episode 1 - The First Episode Dec 8, 2025 1493 Send us Fan MailA triple-homicide in a small rural community leaves more questions than answers. On a tip, Charlie Incarica decides to use his expiring airline miles, embed with a shaken community, and with any luck, make True Crime podcast history.Thanks for listening. Check out the TMK merch at:https://the-murderer-killings-a-true-crime-podcast-shop.fourthwall.com/

The Murderer Killings Podcast: Season 1 Trailer Nov 21, 2025 90 Send us Fan Mail"Follow" to be the first to hear what the New York Times would likely say is "The last True Crime podcast you'll ever listen to."Thanks for listening. Check out the TMK merch at:https://the-murderer-killings-a-true-crime-podcast-shop.fourthwall.com/

The Murderer Killings - A True* Crime Podcast

Episodes

Recommended