Hidden True Crime
Hidden True Crime is a podcast hosted by journalist Lauren Matthias and forensic psychologist Dr. John Matthias. It delves into the hidden motives, relationships, beliefs, and psychology behind compelling criminal cases. Lauren brings a decade of television reporting experience, while Dr. John has conducted psychological evaluations since 1996 and serves as an expert witness. The show is intended for educational and commentary purposes, based on publicly available information and professional opinion.
Episodes
21 Babies, a $3 Million Mansion & the Secret Nobody Was Supposed to See | Surrogacy House of Horrors
Twenty-one children. A $3.2 million mansion. And surrogates who say the family they helped create was nothing like the one they were promised.
In this episode of Hidden True Crime, Lauren Matthias examines the disturbing Arcadia, California, “house of horrors” case involving Guojun and Silvia Shasha Zhang. Prosecutors allege the pair participated in child abuse, concealed an infant’s injuries, an
A Friend Request. A Missing 7-Year-Old. What Every Parent Needs to Know
A Facebook friend request. A mother who blocked him. A 7-year-old who never made it home from her school bus. Hidden True Crime’s Lauren Matthias examines the Joseph Andrew Bragg case in Zimmerman, Minnesota—and the disturbing allegations every parent needs to understand. Through charging documents, reported messages, and accounts from families, we explore how Bragg allegedly sought access to chil
Could the Holdout Controversy Stop a Second Trial? | Lindsay Clancy
The Lindsay Clancy case is far from over after a mistrial and an 11–1 jury split. Hidden True Crime’s Lauren Matthias breaks down the post-trial hearing, Judge Sullivan’s denial of the defense’s request for a finding of not guilty, and Kevin Reddington’s surprising argument questioning whether prosecutors proved Clancy killed her three children, Cora, Dawson and Callan. We also examine the separat
Caleb Flynn Is GUILTY—But These Questions Won’t Go Away
Why did Caleb Flynn’s defense point the finger at his mistress—and where is the missing gun? Hidden True Crime breaks down the final courtroom showdown in the Caleb Flynn murder trial, from the defense’s accusations to the prosecution’s rebuttal and the jury’s guilty verdict in the killing of his wife, Ashley Flynn. The former American Idol contestant’s affair, chilling text messages, Apple Watch
The “American Idol Murder” Trial: The FULL Backstory & Bombshell First Week | Caleb Flynn
The murder trial of Caleb Flynn is underway in Ohio, seven months after his wife, Ashley Flynn, was found shot to death in their home while their two young daughters slept nearby. In this episode of Hidden True Crime, Lauren Matthias breaks down the full Caleb Flynn and Ashley Flynn backstory and the first explosive week of testimony, including Caleb’s past appearance on *American Idol*, his secre
I Was in Court for Richard Allen’s Appeal- What the Cameras Missed | Delphi Murders
Richard Allen is appealing his convictions for the murders of Abby Williams and Libby German, and Hidden True Crime was inside the courtroom as the Indiana Court of Appeals heard oral arguments in the Delphi murders case. Lauren Matthias breaks down what happened inside the hearing as appellate judges questioned Allen’s defense attorneys and the State about his confessions, the lack of a tradition
The Holdout Juror SPEAKS — And The Defense’s fight to Stop a Retrial for Lindsay Clancy
Lauren Matthias of Hidden True Crime breaks down the stunning aftermath of the Lindsay Clancy mistrial, including what jurors say happened during the contentious 11–1 deliberations, the holdout juror’s newly revealed side of the story, and the disturbing controversy surrounding his identity and background. We examine the conflicting claims about reasonable doubt, the juror questionnaire, and the e
Her Final Messages Were About Lindsay Clancy—Hours Later, Her Son Was Dead | Corie Walsh Full Story
Lauren Matthias examines the disturbing Corie Walsh case after the Illinois mother was accused of murdering her 2-year-old son, Barrett “Bear” Walsh—just hours after reportedly sending frantic messages about the Lindsay Clancy trial. What happened inside the family’s Frankfort home, why did Corie allegedly call her toddler the “devil” and “Antichrist,” and was her fixation on Lindsay Clancy connec
A Family Vacation, a Missing Tracker & Two Parents Arrested | Saylor Hayes Full Backstory
On Hidden True Crime, investigative journalist Lauren Matthias takes you inside the heartbreaking case of five-year-old Saylor Hayes, who disappeared during a family vacation in Pawleys Island, South Carolina, and was later found dead in the Waccamaw River. Lauren breaks down the disturbing questions surrounding Saylor’s missing Project Lifesaver tracker, the 911 call, her parents’ account of what
The Experts Couldn’t Agree — Psychologist Dr. John Matthias Breaks Down WHY | Lindsay Clancy Trial
The Lindsay Clancy trial ended in a mistrial, but one of the biggest questions remains: how could the psychologists and psychiatrists who evaluated Lindsay Clancy reach such different conclusions? Hidden True Crime’s Lauren Matthias sits down with clinical and forensic psychologist Dr. John Matthias to examine the conflicting expert testimony surrounding Lindsay’s mental state, alleged psychosis,
ONE JUROR: Inside the 11–1 Split That Derailed the Lindsay Clancy Trial Into a Mistrial
The Lindsay Clancy trial has ended in a mistrial after seven days of deliberations—and Lauren Matthias breaks down the explosive 11–1 jury split, the holdout juror accused of refusing to properly apply reasonable doubt, and the defense’s emergency appeal to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court. We examine the heated courtroom exchanges, Kevin Reddington’s claim that the jury was “robbed by one
She Escaped Samuel Bateman’s Cult—Then Came a Message From Warren Jeffs | Nomz Tells All
In this exclusive interview, Lauren sits down with Nomz from the documentary Trust Me: A False Prophet to discuss growing up in the FLDS, being recruited into Samuel Bateman’s cult, and the events that led to her spending time in prison after Bateman’s arrest. Nomz also reveals a message she received from convicted FLDS leader Warren Jeffs and reflects on reclaiming her voice. At the end of the ep
Lindsay Clancy’s Defense Comes Out Swinging—Prosecution Fires Back | Closing Arguments
Lindsay Clancy’s fate goes to the jury—and Lauren Matthias breaks down the sharply conflicting closing arguments on Hidden True Crime. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington attacks the investigation and the prosecution’s psychiatric experts, arguing that severe mental illness left Clancy not criminally responsible for the deaths of Cora, Dawson, and Callan. Prosecutor Jennifer Sprague argues that Clan
EXCLUSIVE: I had Postpartum Psychosis and Intrusive Thoughts--I was scared | Lindsay Clancy Case
In this exclusive interview, Lauren Matthias sits down with a mother who experienced terrifying intrusive thoughts and postpartum psychosis—and lived through symptoms strikingly similar to some of what Lindsay Clancy has described. What do intrusive thoughts actually feel like? Can you recognize that the thoughts are horrifying and still be unable to make them stop? And what happens when postpartu
FBI Psychiatrist Says Lindsay Clancy KNEW What She Was Doing — Defense Fights Back | Days 21 & 22
Lauren Matthias breaks down Days 21 and 22 of the Lindsay Clancy trial as the Commonwealth’s rebuttal case comes to a close with critical testimony from its final experts. FBI senior psychiatrist Dr. Gregory Saathoff challenged key parts of Clancy’s account, including the command voice she says told her to kill her three children, and testified that he believed she was criminally responsible and c
Judge REPRIMANDS Prosecution After Lindsay Clancy “Mortal Sin” Testimony — Mistrial Denied | Day 19
The Lindsay Clancy trial took a dramatic turn on Day 19 as the prosecution continued its rebuttal case. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington finished his contentious cross-examination of psychiatrist Dr. Avram Mack, challenging his experience, his evaluation of Clancy nearly three years after the killings, and his conclusions about postpartum depression, postpartum psychosis and criminal responsibili
Two Psychiatrists, Two VERY Different Conclusions About Lindsay Clancy | Trial Day 18
Lauren Matthias breaks down a pivotal Day 18 of the Lindsay Clancy trial as the defense and prosecution present sharply conflicting psychiatric opinions about Lindsay’s mental state on January 24, 2023. Renowned forensic psychiatrist Dr. Phillip Resnick — who testified in both Andrea Yates trials and has evaluated dozens of filicide cases — told jurors he believed Lindsay was suffering from bipola
Chaplain Reveals What Lindsay Clancy Told Her About THE VOICE | Trial Day 16 & 17
Lauren Matthias breaks down a pivotal Day 16 and 17 of the Lindsay Clancy trial as testimony about the mysterious “voice” Lindsay says she heard takes a dramatic turn. Hospital chaplain Sheila Cavanaugh testified that Lindsay told her shortly after the deaths of Cora, Dawson and Callan that a male voice commanded her to act and warned that she and her children would not be safe if she didn’t compl
Forensic Psychologist Takes the Stand in Lindsay Clancy Trial - Interview with Dr Leslie Dobson
Forensic and clinical psychologist Dr. Leslie Dobson joins Lauren Matthias of Hidden True Crime to examine the Lindsay Clancy case, including the critical questions surrounding postpartum mental health, psychosis, insomnia, medications, and Lindsay’s state of mind. With more than 20 years of experience, Dr. Dobson has worked in private practice, court-ordered psychological evaluations, the Los Ang
Psychiatrist Reveals ALARMING Signs in Lindsay Clancy’s Medical Records | Trial Day 15
Lauren Matthias breaks down a dramatic Day 15 of the Lindsay Clancy trial as the defense calls psychiatrist Dr. Donald Condi to examine Lindsay’s mental health treatment, escalating symptoms and extensive medication history before the deaths of Cora, Dawson and Callan. Condi testified about severe insomnia, depression, dissociation, feeling detached from reality, possible medication “activation,”
Lindsay Clancy’s Mom Reveals CHILLING Warning Before the Killings | Trial Day 14
Lauren Matthias breaks down a dramatic Day 14 of the Lindsay Clancy trial as the prosecution RESTS and the defense begins calling witnesses—including Lindsay’s former coworker, sister and mother. In emotional testimony, Lindsay’s mother revealed that weeks before the deaths of Cora, Dawson and Callan, Lindsay told her and Patrick that she was having thoughts of harming the children. Jurors also he
Criminal Psychologist REACTS to Lindsay Clancy: Did She Know What She Was Doing?
Lauren Matthias and Dr. John Matthias take a deep dive into the Lindsay Clancy case and the question at the heart of her trial: was Lindsay suffering from postpartum psychosis when she killed her three children, or did she understand exactly what she was doing? Dr. Matthias weighs the psychiatric testimony, Lindsay’s behavior, her state of mind, and the evidence presented at trial to examine the
Inside Lindsay Clancy’s Phone: What She Searched & Texted Before the Killings | Trial Day 13
**This episode was recorded LIVE with minimal editing.
Day 13 of the Lindsay Clancy trial brought jurors deep inside the digital evidence, including a shocking “Suicide Methods” webpage found in data extracted from a computer seized from the Clancy home—but the forensic examiner could not say who was actually using the computer when the page was accessed. Jurors also saw evidence recovered from
Lindsay Clancy WAILS in Court as Autopsy Details Emerge - Judge Pauses Trial | Day 12
Lauren Matthias is here to break down Day 12 of the Lindsay Clancy trial which came to an emotional halt as the medical examiner detailed the autopsies of Cora and Dawson Clancy and jurors were shown photographs documenting their injuries. Lindsay began wailing in the courtroom, becoming so distraught that the judge called a break. The day also brought stunning testimony from a Massachusetts State
“I Feel Like I'm Going to Die” | Lindsay Clancy’s DISTURBING Messages Revealed | Trial Day 11
* This episode was recorded live and we are working out some audio issues in a newly redone studio :)
Lauren Matthias is here to break down Day 11 of the Lindsay Clancy trial, where jurors heard some of the most alarming evidence yet about Clancy’s deteriorating mental health in the weeks before the deaths of her three children. Psychiatric nurse practitioner Rebecca Jollotta walked jurors thr
Psychiatrist GRILLED in BRUTAL Cross-Examination | Lindsay Clancy Trial Day 10
Day 10 of the Lindsay Clancy trial brought an intense cross-examination of psychiatrist Dr. Jennifer Tufts, who treated Lindsay in the months leading up to the deaths of her three children. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington questioned Tufts about all 14 appointments being conducted virtually, her experience treating postpartum mental health conditions, Lindsay’s worsening depression and suicidal t
Susan Smith's Prosecutor Reveals What Still Haunts Him 30 Years Later
In this exclusive interview, I sit down with Tommy Pope, the prosecutor who helped convict Susan Smith, to revisit one of the most infamous murder cases in American history and examine its striking parallels to the Lindsay Clancy trial. Pope takes us inside the Susan Smith case, the prosecution’s fight to prove why a mother killed her own children, and the evidence and arguments that ultimately le
24 HOURS BEFORE THE KILLINGS: Lindsay Clancy’s Psychiatrist Reveals What She Saw | Day 9
*This episode was originally recorded live with minimal editing
The Lindsay Clancy trial continued with critical testimony from the psychiatrist who saw Lindsay just 24 hours before the deaths of her three children. On Day 9, jurors heard what Lindsay’s psychiatrist observed during one of the final appointments before the January 24, 2023 tragedy, including her mental state, treatment, medication
Lindsay Clancy SOBS as Son’s AUTOPSY Is Revealed in Court | Trial Day 7 and 8
**This episode was originally recorded live with minimal editing.
About Hidden True Crime
What started as a simple conversation at their dinner table became a captivating podcast. Join the dynamic duo of Dr. John Matthias, a criminal psychologist, and Lauren Matthias, an investigative journalist, as they delve into the psychological facets of unthinkable crimes every week. Their unique perspect
Inside the Courtroom: Does Blood Spatter Analysis Help the Defense—or State? | Lindsay Clancy Day 6
Lindsay Soeaks & Forensic experts, & blood stain analysis took center stage in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial as jurors heard critical testimony about blood evidence, toxicology, DNA, prescription medications, and the crime scene investigation. Reporting inside the courtroom, Lauren Matthias breaks down testimony from trauma surgeons, Massachusetts State Police investigators, crime scene analyst
EXPLOSIVE New Details Emerge as Bryan Kohberger Fights to Remove His Plea and Defense Expert Speaks
Bryan Kohberger is trying to take back his guilty plea in the University of Idaho murders, claiming he was coerced into confessing and is actually innocent. Lauren Matthias breaks down Kohberger's newly filed post-conviction petition, his first public interview since pleading guilty, the handwritten affidavit, and what legal experts believe his chances are of ever getting a new trial. We also exam
Inside the Courtroom: Psychiatrists Testify. Lindsay's Journals Tell Their Own Story | Clancy Day 5
Day 5 of the Lindsay Clancy murder trial delivered some of the most emotional and closely watched testimony yet. Reporting inside the courtroom, Lauren Matthias takes you through the powerful testimony from psychiatrists, emergency physicians, ICU nurses, investigators, and Massachusetts State Police as the jury heard evidence surrounding Lindsay Clancy's mental state, medical treatment, and the i
EXCLUSIVE Interview: Andrea Yates' Attorney Has Closely Followed the Lindsay Clancy Trial - His Take
George Parnham, the attorney who defended Andrea Yates, joins Lauren Matthias at Hidden True Crime for an exclusive interview to discuss the Lindsay Clancy trial after following the case closely. Parnham shares his perspective on postpartum psychosis, criminal responsibility, the similarities and differences between the Yates and Clancy cases, and what he believes the evidence reveals. Whether you
Inside the Courtroom: Blood Evidence, Hospital Testimony & a Jury Fieldtrip | Lindsay Clancy Day 4
Day 4 of the Lindsay Clancy murder trial brought the jury back inside the courtroom after a morning site visit to the Clancy home. I was there for every moment as jurors heard testimony from the first detective to see Lindsay at the hospital, officers who guarded her for more than 16 hours after her arrest, emergency physicians who desperately tried to save Dawson and Callan, and hospital staff wh
Police, Paramedics & Firefighters Describe the Horror | Lindsay Clancy Day 3
Day 3 of the Lindsay Clancy trial- Lauren Matthias was inside the courtroom as police officers, firefighters, paramedics, and EMTs took the stand, each describing the chaotic moments they arrived at the Clancy home and the desperate efforts to save Lindsay and her three children. We also saw the prosecution continue building its case witness by witness, while the defense challenged key details su
I Was Inside the Courtroom: HORRIFYING 911 Call & Crime Scene Evidence | Lindsay Clancy Trial Day 2
Official audio for day 2! So sorry if you caught the audio mixup!
I was inside the courtroom today while Patrick Clancy's 911 call was played for the jury. Tonight I will recap everything that I experienced... From what I heard, to how jurors reacted, and what I saw and heard Lindsay Clancy do as that call was played. Plus we will break down every other moment in court today- from the crime scen
"I would've done ANYTHING" -Patrick Clancy | Lindsay Clancy Opening Statements -Inside the Courtroom
The Lindsay Clancy trial is officially underway, and I was inside the courtroom for every moment of Day 1. From explosive opening statements to Patrick Clancy's highly anticipated testimony, I'll take you beyond the headlines and inside the courtroom to break down what the jury saw, what stood out, and what it could mean as this closely watched trial unfolds.
About Hidden True Crime
What started
Inside the Lindsay Clancy Trial: The Battle Before Opening Statements
The Lindsay Clancy trial is officially underway, and before a single witness has testified, the courtroom is already erupting with high-stakes clashes over evidence, expert witnesses, the haunting 911 call, autopsy photos, and the defense's postpartum psychosis strategy. In this episode, we break down everything that happened during the first week of trial—from explosive exchanges between prosecut
5 Psychological Secrets Criminals Don't Want You to Know | Criminal Psychologist Explains
Have you ever wondered what traits make up a criminal? Oftentimes our minds go straight to words like "evil", "psychopath", or "insane"... But the answer isn't that simple. In this episode, Dr. John Matthias explores five psychological traits that often appear in criminal offenders—and why understanding them can help us make sense of some of the most disturbing crimes. Drawing from decades of clin
Lindsay Clancy Deep Dive | EVERYTHING You Need to Know Ahead of the Trial- Murder or Mentally Ill?
A mother. Three children. One of the most heartbreaking criminal cases in America. As jury selection begins in the Lindsay Clancy trial, Hidden True Crime takes an in-depth look at everything that happened before the deaths of Cora, Dawson, and Callan Clancy. Beyond the headlines, we examine Lindsay Clancy's months-long mental health decline through medical records, psychiatric evaluations, medica
Murder or Mistake? Breaking Down the Timeline in the Mysterious Death of Nolan Wells | FULL STORY
An 18-year-old football player leaves for a Fourth of July trip with friends... but never comes home. Two days later, Nolan Wells is found dead on a remote Mississippi barrier island, and what should have been a straightforward investigation quickly becomes a mystery filled with conflicting timelines, unanswered questions, and growing public scrutiny. In this episode, Lauren Matthias breaks down e
EXCLUSIVE: Scott Peterson's Attorney Tells All as New Doc Makes Shocking Claims | Mark Geragos
Mark Geragos joins Lauren Matthias to discuss representing Scott Peterson & the all new Two-Part Documentary “Scott Peterson: The New Evidence” premiering July 16th and 17th on A&E. Mark takes Lauren inside the case- from the evidence he thinks would have changed the whole case, to where things stand now, this interview is a deep dive just ahead of the new documentary's release.
Sponsor
Min
DERANGED Parents Dissolve Little Girl & Report Her Missing Weeks Later? | Javeayah Harris Full Story
A frantic 911 call. A missing 4-year-old girl. Hundreds of law enforcement officers searching thousands of acres. Then, in a devastating twist, investigators say the entire story was a lie. In this episode, Lauren Matthias breaks down the shocking case of Javeayah Harris, including the 911 call, family interviews, court documents, arrest warrants, confessions, and the disturbing evidence that led
DISTURBING Details Emerge as 16 Kids Rescued From Ohio House of Horrors | Siders Family Full Story
Sixteen children were allegedly hidden from the outside world for years inside a tiny Ohio home investigators say was filled with human waste, garbage, insects, and conditions they described as "third world." Authorities say some of the children couldn't communicate, one was fighting for their life, and neighbors had no idea they were there. But the deeper this investigation goes, the more disturb
Hoarder Parents Charged After 255 lb 7-Year-Old Found Dead with "Feral" Sister in Home | FULL Story
A healthy 7-year-old boy somehow grew to 255 pounds, became bedridden, covered in infected bedsores, and died before anyone intervened. Now, his parents face second-degree murder, torture, and ch*ld ab*se charges. In this episode, Lauren Matthias examines the heartbreaking death of Casper O'Brien, the police investigation, medical records, 911 call, and newly released court documents to uncover ho
BREAKING: Judge in Kouri Richins Trial Recuses Himself While Defense Demands Redo because of Bias
Kouri Richins wants her murder conviction thrown out—and now the judge who presided over her trial has stepped aside while another judge decides what happens next. In a sweeping motion for a new trial, Kouri's attorneys accuse the court of judicial bias, claim prosecutors violated pretrial rulings, and argue the jury was unfairly influenced from start to finish. Today, we're breaking down every ma
EXCLUSIVE: "He's a Buffoon". - Samuel Bateman Juror Doesn't Hold Back | False Prophet Trial
What was it really like to sit just feet away from Samuel Bateman throughout his trial? In this exclusive interview, we speak with a juror who shares what the jury saw, what stood out during testimony, and how they weighed the evidence before reaching a verdict. From Bateman representing himself in court to the emotional testimony from witnesses and victims, we go behind the scenes of one of the m
Sam Bateman Defends Himself: Wife Testifies & Closing Arguments | Day 3
*This episode was originally recorded live. There was minimal editing done to it. *
One of Samuel Bateman's wives took the stand in his defense before Bateman delivered his own closing argument directly to the jury in one of the trial's most unusual moments. In this full Day 3 recap, we break down her testimony, Bateman's final attempt to persuade the jury, the prosecution's response, and the key
Samuel Bateman Takes the Stand on Day 2 of Trial
*This episode was originally recorded live and post verdict. There was minimal editing done to it. *
Samuel Bateman took the stand in his own defense, giving testimony that left many in the courtroom stunned. In this full Day 2 recap, we break down Bateman's claims, the prosecution's cross-examination, and key moments the jury heard.
Sponsor:
Goodr-Head to https://goodr.com/HIDDEN to claim
DRAMATIC Opening Statements and Child Victims Testify | Samuel Bateman Trial Day 1 Full Recap
***This episode was recorded live and minimally edited.**
The trial of Samuel Bateman is officially underway—and Day 1 was explosive. In this full courtroom recap, we break down Bateman's shocking opening statement as he tells jurors he's "kind and gentle" and would never harm a child, despite the allegations against him. We also cover emotional testimony from the three child survivors found insi
The Viral LEGO Scandal: We Put the Whole Story in Order So You Don’t Have To
How did a missing LEGO collection worth up to $200,000 spiral into lawsuits, arrests, police corruption allegations, and a nationwide internet firestorm? In this complete investigation, Lauren Matthias breaks down the viral Reckless Ben vs. Bricks & Minifigs saga from beginning to end—covering Bryan Mansell’s missing Star Wars LEGO collection, the role of Bricks & Minifigs, shocking bodycam footag
BREAKING: Joseph Duggar DENIED Unsupervised Access to His Children
BREAKING: Joseph Duggar has been denied unsupervised access to his children—and the reason why may be even more significant than the ruling itself. In a brief but revealing Florida hearing, the judge repeatedly referenced ongoing Arkansas criminal proceedings, child welfare investigations, and active supervision plans involving Joseph and Kendra Duggar's family. What started as a request for unsup
What Netflix Left Out of ‘Maternal Instinct’ | Taylor Parker Unmasked by Criminal Psychologist
Taylor Parker spent months convincing everyone around her that she was pregnant. The lie would end in one of the most shocking and disturbing crimes in recent history. In this episode, forensic psychologist Dr. John Matthias reacts to Netflix's 'Maternal Instinct', breaking down Taylor Parker's psychology, reported diagnoses, compulsive deception, and the motivations that may have led to the murde
She Wanted Out. Investigators Say He Wouldn’t Let Her Leave | Angela Whitaker FULL STORY
A missing mother sends one final message: "If I don't get away from here, I know it will be bad."* Days later, she's gone. Investigators say Angela Whitaker moved hundreds of miles for a job opportunity and a fresh start. Instead, they allege she became trapped in a nightmare that ended on a remote mountainside. An ex-fiancée comes forward with explosive claims. A secret trip into the woods. Concr
Nick Reiner DEMANDS Million Dollars from Trust & Alan Jackson Ready to Rejoin Defense if Money Comes
A shocking new court filing in the Nick Reiner case may reveal why celebrity defense attorney Alan Jackson abruptly withdrew just weeks after declaring, “Nick Reiner is not guilty of murder. Print that.” In this episode, Lauren breaks down the latest legal battle surrounding the son of Rob Reiner and Michele Singer Reiner, who is accused of murdering both of his parents in their Brentwood home in
Psychologist Reacts: The Warning Signs Everyone Missed | Marcia Norman Case
This episode originally premiered on May 18, 2025, but as the case against Jeffrey Zizz moves closer to trial, it feels more important than ever to revisit.
Marcia Norman deserved to grow old surrounded by her family, grandchildren, friends, and the life she built. Instead, prosecutors allege she was targeted by a man she trusted.
In this episode, forensic psychologist Dr. John Matthias examines
A Missing Grandmother, a Secret Obsession, and a Man Nobody Suspected
A year after the disappearance and murder of 82-year-old Marcia Norman shocked Washington State, Hidden True Crime returns with a major update—and troubling new questions about whether justice will truly be served. In this episode, Lauren Matthias examines newly obtained court documents, witness statements, digital evidence, and jail calls that paint an even darker picture of what investigators al
The Nightmare Upstairs: When Abuse Allegations Collide with Custody Battles | Psychologist Reacts
Lauren Matthias and forensic psychologist Dr. John Matthias react to the new documentary The Nightmare Upstairs and explore the difficult questions at the center of the case. Beyond the documentary itself, we discuss family abuse, child disclosures, parental alienation, custody battles, trauma, and why these cases can be so challenging for courts and professionals to navigate. What happens when ch
Utah Father Goes on the Run With 2 Babies After Alleged Escape Plan | Dane Richman
Today on Hidden True Crime, Lauren Matthias covers the urgent and actively unfolding disappearance of two young brothers — Will Richman and Wesley Richman — who authorities believe were abducted by their father, Dane Richman, during a bitter custody dispute. Investigators say the case involves alarming warning signs including financial collapse, emotional instability, an abandoned home, possible o
Mackenzie Shirilla Unmasked | The DARK Psychology Behind Netflix’s ‘The Crash’
Dr. John, a forensic psychologist, reacts to The Crash and breaks down the disturbing psychology behind Mackenzie Shirilla — the Ohio teen convicted after driving her car into a wall at 100 mph, killing her boyfriend and another friend. While Netflix explores the case itself, this episode goes deeper into the relationship dynamics, emotional possession, attachment, control, and psychological warni
The Most Controversial Filing Yet in Joseph Duggar’s Case
In this episode of Hidden True Crime, Lauren Matthias breaks down the latest shocking developments involving Joseph Duggar after his team appeared for a brief arraignment in Florida on child crime charges involving a minor. But the real story may not be the two-minute hearing itself… it’s the explosive pretrial motions happening behind the scenes. Lauren unpacks the allegations tied to a 2020 fami
She Married an Inmate on Death Row… Then Watched Him Die | Tiana Broadnax Interview
In this deeply emotional and psychologically complex interview, Tiana Broadnax speaks out about marrying James Broadnax while he was on death row — and what it was like to witness his execution two weeks after the wedding.
Tiana describes falling in love with a man convicted of double murder, fighting for his innocence, navigating the stigma of marrying a death row inmate, and ultimately watching
Facial Expressions, Body Language,& What Kouri Richins’ Speech REALLY Revealed | Psychologist Reacts
Just before being sentenced for the murder of her husband, Eric Richins, Kouri Richins addressed the court in a dramatic sentencing statement that left many people questioning what was real, what was strategic, and what it revealed about her state of mind. In this episode, Lauren Matthias and forensic psychologist Dr. John Matthias break down Kouri’s sentencing speech, the heartbreaking victim imp
Kouri’s WILD Statement After Sons Say They Fear Her | Richins Sentencing
** This episode was originally recorded live.
Kouri Richins has finally learned her fate after being convicted of murdering her husband Eric Richins in March of 2022
Sponsors:
Brodo: Head to https://brodo.com/HTC for 20% off your first subscription order and use code HTC for an additional $10 off.
First Day Life: Get up to 57% off and a free gift with code HIDDEN at https://FirstDay.com. #a
Kouri Richin’s Sons Speak Out Before Her Sentencing
In this episode of Hidden True Crime, Lauren Matthias breaks down the explosive filing in the Kouri Richins case, including chilling new allegations about the murder of Eric Richins, the state’s argument that Kouri “learned” from her first failed poisoning attempt, and the heartbreaking impact this case has had on the couple’s three young sons. Prosecutors reveal emotional statements from the chil
“She Was Already Dead” | Prosecutors Reveal Chilling Timeline in Celeste Rivas Hernandez and D4VD Case
Prosecutors say they now know exactly what happened to 14-year-old Celeste Rivas Hernandez — and the chilling timeline they’ve laid out against David Burke is more disturbing than many imagined. In this episode of Hidden True Crime, Lauren Matthias breaks down explosive new court filings.
Sponsor
ASPCA Pet Health Insurance: Explore coverage at https://www.aspcapetinsurance.com/HIDDEN
About
“She Fought Until the End” | Haunting Closings & Verdict for Tanner Horner in Athena Strand Trial
In this emotional and disturbing breakdown, Lauren Matthias walks through the defense’s final attempt to explain Tanner’s behavior through trauma, autism spectrum traits, fetal alcohol exposure, and childhood neglect… before the prosecution delivers a devastating rebuttal witness from Tanner’s own past. We unpack the expert testimony, the battle over future dangerousness, the prosecution and defen
Behind the Prophet: Samuel Bateman’s Rise to Power & What Netflix Missed
Secrets, power, and belief—this episode unpacks the disturbing rise of Samuel Bateman and the system that allowed his abuse to flourish. From the origins of the FLDS and the influence of leaders like Warren Jeffs, to the isolation and unchecked authority that created an environment ripe for manipulation, we explore how control takes hold—and why it’s so hard to break free. At the center is Christi
DISTURBING New Details Just Revealed in Court by Tanner's Own Experts | Athena Strand Trial Recap
It's week 4 of the Tanner Horner trial and Lauren Matthias is here with all of the updates. The defense has now spent weeks trying to explain Tanner Horner—his autism, trauma, mental health, and the life that shaped him—but their own expert made something clear: he knew right from wrong, and the crime itself was horrific. In this episode, we break down the second week of defense testimony in the m
Tanner Horner Unmasked — The Psychology Behind the Athena Strand Case
Dr. John Matthias, a criminal psychologist, breaks down the penalty phase of the capital murder trial of Tanner Horner, the man convicted of killing 7-year-old Athena Strand. In this episode, we analyze emotional testimony from family members, claims of generational trauma, autism, and brain abnormalities, and the science presented to explain behavior. But do these factors actually help explain wh
Did the Defense Help Tanner Horner… or Hurt Him? Brain Scans, Trauma & Key Testimony | Athena Strand
The defense begins in the capital murder trial of Tanner Horner, shifting the focus from the devastating final moments of 7-year-old Athena Strand to the life and mind of the man who killed her. In this episode of Hidden True Crime, Lauren breaks down emotional testimony from family members detailing generational trauma, addiction, and instability, alongside expert witnesses who introduce complex
Before “Trust Me”… She Lived It | A True Story of Belief, Control & a False Prophet | Dr Christine
With Netflix’s “Trust Me: A False Prophet” topping charts worldwide, many are just now learning about the rise and fall of Samuel Bateman. But years before that documentary, Dr. Christine Marie sat in my home and shared her own story of a false prophet.
This interview—recorded six years ago—remains one of the most powerful conversations I’ve ever had.
Because this isn’t just a story about one ma
BREAKING: Autopsy Reveals Mutilation as “Significant” Phone Evidence Emerges in Celeste Case | D4VD
The autopsy report is finally in—and the details are devastating. In this episode of Hidden True Crime, Lauren breaks down the official cause of death of Celeste Rivas Hernandez, along with newly released evidence, courtroom revelations, and disturbing findings prosecutors say build their case against David Anthony Burke aka D4VD.
Sponsor:
Rocket Money- Let Rocket Money help you reach your fina
BOMBSHELL Evidence Exposes "HORRIFIC" Plan to Silence Celeste Rivas Hernandez | D4VD Case
A 14-year-old girl leaves home—and never comes back. In this episode of Hidden True Crime, Lauren breaks down the shocking case of Celeste Abigail Rivas Hernandez and the arrest of rising musician David Anthony Burke, who now faces charges including first-degree murder, continuous SA of a child, and mutilation of human remains. What began as an online connection between a young fan and a rising ar
Courtroom Audio Made Jurors SOB… Then Prosecution Rests | Athena Strand Trial
This week on Hidden True Crime, we break down the devastating capital murder trial of Tanner Horner, the man who has pleaded guilty to the kidnapping and murder of 7-year-old Athena Strand. With the prosecution now resting, jurors have been forced to sit through some of the most disturbing evidence imaginable—including chilling audio from inside the delivery truck where Athena spent her final mome
Kendra’s Family Speaks Out — Warns of “Retaliation” | Joseph Duggar Case
Breaking developments in the case of Joseph Duggar—as the Caldwell family breaks their silence and a family friend drops a stunning public statement that could change everything. In this episode, Lauren unpacks the escalating tension between the Duggars and the Caldwells, new allegations surrounding the handling of a child victim, and the growing questions about control, loyalty, and accountabilit
From Nu Skin Wealth to a Horrific Murder | The Summer Roney Case
Last year, Hidden True Crime introduced you to Summer Roney—a vulnerable young woman whose brutal murder shocked those who heard her story. Now, we’re going deeper. In this episode, Lauren Matthias uncovers disturbing new developments surrounding Summer’s life, her abuse at the hands of Robert McKell, and the ongoing case against her accused killer, Jacob Johnson—a case that appears to be stalling
Gone at Sea... Bahama Mystery Deepens | EVERYTHING You Need to Know about Brian & Lynette Hooker
What began as a tragic accident at sea is quickly unraveling into something far more complicated. In this episode of Hidden True Crime, Lauren breaks down the disappearance of Lynette Hooker, who vanished off the coast of the Bahamas during a nighttime dinghy ride with her husband, Brian Hooker—the only witness to what happened. As his story shifts, troubling details emerge: conflicting accounts,
Kendra Duggar TURNS on Her Family... & Jim Bob’s “Terrible Decision” Regarding Joseph Sparks Debate
A single line from a jail call—about kicking her own family out—opens the door to something much bigger. In this episode of Hidden True Crime, Lauren breaks down explosive new details in the case of Joseph Duggar, including his release on bond, the mounting legal pressure on both him and his wife Kendra, and the unraveling relationship with the Caldwell family—who may also be at the center of the
FedEx Delivers a Christmas Nightmare | Athena Strand -Full Story
*After this recording, and on the morning of the trial, Tanner Horner plead guilty to the murder of Athena Strand. The trial must continue on, despite the plea, so that the jury can decide whether or not Tanner will receive the death penalty.
A FedEx delivery. A quiet rural home. And within days, a confession that would devastate an entire community. In this episode of Hidden True Crime, Lauren
