Home Podcasts Controversies in Church History
Controversies in Church History

Controversies in Church History

Darrick N Taylor 135 Episodes Jul 5, 2026

In this podcast, host Darrick Taylor explores difficult and even disturbing issues in the history of the Catholic Church. As a faithful Roman Catholic trained as a secular historian, Taylor brings a unique perspective to each topic. The show is designed for Catholics but remains accessible to anyone interested in religious history. It combines engaging storytelling with an academic approach to historical controversies.

Episodes

ReView: The Problem of Unbelief in the Sixteenth Century
ReView: The Problem of Unbelief in the Sixteenth Century Jul 5, 2026 00:40:21 Hello friends! The latest episode episode of Controversies in Church History is a replay of what was originally a patron-only episode for patrons on Patreon, which I now make available to everyone. In it, I take a look at a work of history written nearly a hundred years ago, The Problem of Unbelief in the Sixteenth Century, by Lucien Febvre, a French historian who published his book during the dar
Charting the Crisis in the Church: an Interview with James Green
Charting the Crisis in the Church: an Interview with James Green Jun 15, 2026 02:09:38 The latest episode of Controversies in Church History is an interview with James Green, a Catholic teacher and writer. James has penned a series of articles at his Substack taking a closer look at the data on vocations, church attendance and other data on key indicators in the Catholic Church before and since the Second Vatican Council. In our discussion, which is a long one, we look at the impact
Charles de Gaulle and Vatican II
Charles de Gaulle and Vatican II Mar 12, 2026 00:27:05 Originally a bonus episode for patrons of the podcast, this episode takes a look at some of Charles De Gaulle's recorded opinions concerning the Second Vatican Council. De Gaulle led the Free French forces during WWII and served ten years as president of France (1958-1968). De Gaulle had a keen political sense and his comments on Vatican II are both interesting but also prescient. Enjoy.
What We've Been Reading 2025 (ish)
What We've Been Reading 2025 (ish) Feb 15, 2026 00:47:50 The latest episode is a walk-through of what yours truly has been the past year (or so), and gives an update on upcoming episodes and their content (hint: there will be new episodes and they will be awesome). Cheers!
Did Pius IX Create Pope Francis?
Did Pius IX Create Pope Francis? Jan 23, 2026 00:33:26 Hello everyone! Controversies in Church History is back after a long hiatus, and we are bringing you an episode about two popes: Pius IX and Francis. We dive into the question of whether the centralization of power in the papacy that began under Pius IX (1848-1878) led to the reign of the late Pope Francis (2013-2025), and whether Pius IX can be said to be responsible for it. Also, I update the st
Interview: the Council of Nicaea with Ben Wyatt
Interview: the Council of Nicaea with Ben Wyatt Jul 25, 2025 00:51:48 Hello everyone. The 1700th anniversary of the First Council of Nicaea is upon us, and we are pleased to present you with an interview on the subject. Ben Wyatt is an author, podcaster, and Episcopal priest, who has recently published his first book, Christ and the Council: Conflict, Politics, Theology, and the Outrageous, Extraordinary Story of the Church’s First Creed. In the course of our interv
Are Catholic Traditionalists "Jansenists"?
Are Catholic Traditionalists "Jansenists"? Jul 9, 2025 00:34:10 In the latest episode, I take a deeper look at a recent controversy. Two Catholic scholars recent wrote an article in Commonweal Magazine comparing Traditionalist Catholics--those who attend the Latin Mass--to a heresy known as "Jansenism." In this short episode, I talk about why this comparison does not hold, but is actually a polemical use of history designed to smear Traditionalists.
The Perennial Heresy: Montanism, c. 160-600 AD
The Perennial Heresy: Montanism, c. 160-600 AD May 27, 2025 00:45:40 In the late 2nd century AD, a Christian convert from Phrygia (modern Turkey) named Montanus began experiencing visions and speaking in tongues, which he believed were the Holy Spirit speaking through him. Soon he was joined by two women, Priscilla and Maximilla, who experienced the same ecstatic episodes. Montanus and his followers believed he was a prophet, called to lead Christians back to their
Church Musings: Thoughts on a New Pope
Church Musings: Thoughts on a New Pope May 9, 2025 00:29:36 With the election of Pope Leo XIV, we move into a new papal reign, and in this brief episode, I share a few thoughts about the new pontiff, the challenges he will face, and musings on the larger historical context of those challenges. Cheers!
That the Bones You Have Crushed May Rejoice: the Origins of the Cult of Relics
That the Bones You Have Crushed May Rejoice: the Origins of the Cult of Relics Apr 22, 2025 00:50:09 Our latest episode continues our discussion on the cult of the saints, but this time focusing on one of its more controversial aspects: the veneration of relics. In this episode, I talk about what the veneration of relics entails, how it emerged from the cult of the martyrs, and the evidence for its practice among early Christians. I also describe how by the sixth century, belief in the powers of
Guadalupe & the Flower World: an Interview with Joseph and Monique Gonzalez
Guadalupe & the Flower World: an Interview with Joseph and Monique Gonzalez Apr 13, 2025 00:55:35 Controversies in Church History is back! This time, I interview the husband and wife team of Joseph and Monique Gonzalez about their book, Guadalupe and the Flower World Prophecy: How God Prepared the Americas for Conversion Before the Lady Appeared. In our interview, they discuss the history and culture of the peoples of Mexico prior to the Spanish conquest, and how certain aspects of their cultu
Updates/Upcoming Episodes and Other Things
Updates/Upcoming Episodes and Other Things Apr 2, 2025 00:05:55 Hello! This is just a brief update on what's cooking for Controversies in Church History. Please take a listen, I have some good things in store for my followers. Cheers!

Recommended