Home Podcasts Supernatural Then and Now
Supernatural Then and Now

Supernatural Then and Now

Story Mill Media / Realm 210 episodes Latest Jun 1, 2026

Supernatural Then and Now is a rewatch podcast hosted by actors Rob Benedict and Richard Speight Jr., who played Chuck Shurley/God and Gabriel on the CW series Supernatural. Each week, they revisit an episode of the show with guests from the cast and crew, including stars Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles. The podcast offers behind-the-scenes insights and discussions about the series' themes of family, fate, and faith.

Episodes

Slumber Party with Todd Aronauer (S9EP4) Jun 8, 2026 3124 Producer Todd Aronauer returns to the show to talk season 9 and The Wizard of Oz. Learn what a bottle episode is, hear about shooting at the Men of Letters Bunker, and get info on the process of designing the look of the show. Rob and Rich learn about the books about Oz. www.patreon.com/spnthenandnow Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
I'm No Angel with Misha Collins (S9EP3) Jun 1, 2026 3248 Misha Collins returns to the podcast! He discusses Castiel being more human, feeling secure as a series regular on the show, and the SPN reunion on The Boys. This episode is a barrel of laughs!! Rob and Rich learn about Bartholomew. www.patreon.com/spnthenandnow Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Devil May Care with Alaina Huffman (S9EP2) May 25, 2026 3043 Alaina Huffman joins the podcast to talk all things Abbadon. She plays one bad-ass knight from hell! Hear about stunt double hands, being naked in a tub, and cool costumes. Rob and Rich learn more about the bible. Rich wants to be Abbadon. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
I Think I'm Gonna Like It Here with Tahmoh Penikett (S9EP1) May 18, 2026 3934 Tahmoh Penikett joins the podcast to talk about Ezekiel (and maybe another character). Tahmoh talks about his journey as an actor, meet fans at conventions, and Jared's influence on his performance. Rob and Rich learn about seeing things on your death bed. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
FLASHBACK to In My Time of Dying with Jensen Ackles and Jeffrey Dean Morgan (S2EP1.2) May 11, 2026 3729 Here is a flashback to season 2, episode 1. Jeffrey Dean Morgan and Jensen Ackles join Richard Speight Jr. and Rob Benedict for the launch of Season 2 of the podcast. They dive into details about In My Time of Dying. These guys respect each other so much. Hear inappropriate stories from the set and about the new matching tattoos they just got. We'll be back with Season 9 on May 18th! www.p
[REDACTED] S1E1: False Start (Part 1) May 4, 2026 1303 This is a new podcast we want to put on your radar! Introducing [REDACTED]; from Athan (The Grotto) and Jamie Petronis (The Cellar Letters) Following the death of his twin, failing actor Jacob Kane assumes his late-brother’s life in hopes of a fresh start. Instead of finding stability, Jacob finds himself working within The [REDACTED] Unit, a covert agency tasked with containing impossible creat
Season 8 Podcast Finale! Apr 27, 2026 3028 Rob, Rich, and Steve pick their 5 favorite episodes from season 8. It is an impossible task because 8 is great (and not Speight!). Jeremy Carver had a great first season as the showrunner of Supernatural. There are several iconic episodes. Which ones will make the list? Listen to find out! Subscribe on Patreon to watch the video. www.patreon.com/spnthenandnow Learn more about your ad choice
Sacrifice with Mark Sheppard (S8EP23) Apr 20, 2026 4064 Mark Sheppard (Crowley) returns to the podcast to talk about the season finale of season 8 of Supernatural. Hear about him sitting in the chair, blowback for the opening scene with Kim Rhodes, and other behind-the-scenes stories. Rob and Rich learn angels being cast from heaven. www.patreon.com/spnthenandnow Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Clip Show with Curtis Armstrong (S8EP22) Apr 13, 2026 3940 iving legend Curtis Armstrong joins the podcast for a walk through the 80s and the deep dive into Metatron. So much is covered in this conversation. Rob and Rich learn more about the Old Testament. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
The Great Escapist with Ben Edlund (S8EP21) Apr 6, 2026 3558 Ben Edlund returns to the podcast to discuss his swan song, the final episode he wrote for the show. Hear about the challenges of balancing multiple story lines, his thoughts on Sam's decline, and the appearance of Metatron. Rob and Rich learn a little something about curing demons. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Pac-Man Fever with Felicia Day (S8EP20) Mar 30, 2026 3388 It's so great to have Felicia Day back on the podcast! Her portrayal of Charlie Bradbury is an important brick in the wall of Supernatural. She discusses working with Bob Singer, the incident on set that made her leave her body, and working with Robbie Thompson. She also discusses her new book! Rob and Rick learn about dream-hacking. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Taxi Driver with Guy Norman Bee (S8EP19) Mar 23, 2026 3666 You talking to me? Director Guy Norman Bee returns to the podcast to discuss this heavy episode. Sam is making his way through the trails, and like a true hero, has gone to hell and back. Hear stories about the graffiti, creating hell, and having an episode with such a big cast. It's great to see Bobby again! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Recommended

Playing