Believing the Bizarre: Paranormal Podcast

Extraterrestrial Encounters: Vol 5 Aug 18, 2026 3988 Extraterrestrial Encounters: Vol 5 | Paranormal Podcast We're back with Extraterrestrial Encounters Volume 5,! We start with Lilli, a day-one listener from a small farming town in Ontario, who went out one night, blacked out, and woke up in the middle of a cornfield with no memory of how she got there, a story she'd been quietly filing under "weird thing that happened" for years before finally le

The Haint Aug 11, 2026 3502 The Haint | Paranormal Podcast This week, we headed down to the Lowcountry to dig into one of the South's most fascinating and frustrating paranormal entities — the haint — which depending on who you ask is a ghost, a demon, an evil spirit tied to the earth, or honestly all of the above, rooted in the rich and deeply important traditions of the Gullah Geechee people and a blend of African, Europe

Lemp Mansion Hauntings Aug 4, 2026 4142 The Haunted Lemp Mansion | Paranormal podcast This week, we dive into one of America's most genuinely tragic haunted locations — the Lemp Mansion in St. Louis — starting with a German immigrant named Adam Lemp who built a beer empire from a grocery store and a network of natural limestone caves, and tracing the family's meteoric rise through his son William turning it into a national powerhouse w

The Dodleston Messages | Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast Jul 31, 2026 7576 The Dodleston Messages | Paranormal Podcast Hey everyone! This bonus episode is an older collab we did with Kaydra on her podcast, Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast. Enjoy! Episode Description: We joined Kaydra over at Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast, for a deep dive into one of the most well-documented and genuinely bizarre cases in English paranormal history — the Dodleston Messages, where a school

The Spirits of Solace Jul 28, 2026 3463 The Spirits of Solace | Paranormal Podcast This episode, we've got two listener submissions that are a little different from the usual... no demons clawing at you, no entities trying to drag you out of bed, just some genuinely peaceful and deeply personal encounters that somehow hit harder because of it. First is Leona from California, who at 13 or 14 during one of the hardest periods of her li

The Shtriga Jul 21, 2026 4439 The Shtriga | Paranormal Podcast This episode we dove into the Shtriga, the Albanian vampiric witch who doesn't lurk in a castle or avoid the sun, but instead lives right next door, blends in at the market, and waits until you're asleep to slip into your home as a moth, a fly, or a bee and quietly drain your life force while you're too exhausted to notice something's wrong. We broke down the fu

Terrified Together with Chilluminati Podcast Jul 17, 2026 5694 Terrified Together with Chilluminati Podcast | Paranormal Podcast We teamed up with Jesse, Mike, and Alex from the Chilluminati podcast for this Terrified Together, and the five of us tackled two listener submissions that had the whole group going back and forth on where the line is between what the mind creates and what's actually out there. First up was Ash's story. Ash experienced what we be

DMT Machine Elves Jul 14, 2026 3798 DMT Machine Elves | Paranormal Podcast This week, we dove into the world of DMT and the Machine Elves, the strange interdimensional beings that thousands of people across the world, who have never met and had no reason to compare notes, keep describing in almost identical detail after taking one of the most powerful psychedelics known to exist. We broke down what DMT actually is, walked through

The Silent Watcher Jul 7, 2026 3876 The Silent Watcher | Paranormal Podcast This week, we've got 2 listener submissions that genuinely got under our skin — first from Logan in Indiana, who as a 3 or 4 year old kept waking up to a silent black humanoid figure slowly rocking in the chair across his room, and when we say silent, we mean the kind of deliberate, suffocating silence that swallowed even the sound of a child screaming for

Remembering the Bizarre - Denver Airport Conspiracy Jul 3, 2026 2534 Remembering the Bizarre - Denver Airport Conspiracy Here is a small sample of one of the segments we do over on Patreon. It's Remembering the Bizarre! In this game, Producer Ben quizzes us on OUR OWN episodes. How much do we remember? What tangents have been forgotten and random details remembered? This time, we were quizzed on our episode covering the Denver Airport Conspiracies. Enjoy! If yo

Phantom Time Conspiracy Jun 30, 2026 3716 Phantom Time Conspiracy | Paranormal Podcast We went full conspiracy mode and tackled the Phantom Time Hypothesis, the genuinely wild theory that the Holy Roman Emperor Otto III conspired with Pope Sylvester II and the Byzantine Emperor Constantine VII to fabricate nearly 300 years of history, meaning we're not actually living in 2026, but somewhere closer to 1729. We broke down the evidence pe

Bizarre News: New Alien Protocols, Disappearing Vloggers, and Brazil UFOs Jun 26, 2026 2224 June 2026 Bizarre News - Paranormal Podcast This month's Bizarre News covers four stories that somehow span the full spectrum of weird — starting with a ghost hunting vlogger in Malaysia who went live, disappeared mid-stream for 40 hours, and was eventually found in a public restroom in a weakened state with zero explanation for where he'd been. We also got into a new UN-backed protocol that no

The Imjärvi Incident Jun 23, 2026 4193 The Imjärvi Incident | Paranormal Podcast This week, we headed to January 1970 in the frozen forests of southern Finland to cover the Imjärvi UFO incident, where two experienced, credible cross-country skiers named Aarno and Esko stopped for a rest in a clearing and watched a metallic disc descend from a glowing cloud just meters above the ground, accompanied by a buzzing that wouldn't quit and a

Terrified Together with the Dark Paranormal Jun 19, 2026 5569 Terrified Together with the Dark Paranormal We teamed up with KKevin Eustace from the Dark Paranormal podcast for this Terrified Together, and the two listener submissions he brought did not disappoint, starting with Hector from Modesto, California, a lifelong skeptic who grew up without horror movies and still can't fully explain the series of connected paranormal moments that have followed him

The Hands From Under the Bed Jun 16, 2026 3056 The Hands From Under the Bed | Paranormal Podcast This week, we've got two listener submissions. First from Rebecca in Texas, who as a terrified little girl forced to watch Salem's Lot by her dad couldn't shake the vampires long enough to sleep, prayed desperately in the dark, and then had an experience in that darkness that she still remembers in perfect detail decades later. Then we got into

PURSUE UAP Files Release Jun 9, 2026 4087 Government UFO Files | Paranormal Podcast It's time to break down these government UAP files! The PURSUE UFO files are the massive declassified release from the Department of War covering over 200 previously classified UFO and UAP cases spanning 82 years, from the 1940s all the way to 2025, pulled from NASA, the FBI, the Pentagon, and beyond. We went through astronaut audio from Gemini 7 wher

Sam the Sandown Clown Jun 2, 2026 4166 The Sandown Clown | Paranormal Podcast This episode we dove into one of the strangest and most uniquely bizarre encounters in UK paranormal history, the Sandown Clown, where in May of 1973, two children on the Isle of Wight followed an unsettling wailing sound across a golf course and a marsh, only to find a seven-foot-tall, no-neck, bone-white, three-fingered entity in a yellow pointed hat livin

Bizarre News: Aliens, Demonic Sightings, and Argentina Duendes May 29, 2026 2353 Bizarre News | Paranormal Podcast This month's Bizarre News has us covering four stories that somehow all ended up connecting — starting with renowned physicist Michio Kaku going on Diary of a CEO and laying out his case that alien life almost certainly exists, UAPs are real but we're still at Close Encounters of the First Kind, and if they wanted us gone we'd already be gone, which is either ver

The Haunted Porcelain Doll May 26, 2026 3509 The Haunted Porcelain Doll | Paranormal Podcast In this episode, we've got two listener submissions that both somehow involve grandmothers handing their family members something terrifying and then acting totally unbothered about it. The first, 16-year-old Lindsay staying alone with her grieving great-grandma, grabbing a fireplace poker after hearing phantom footsteps from a kitchen that should

Terrified Together with Scaroline May 22, 2026 4793 Terrified Together with Scaroline | Paranormal Podcast We teamed up with Scaroline for this Terrified Together — she streams from the Underworld, keeps a collection of genuinely haunted dolls including one named Coco that she communicates with through a custom doll phone, and she fit in immediately. So naturally, we got into three listener submissions ranging from a 12-year-old and his dad spott

The Pale Yellow Man May 19, 2026 3180 The Pale Yellow Man | Paranormal Podcast We've got three listener submissions this episode, starting with a 13-year-old cleaning a warehouse where Bay 4 carried a heavy, wrong feeling from day one — complete with disembodied clicking sounds that circled the room like a predator, shadow legs with no body, and one final crash in the dark that sent them sprinting out and never coming back. Then we

Throwback Files: Missing 411 May 14, 2026 4424 Throwback Files: Missing 411 | Paranormal Podcast This month, we revisit the very popular Missing 411! About Missing 411 Missing-411 is the first comprehensive research about people who have disappeared in the wilds of North America. From very true crime-ish reasons to potentially paranormal explanations, we examine some of the top disappearances and give our new thoughts. 🛸 ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠

The Rules of Appalachia May 12, 2026 4809 The Rules of Appalachia | Paranormal Podcast In this episode, we went deep into the unwritten survival guide of one of the most ancient and genuinely unsettling stretches of wilderness in North America — the Rules of Appalachia — breaking down 14 laws that locals, hunters, and hikers swear by if you want to make it back out of those mountains in one piece. From never whistling after dark, to wha

Haunted Chillingham Castle May 5, 2026 4015 Chillingham Castle | Paranormal Podcast We packed our bags and headed back to England for this one — Chillingham Castle in Northumberland, which might just be the most blood-soaked, ghost-saturated piece of real estate in the entire UK, and we went deep on every brutal layer of it. Waaaay more exciting than Leap Castle (looking at you, Producer Ben)From King Edward I using it as his war headquart

Did My Toddler See a Mimic | Am I the Haunted? May 1, 2026 1155 Am I the Haunted? | Paranormal Podcast We're back with another round of Am I the Haunted, where we dig up three more Reddit confessions and hand out our completely unqualified verdicts — haunted, probs haunted, or not haunted. This episode we've got a toddler who started refusing to go to grandma's house alone because apparently grandma has a stand-in when she's out of town, someone who keeps c

The Creature in the Vanity Apr 28, 2026 2915 The Creature in the Vanity | Paranormal Podcast We've got three listener submissions this week that each hit differently — starting with a birthday trip to the Stanley Hotel where flickering lights, a disembodied little girl's giggle, and a mysterious cigar smell in the elevator made for a haunting you'd actually want to have. Then we dove into Kevin's story out of Santa Fe, where an ornate fam

Bizarre News: Chernobyl Wildlife, Missing Scientists, and Ridiculous Tattoos Apr 24, 2026 2562 Bizarre News April 2026 | Paranormal Podcast April's Bizarre News had us covering everything from the unexpected wildlife sanctuary blooming inside Chernobyl's exclusion zone, to a deeply unsettling federal investigation into 11 scientists with security clearances tied to aerospace, nuclear, and defense programs who've died or vanished under mysterious circumstances since 2022. We also got into

Terrified Together with Sinisterhood Apr 21, 2026 4261 Terrified Together with Sinistergood | Paranormal Podcast We had the absolute pleasure of welcoming Christie and Heather from the Sinisterhood podcast for this month's Terrified Together, and honestly, the four of us could have talked haunted locations, crystals, and fae pacts for about six more hours. We covered two listener-submitted stories — one from a front desk worker in Tennessee who kep

Is My Imaginary Friend a Demon | Am I the Haunted? Apr 17, 2026 1292 Am I the Haunted? | Paranormal Podcast We're back with another Am I the Haunted, where we dig through Reddit's most unsettling paranormal confessions and hand out our completely unqualified verdicts — haunted, probs haunted, or not haunted. This episode, we've got a sister who's watched a nun appear in a wardrobe while a toddler asks questions that nobody in the house can explain, a teenager wh

Owlman of Mawnan Apr 14, 2026 4416 Owlman of Mawnan | Paranormal Podcast #owlmanofmawnan This week, we took a deep dive into one of Britain's most compelling cryptid mysteries this episode: the Owlman of Mawnan, a gray-feathered, red-eyed, man-sized winged humanoid that's been terrorizing the woods near a 13th century Cornish church since the 1970s, and somehow keeps showing up specifically in front of young women. We walked thr

Throwback Files: Suicide Forest Apr 9, 2026 3472 Throwback to Aokigahara Forest (Suicide Forest) | Paranormal Podcast Welcome to another episode of the Throwback Files, where we revisit old BTB episodes. This month, we head to Japan (and 2021) to episode 41 where we covered the haunting suicide forest. Just like last time, trigger warning regarding suicide and those kind of negative thoughts. We return to Aokigahara Forest and discuss it's h

Mysterious Feral People Apr 7, 2026 3799 Feral People | Paranormal Podcast We dove deep into one of the more unsettling corners of the paranormal world this episode — feral humans — the idea that there are people living so far removed from society in places like the Appalachian Mountains and national forests that they've essentially become something else entirely. We walked through the history, the science, and the psychology behind h

Did I See a Griffin | Am I the Haunted? Apr 3, 2026 1166 Am I the Haunted | Paranormal Podcast We're back with another round of Am I the Haunted, where we dig up three more stories from the internet's paranormal confessionals and put them through our very scientific haunted, probs haunted, or not haunted scale. This episode we've got a new mom whose brother-in-law heard a very familiar voice saying something he definitely shouldn't have, a teenager

Terrified Together with BonusPac Mar 31, 2026 4533 Terrified Together with BonusPac | Paranormal Podcast We brought on BonusPac for our Terrified Together, and honestly, it might be one of the funniest episodes we've ever done — but don't let the laughs fool you, because the stories we covered were genuinely unsettling. We walked them through a Colorado family's haunting that started with a mother's deeply creepy dreams and escalated into someth

Bizarre News: Ohio Bigfoot Flap, UFO Hotspots, and Robot Gladiator Battles Mar 27, 2026 2794 Bizarre News: March 2026 | Paranormal Podcast This month's Bizarre News had us kicking things off close to home — literally — with a wild Bigfoot flap happening right in our backyard in Northeast Ohio, plus a meteorite that was loud enough to rattle windows across multiple states and had one of us genuinely wondering if the neighbor's house exploded. From there we covered dozens of sheep vanish

Skinwalker in the Woods Mar 24, 2026 3143 Skinwalker in the Woods | Paranormal Podcast This week we've got three listener submissions that genuinely had us questioning reality, starting with an 8-year-old sneaking into the chained-off section of a notoriously haunted abandoned elementary school and coming face to face with something that had absolutely no business being on all fours in that hallway. Then we heard from Nicole, a military

Did a Ghost Girl Follow Me Home | Am I the Haunted? Mar 20, 2026 1267 Am I the Haunted | Paranormal Podcast We're back with another round of Am I the Haunted — our favorite excuse to dig through Reddit's most unsettling paranormal confessions and decide whether these people are dealing with something genuinely spooky or just need a better night's sleep. This time around we had a guy who reconnected with his faith and started experiencing things in the dark that

The Haunted St. Augustine Lighthouse Mar 17, 2026 4416 Haunted St. Augustine Lighthouse | Paranormal Podcast For our 300th episode, we took a deep dive into one of America's most storied haunted locations — the St. Augustine Lighthouse in Florida, a 165-foot spiral-striped beacon that's been racking up ghost sightings, mysterious deaths, and paranormal encounters since the 1500s. We walked through centuries of wild history, from Spanish colonists a

Throwback Files: The Not Deer Mar 12, 2026 3699 Throwback Files: The Not Deer | Paranormal Podcast Welcome to another episode of the Throwback Files, where we revisit old BTB episodes. This month, we are going back to 2021 and hanging out with our favorite strange, Appalachian cryptid. Charlie even brings some new encounters into the mix! Find out if our old Believability Scale Ranking stays the same or if we now find the Not Deer more or le

Cursed Games: Vol 6 Mar 10, 2026 4847 Cursed Games: Vol 6 | Paranormal Podcast We're back with Cursed Games Volume 6, and honestly, we can't believe we're already six deep into a series that somehow keeps getting creepier — this time covering four games you almost certainly should not play. We kicked things off with Red Door Yellow Door, a hypnotic trance ritual that takes you wandering through a hallway of doors in your own mind,

My Ex's House is Out to Get Me | Am I the Haunted? Mar 6, 2026 1207 Am I the Haunted | Paranormal Podcast We're back with another installment of Am I the Haunted — our paranormal spin on the beloved Reddit format where we dig through the internet's strangest and most unsettling encounters and put them to the test. This episode had us examining three compelling submissions: a grieving family who may have captured something extraordinary in a photograph, a man wh

Extraterrestrial Encounters: Vol 4 Mar 3, 2026 3810 Extraterrestrial Encounters: Vol 4 | Paranormal Podcast We're back with Extraterrestrial Encounters Volume 4, diving into three awesome listener-submitted UFO stories. From a group of teenagers canoeing on a pond in rural Ohio who witnessed a single light transform into something far more extraordinary, to a Southern California resident who had not one but two separate close encounters with unid

Bizarre News: Victorian Ghost, AI Whale Communication, and a Slenderman Sighting Feb 27, 2026 2495 Bizarre News - February 2026 | Paranormal Podcast From a chilling ghostly photograph captured inside a 140-year-old UK theater undergoing renovation to a haunted hospice center in Norfolk that had staff so rattled they called in a priest, we covered a lot. We also dove into a viral dashcam video from a late-night driver in North England who encountered a towering, unsettling figure on the road t

Terrified Together with Ghosteas Feb 24, 2026 4255 Terrified Together with Ghosteas | Paranormal Podcast This month's Terrified Together with Ghosteas is a cozy collab full of listener-submitted paranormal stories. We kicked things off with a chilling near-death experience involving a massive stroke, a mysterious voice on the phone, and a mother's inexplicable instinct to race home just in time. Then we dove into a deeply unsettling haunted h

This Book Might Be Cursed | Am I the Haunted? Feb 20, 2026 1088 Am I the Haunted? | Paranormal Podcast In our first-ever "Am I the Haunted?" episode inspired by the popular "Am I the Asshole?" format, we read three Reddit submissions and decide whether people are experiencing genuine paranormal activity using our new scale of haunted, probably haunted, or not haunted. Our first story comes from someone who moved into a new house and feels an overwhelming an

La Llorona - The Weeping Woman Feb 17, 2026 4017 The Weeping Woman - La Llorona | Paranormal Podcast This week, we explore the Weeping Woman - La Llorona, who wanders along rivers and lakes throughout Mexico, the American Southwest, and Latin America, forever crying out for her lost children with her signature wail of "Ay, mis hijos!" We trace the possible origins of this vengeful ghost back to the 1500s in Mexico City, examining connections

Throwback Files: Fresno Nightcrawler Feb 12, 2026 2831 Throwback Files: Fresno Nightcrawler | Paranormal Podcast In this month's throwback episode, we head back to Fresno and visit Charlie's sworn enemy, the Fresno Nightcrawler. About the Fresno Nightcrawler: The Fresno Nightcrawler is a popular cryptid from folklore, known from grainy videos of strange, white, leg-like figures with no visible heads or arms, resembling "walking pants" that glide ac

Greek Gods Feb 10, 2026 4601 Greek Gods | Paranormal Podcast In this Greek gods episode timed with the Winter Olympics, we explore the fascinating world of Greek mythology starting with the origin story of the three most powerful gods—Zeus, Poseidon, and Hades—who were born to the Titan Cronus and his wife Rhea during the Golden Age, though Cronus attempted to eat all his children after a prophecy warned he'd be overthrown b

Creature Feature: Vol 6 Feb 3, 2026 4190 Creature Feature: Vol 6 | Paranormal Podcast *This is volume 6...I need you to promise me that you'll ignore all the times I say *5* in this episode* In Creature Feature Volume 6, we dive into four unsettling listener submissions, starting with Cecil from Texas, who was letting his dogs out around 10pm when he noticed something watching him over the fence—at first he thought it was his neighbor'

Bizarre News: Stolen Bones, Australian UFOs, and Human Robots Jan 30, 2026 2331 January 2026 Bizarre News | Paranormal Podcast In this month's Bizarre News, we cover four wild stories starting with the shocking case of Jonathan Gerlach from Philadelphia, who was arrested after police discovered skulls, arm and leg bones, mummified hands and feet, and two actively decomposing torsos in his possession—along with approximately 100 bodies worth of bones stored throughout his hom

Terrified Together with Red Treehouse Podcast Jan 27, 2026 3727 Terrified Together with Will Soto of the Red Treehouse Podcast In this Terrified Together collaboration with Will from the Red Tree House podcast, we explore two fascinating listener submissions, starting with Zach's UFO encounters in Colorado. Zach's first sighting occurred during late winter or early spring 2018 while stuck in bumper-to-bumper traffic on I-70, when he spotted a massive flying

The Hotel Room Portal Jan 20, 2026 3148 The Hotel Room Portal | Paranormal Podcast In this listener submission episode, we explore three unsettling paranormal encounters starting with Taylor's story from Washington state, where at age 13 she witnessed a tall, scrawny, fuzzy black figure crouching near her bedroom door in the attic—an entity so disturbing that she kept it secret for a year until her best friend saw the exact same creatu

Throwback Files: Dyatlov Pass Incident Jan 15, 2026 4205 Throwback Files: Dyatlov Pass Incident | Paranormal Podcast It's time for another throwback Thursday! On this month's Throwback Files, we revisit the very mysterious Dyatlov Pass Incident. About the Dyatlov Pass Incident In February 1959, nine experienced Soviet hikers died under mysterious circumstances in the Ural Mountains after cutting their way out of their tent and fleeing into extreme co

The Dark Web Jan 13, 2026 4517 Dark Web Stories | Paranormal Podcast This week, we dive deep into the hidden corners of the internet to explore the Dark Web—what it is, how it works, and the disturbing realities lurking beneath the surface. We begin by breaking down the structure of the internet itself, explaining how the surface web we use daily represents only 5-10% of all online content, while the deep web makes up 90-95%

The A70 UFO Incident Jan 6, 2026 2665 The A70 UFO Incident | Paranormal Podcast In our first episode of 2026, we journey to Scotland to explore the A70 incident, one of the UK's most compelling alien abduction cases. On the night of August 27, 1992, Gary Wood and Colin Wright were driving south on the A70 highway near Edinburgh. As they traveled through the small town of Bonny Bridge—an area with over 300 UFO sightings annually—Coli

The Cedar Point UFO Abduction Dec 30, 2025 4598 The Cedar Point UFO Abduction | Paranormal Podcast In this final episode of 2025, we explore two chilling listener-submitted stories that blur the line between the paranormal and extraterrestrial. Our first tale comes from Tiffany in Oklahoma, whose family experienced an unsettling encounter with a mimic entity in their crowded household. When Tiffany stepped outside with her dog one February

Bizarre News: Strange Dark Web Sales, Bermuda Mystery, and 3I Atlas Dec 26, 2025 2821 Bizarre News - December 2025 | Paranormal Podcast In this December edition of Bizarre News, we kick things off with a terrifying close-to-home story from Canton, Ohio, where an off-duty police officer working security at a Walmart experienced what could have been a fatal encounter. While booking shoplifter Shane Newton and his female accomplice in the back of the store, the officer performed on

The Disappearing Man in the Desert Dec 23, 2025 3363 The Disappearing Man in the Desert | Paranormal Podcast Our first story comes from David, who was working border patrol on a narcotics and human trafficking assignment near a river in the American Southwest. During what should have been a quiet night shift, David and his partner experienced something that would shake them both—three deliberate, hard knocks on their Humvee's driver's side window

Herb Schirmer Alien Abduction Dec 16, 2025 4408 Herb Shirmer Alien Abduction | Paranormal Podcast In this episode, we explore one of the most detailed and credible alien abduction cases from the 1960s—the extraordinary encounter of Herb Schirmer, a 22-year-old police officer in Ashland, Nebraska. On December 3, 1967, during a routine midnight patrol after wrangling an escaped bull back into its pen, Schirmer spotted flashing red lights at th

Throwback Files: The Flatwoods Monster Dec 11, 2025 2903 Happy Throwback Thursday and welcome to another installment of the Throwback Files, where we go back and revisit old episodes. This month, we are revisiting the popular Flatwoods Monster. About the Flatwoods Monster On September 12, 1952, two brothers and their friend witnessed a bright object cross the sky and land on a local farm in Flatwoods, West Virginia, prompting them to investigate the

Terrified Together with Wheezy (Noteasybeinwheezy) Dec 9, 2025 3481 In this month's Terrified Together, we welcome content creator Wheezy to discuss her journey from bored TikTok skeptic to successful multi-platform creator known for her screaming car videos, Pringles can bits, and authentic personality. We dove into two deeply unsettling listener-submitted stories that both dealt with entities appearing at life's thresholds. The first came from Anna, a health

Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 Disappearance Dec 2, 2025 4444 Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 Disappearance | Paranormal Podcast In this episode, we dive deep into one of aviation's most perplexing mysteries: the disappearance of Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370. On March 8, 2014, the Boeing 777 vanished from radar just 40 minutes after takeoff with 239 people on board, scheduled to fly from Kuala Lumpur to Beijing. We walk through the timeline of that fatef

Bizarre News: Alien Spacecraft or Comet? And Scientists Crack Warp Speed Nov 28, 2025 3958 Bizarre News - November 2025 | Paranormal Podcast In this month's Bizarre News, we bring you a collection of cutting-edge scientific discoveries and paranormal mysteries that blur the line between science fiction and reality. We kick things off with the interstellar comet 3I/Atlas, which has sparked intense debate in the scientific community after Harvard physicist Dr. Avi Loeb identified twelv

Terrified Together with Cryptid Cocktail Party Nov 25, 2025 4335 In this special Terrified Together collaboration with our friends Dave and Sarge from Cryptid Cocktail Party, we share two intense listener-submitted encounters that blur the line between tragedy and the paranormal. Our first story involves Levi's harrowing story from Wales, where a routine Costco trip turned into a real-life Final Destination moment when scaffolding from an unsecured truck pier

The Woman in White Nov 18, 2025 3248 The Woman in White | Paranormal Podcast In this listener-submitted episode, we share three unsettling paranormal encounters sent in by our audience that range from dimensional displacement to possessed dolls. We start with Sophia's story from West Virginia in 2008, when she was just 10 years old and chased her normally calm dog, Chance, across the street—only to find herself completely transpor

Throwback Files: The Mothman Nov 13, 2025 2543 Throwback Files: Mothman | Paranormal Podcast Welcome to the Throwback Files on The Mothman! This new series will allow us to explore older episodes that some of you newer listeners may not have had a chance to hear. We will include thoughts on why we chose each particular episode, along with new comments at the end of the episode. We hope you enjoy this new monthly throwback Thursday special.

Veteran Horror Stories Nov 11, 2025 2726 Veteran Horror Stories | Paranormal Podcast In this special Veterans Day episode, we honor those who serve by sharing six chilling paranormal encounters experienced by military personnel during their time in service. We explore stories from soldiers stationed across the globe, from basic training at Fort Jackson to deployments in Korea, Iraq, and Afghanistan. The episode opens with a Fort Jac

The Montauk Project Nov 4, 2025 4289 The Montauk Project | Paranormal Podcast In this episode, we dive deep into one of the most controversial conspiracy theories in paranormal history—the Montauk Project. We start by exploring the very real Camp Hero military base located on the easternmost tip of Long Island in Montauk, New York, which operated from World War II through the Cold War era. Originally disguised as a quaint fishing

Perplexing Stories: Halloween Special Oct 29, 2025 4107 To ring in 150 EPISODES, Kaydra invites some friends to the show to read some of their favorite spooky stories from the internet. Happy Halloween! This episode was produced and edited by Kaydra Brannan, the host of Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast. https://www.perplexitymysterypodcast.com/ Show Notes: Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast https://www.perplexitymysterypodcast.com/ Story: https://www.reddi

Terrified Together with Let's Get Haunted Oct 28, 2025 6496 In this special Terrified Together crossover episode, we welcome back our podcast besties Aly and Nat from Let's Get Haunted for what has become an annual October tradition. We dive into two chilling listener-submitted stories that explore the darker side of family dynamics and supernatural encounters. Follow all things Let's Get Haunted here: https://www.letsgethaunted.com/ 🛸 ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Patreon⁠⁠⁠⁠

The Haunted Sallie House Oct 21, 2025 5499 The Sallie House | Paranormal Podcast In this special Halloween live episode, we traveled to Atchison, Kansas to explore one of America's most infamous haunted houses—the Sallie House. We dive into the dark backstory dating back to 1905, when a desperate mother allegedly brought her six-year-old daughter to Dr. Charles Finney's home for emergency surgery. According to local lore, the doctor bega

The Bear Demon Oct 14, 2025 3156 The Bear Demon | Paranormal Podcast This listener submission episode starts with Katrina from Alaska, who in December 2019 made the questionable decision to attempt summoning Paimon, one of the nine kings of hell. What followed were months of unsettling experiences—shadowy creatures darting between trees, an overwhelming sense of dread, and two disturbing encounters in the woods that left her d

The Lizard Man of Scape Ore Swamp Oct 7, 2025 4422 The Lizard Man of Scape Ore Swamp | Paranormal Podcast In this episode, we dive deep into the swamps of South Carolina to explore the legendary Lizard Man of Scape Ore Swamp. We kick things off with the most famous encounter from 1988, when 17-year-old Christopher Davis was driving home from his McDonald's shift when his tire blew out near the swamp. What happened next became the stuff of local

The Voynich Manuscript Sep 30, 2025 3847 The Voynich Manuscript | Paranormal Podcast This week is all about the strange Voynich Manuscript. We explored how this mysterious 240-page medieval book, written entirely in an unknown language and filled with bizarre illustrations, has baffled scholars for over a century. From its discovery by rare book dealer Dr. Wilford M. Voynich in 1912 at a Jesuit college near Rome to its current home at Y

The Haunted Split Rock Quarry Sep 23, 2025 4135 The Haunted Split Rock Quarry This week, we dive into three unsettling listener-submitted stories. Our first tale comes from Jenna, who recounts the terrifying experiences of her three-year-old sister Sophia, who claims to see a menacing shadow man in top hat and suit watching her through windows throughout their family home. What starts as typical childhood imagination quickly escalates when

Terrified Together with Kaydra Brannan (Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast) Sep 16, 2025 3708 Our next Terrified Together is with friend of the podcast, Kaydra from Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast! During this collab, we dive into two compelling listener submissions that took us from the Mississippi countryside to New Jersey suburbs. Emma from Mississippi shared her incredible journey from being terrified of everything paranormal to becoming fascinated by it, starting with a dramatic UFO s

The Black Eye Club Sep 9, 2025 4237 The Black Eye Club | Paranormal Podcast This week, we dive deep into one of the internet's most intriguing conspiracy theories: the Black Eye Club. We explore the curious pattern of celebrities, politicians, and influential figures appearing in public with prominent black eyes - particularly on the left side - and the theories surrounding what this might mean. From George W. Bush and Jay Leno

The Smurl Family Haunting Sep 2, 2025 3164 The Smurl Family Haunting | Paranormal Podcast This week, we dive deep into one of the most documented cases of demonic oppression in modern history - the Smurl haunting. We explore how a working-class Catholic family's dream of stability turned into a 14-year nightmare when they moved into a duplex in West Pittston, Pennsylvania in 1973. What started as subtle oddities like an impossible-to-cl

Terrified Together with Kassie (Tell Me Your Ghost Story Podcast) Aug 26, 2025 3319 Our next Terrified Together is with Kassie, the awesome host of the Tell Me Your Ghost Story Podcast. Our first story comes from Mackie in Lubbock, Texas, who experienced a terrifying encounter that drained her and her boyfriend's energy for an entire week. What started as unexplained fatigue and loss of motivation escalated into a haunting night where they both witnessed a seven-foot shadow fi

The Creature that Wanted the Baby Aug 19, 2025 3181 The Creature that Wanted the Baby | Paranormal Podcast Our first story comes from Baker in West Texas, who shares an incredible tale from 1985 about his newborn son's strange sleeping patterns and unexplained nocturnal visitors. What started as puzzling midnight crying episodes soon revealed something far more extraordinary when family members began witnessing shadowy figures hovering over the b

Episodes

Recommended