Home Podcasts Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal
Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal

Choosing to Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal

Choosing To Stay After Infidelity and Betrayal 184 Episodes Oct 8, 2026

Choosing To Stay After Infidelity & Betrayal is a podcast for couples navigating the aftermath of infidelity, betrayal, and broken trust. It offers trauma-informed tools and honest conversations for both the betrayed partner and the partner who caused harm. Hosted by Hali Roderick, the show explores trust repair, emotional regulation, accountability, boundaries, and discernment. It emphasizes not rushing forgiveness or promoting a one-size-fits-all outcome, but rather grounded hope and realistic recovery paths.

Episodes

#180 Doing Recovery vs. Living Recovery: What Actually Heals a Relationship After Betrayal with Mike Tiede
#180 Doing Recovery vs. Living Recovery: What Actually Heals a Relationship After Betrayal with Mike Tiede Oct 8, 2026 00:42:19 You've done the work. So why does healing still feel like something you're performing instead of living? In this episode, Hali sits down with psychologist and partner specialist Mike Tiede to unpack the difference between doing recovery and living it — and why so many couples get stuck in the gap between the two.About Mike Tiede:Mike is a Master 's-level, Licensed Psychologist (MA, LP)
#179 - 5 Ways to Stay in Your Marriage Without Losing Yourself After Infidelity and Betrayal
#179 - 5 Ways to Stay in Your Marriage Without Losing Yourself After Infidelity and Betrayal Oct 1, 2026 00:23:41 When you're trying to heal a marriage after infidelity or betrayal, it's easy for recovery to become the center of everything.In this episode, Hali explores five ways couples can rebuild trust and emotional safety after betrayal without either partner disappearing in the process.Whether you are the betrayed partner or the partner who broke trust, healing after infidelity isn't just abo
#178 Understanding Intimacy Anorexia — with Dr. Janice Caudill, PhD
#178 Understanding Intimacy Anorexia — with Dr. Janice Caudill, PhD Sep 24, 2026 00:41:18 "Intimacy anorexia" is one of the most talked-about — and most misunderstood — terms in betrayal recovery. In this episode, I set out to understand it honestly, with one of the most credentialed voices in the field - Dr. Janice Caudill.This conversation is built for couples. Whether you're the betrayed partner or the one working to rebuild trust, we look at how intimacy breaks down,
#177 One Hour a Week Was Never Going to Be Enough
#177 One Hour a Week Was Never Going to Be Enough Sep 17, 2026 00:11:27 If you're a woman and you’re doing the work — therapy, coaching, reading everything you can get your hands on — and you're still white-knuckling it alone most days of the week, this episode is for you. I talk about why healing from betrayal trauma was never going to happen in one hour a week, including from my own experience, and about a pattern I see constantly: how much of our time, mone
#176 The Fight Under the Fight — Decoding What Betrayal Trauma Does to Your Everyday Arguments
#176 The Fight Under the Fight — Decoding What Betrayal Trauma Does to Your Everyday Arguments Sep 10, 2026 00:14:02 If you're rebuilding trust after infidelity, you've probably noticed something strange: small disagreements can escalate way faster and way bigger than the topic seems to deserve. A dish in the sink. A short text back. Being fifteen minutes late.In this episode, we talk about why that happens — and it's not because either of you is being dramatic. After betrayal, your nervous system st
#175 The Separation Plan Guide: Navigating Time Apart After Betrayal Trauma with Shawna Meek, PCC, CPC-S
#175 The Separation Plan Guide: Navigating Time Apart After Betrayal Trauma with Shawna Meek, PCC, CPC-S Sep 3, 2026 00:43:01 "Separation" doesn't have to mean divorce. In this episode, I'm joined by Shawna Meek of Living Stones Coaching to talk about the therapeutic separation — a structured, intentional time apart designed to create safety and clarity for couples navigating betrayal.Whether you're considering time apart or just trying to understand your options, this conversation offers a grounded starting point. Conne
***BONUS Choosing Different Mini Series: What I Wish I'd Done Differently with my daughters, Mataia and Morgan
***BONUS Choosing Different Mini Series: What I Wish I'd Done Differently with my daughters, Mataia and Morgan Aug 29, 2026 00:29:15 In this episode of the Choosing Different mini-series, Hali is joined by her daughters, Mataia and Morgan, for an honest conversation about betrayal trauma's impact on the whole family — not just the marriage. Hali reflects on what she believed she was doing right at the time (staying reassuring, keeping hard details between the adults) and what she's since learned she missed about how her
#174 It's Not Too Late: Healing an Affair You Thought Was Behind You
#174 It's Not Too Late: Healing an Affair You Thought Was Behind You Aug 27, 2026 00:14:56 If the betrayal in your relationship happened years ago — and life moved forward, but the deepest layers of healing never actually happened — this episode is for you.Maybe the resources weren't available at the time. Maybe neither of you had the language for what betrayal trauma actually is. Maybe you got through the facts but never did the deeper grief work. Whatever the reason, when real rep
#173 Betrayed Men: Why Their Trauma Looks Different — and What Actually Helps with Dr. Laney Knowlton
#173 Betrayed Men: Why Their Trauma Looks Different — and What Actually Helps with Dr. Laney Knowlton Aug 20, 2026 00:44:59 When we talk about betrayal trauma, the picture most people carry is of a betrayed woman. But men experience betrayal too — and their pain often goes unseen, misread as anger, or dismissed entirely. In this episode, Dr. Laney Knowlton joins us to look honestly at what betrayal trauma looks like for men.We talk about the support gap, look at the cultural messages men carry, and how those make heali
#172 Why the Right Words Aren't Enough: Embodied Empathy in Betrayal Recovery
#172 Why the Right Words Aren't Enough: Embodied Empathy in Betrayal Recovery Aug 13, 2026 00:27:06 You can say all the right words and still leave your partner feeling completely unsafe.If you're the partner who caused harm, that may be the most frustrating thing you've encountered in recovery — you apologized, you said "I understand," you told her you're here, and somehow it still landed wrong. In this episode, Hali explains why your partner isn't responding to your w
*** BONUS Choosing Different Mini Series: Three Words Every Parent Owes Their Child: "I Believe You" 
*** BONUS Choosing Different Mini Series: Three Words Every Parent Owes Their Child: "I Believe You"  Aug 8, 2026 00:20:44 What happens when a child no longer has to convince their parent that their pain was real?In this episode of Choosing Different Mini Series, Hali sits down with her daughter, Morgan Ellsworth, for a short, unscripted conversation about one of the most healing things a parent can offer: belief. They talk about the three quiet ways parents unintentionally dismiss a child's experience - through d
#171 Elements of Healthy Relationships in Recovery with Randi Gray
#171 Elements of Healthy Relationships in Recovery with Randi Gray Aug 6, 2026 00:45:15 What does a truly healthy relationship look like after infidelity and betrayal — and is it even possible to get there? In this episode, Hali sits down with Dr. Randi Gray, Licensed Professional Counselor and PhD in Psychology, to break down the real, practical elements of healthy relationships in betrayal recovery.Dr. Gray has spent 12 years specializing in pornography and sex addiction and betray

Recommended